Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Posts

Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#1

Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

I am looking for some information here that I can't seem to find in a place you might expect - like the airline! I am scheduled to do a two day demo in LaCrosse WI in April. I am going to have to fly to do this, since I do not have the luxury of time for driving out or even taking the train. I am not afraid to fly. While I have not done a lot of it, most of my flying has been in big barn like airplanes where we all wore the same clothes, and when we got where we were going, we all jumped out and ran around shouting, shooting, and throwing stuff. But things have changed a bit. The seats have gotten smaller and my seat has gotten wider since my last commercial flight in 1979.

My question is this. What is the likelihood of me fitting into a regular sized airplane seat? I do not need to be comfortable (like that would ever happen on an airplane!) but I do need to be able to physically fit into whatever chair they have for me. I really do not like the idea of having to buy two seats, although I would not mind annoying some tofu eating PETA person if I had to. The lady at the airline thought I might be better off flying out of Philly instead of Allentown since they had bigger planes, but had no objective data of any sort for me.

I have already decided to mail my tools and stuff out in a box, since I am going to have to change planes at least once, and probably twice, since you can't get there from here. I did get that much good advice from the nice lady at the airline counter (after I talked to the foreigner on the other side of the planet). So, if anyone here has some constructive info to offer, I would appreciate it.

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#2

JL

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

JL

>Try for a seat on near the wing exit door. These typically give you more leg room. As for width - business class or first class have wider seats as well as leg room.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#3

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

David Breth

>Bill -

A couple of things. This won't sound good, so sorry in advance. If you are still about the same size as you show as a man out standing in his field, I think you're just fine unless the plane is tiny. I've flown with some giants who crammed it into one seat. The arm rests lift up by the way, and as long as you share a seat with a decent person, you're good. Also, the arm rests are pretty low relative to the seat, so "soft parts" can overflow the armrest The other thing that could come into play is that they do have seatbelt extenders for people of greater carriage.

Lastly, Bill I feel terrible writing this. You're a big guy, far from a giant guy, and I hope I'm not writing things that make you self-conscious or sound like I'm being mean. In my mind you're a giant in turning, a giant of a good guy, and that's about it.

David B.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#4

Big people on planes

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Bill,

Flying commercially is one of the places that it really pays to be a small person (gloat, gloat.)

However, a few months ago, I flew one of the small airlines from Detroit to Knoxville by way of DC. On one or other of the legs, I shared a seat with a rather large woman. I'm being kind here. She outweighed you and was only about 5' tall. I really felt sorry for her, but she did fit in the seat and she didn't overly crowd me. She did have to have the seatbelt extender. My only concern was what I would have done if we went down over water. No way she could have gotten out of her seat in an emergency and no way I could have gotten across her. I'd have had to go over the seat in front of me to get out. It actually made me a little paranoid.

Anyway, ask for an aisle seat so that you aren't boxed up against the window, and make sure you can get up in a hurry if you have to. 8^]

Gary

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#5

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Carole Valentine

>Haven't seen you in person Bill, but you don't look like you are a "two-seater" to me. Can you sit in a regular dining chair with arms like you would find in restaurant...a captain's chair? If so, you shouldn't have any problem with an airline seat (unless they have drastically shrunk since the last time I flew which was quite a few years ago)

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#6

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Jim Rutten

>Finally a topic upon which I can speak with some authority given my turning muscle exeeds yours and I ride planes with some frequency. Yes most airline seats are dinky, miniscule, and just plane uncomfortable. I have often wondered why they couldn't put the chairs from the boarding area (in which I fit fine) on the airplanes! Anyway, back to the topic. First, it helps immensely flying with a loved one. My wife usually flies with me and of course gets the seat next to the other person. I try to pay her back on the rare flight that is not full by letting her sit wherever she wants. As far as the seat belt extender goes there are some airlines that I have to use them on. We found them in one of the catalogs on the plane and now have one of our own. Just looking at your picture my guess is that you will not need one, but if you do just ask one of the stewardesses. You could also try to google it. I agree with David that it is nice that the armrests go up. I have a double whammy in that I am also 6'4" so usually me knees are jammed into the seat in front of me. The exit rows help with that but be careful because some of the exit rows have solid arm rests instead of the moveable ones. Also, if you want an exit row be prepared to get to the airport around 3 hours before the flight as they go quickly.

Good luck,

Jim

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#7

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane *LINK*

Rick Allen

>Here is a good resource. Notice that Midwest tends to have wider seats.

Good luck with your trip.


Seat room by airline and equipment (airplane model

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#8

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Raymond Overman in SC

>Bill,

Being a short stumpy person myself, I just flew out to San Diego through New Jersey in the very back seat of a larger plane with two people beside me. I was in the window seat and it wasn't comfortable. They usually cram you in 6 abreast, 3 on each side. If you are flying in a smaller plane, which is what most airlines do up and down the east coast, make sure you get an aisle seat and you should be ok. Also, request the Exit Row as suggested and you'll get a little more leg room. Smaller planes are usually 3 abreast leaving one seat across the aisle. Get that one if you can.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#9

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for all the replies everyone! For the record, I am 6' 2" and 400 even. I had lost a few pounds, but people started worrying that I was sick or something, so I got them back. My nutritonist friend tells me if I got down to zero body fat I would still weigh 280, so I could lose a whole person and still be XXXL.

David, no worries, no offense. There is almost nothing that fits for me in the realm of normal human activity. Cars, clothes, shoes, hats, coats, gloves, chairs, you name it, it don't fit. Our small car is a Suburban!

Carole, I can stuff myself into those restautrant seats. I think that might be part of the problem! ;-)

Rick, thanks for the link, I will be checking it out momentarily.

I will be sure to report on my experiences, as this is a new one for me. I have done a lot of demos, as far away as IN and Toronto, but this will be the first one where I can't take my beloved truck for materiel support.

Jim and Gary and J, I will be sure to add my impressions (maybe literally!) on the seats in which I get to sit.

Bill

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#10

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Bart Leetch

>Hey Superman you'll do fine.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#11

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>I feel sorry for you Bill cause I know just what trouble your having. I'm about your size, 6 ft 8 1/2 and just a bit under 400 lbs. I try and get the reservation clerk when I make my reservation to give me the isle seat right behind the 1st class section. Then I verify it when I check in and once again at the loading dock. Sometimes it works and sometimes it dosen't. One consideration it should be a short flight. OB

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Big people on planes

Dick Hines

>I am not a small guy either Bill and when I did fly it was with a bunch of big guys,volleyball team. Try for the first row back from first class. They have a little more leg room. Also some one has already suggested the exit row seats.

I flew on a small commuter plain once. One of those little prop jobs. I had the whole back seat to my self. They are noisey but for a short flight they will do.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#13

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

ben d.

>Bill'' You may want to check expedia.com for airline tickets and buy on line since you can get a cheaper ticket there ordinarly anyway. At least you can look at all airlines, their planes, their seating and you can pick your seat before you get to the airport. Yes most airlines will let you check yourself in to the seat you want if they are available which will be shown on your computer. You will already have purchased your ticket before you arrive at the airport so all you will have to is check in and get your boarding pass that will confirm your seat reservation. If you get confused by all this drop in at a travel agent and they can do it for you. A ticket may cost a little more but peace of mind is worth something. I never go to the airline to make a reservation.

There are other sellers on-line but expedia is the one I use when I do have to fly. Their deal is pretty straight forward. Everything is priced right there so you know what you are dealing with.

Hope this helps. and have fun

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#14

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

Dinyar Chavda

>Bill:

Once you've decided what options you have re airlines, planes and flights, go to http://www.seatguru.com/index.php, and it will help you with your choice.

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#15

Steven Antonucci

@6'1" 210, I've been the small guy in the row!

steve antonucci

>I took a flight once where I was sitting next to a guy who needed two extenders. He would have referred to you (Bill) as Tiny, and conservatively, he was at least 500#'s. We had one open seat on the plane, and it was between him and me, until the drunken 6'4" 270# idiot came stumbling onto the plane.

Thankfully, it was San Jose to Las Vegas and then to Newark. He got off in Vegas, and I had some elbow room.

I'd certainly opt to fly "after hours" (i.e. not 7AM Monday) to avoid business travellers and crowded flights. It's always nice to be able to flip up an armrest and spread out (even for me at 205#).

steve

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#16

Re: Riding in an airplane - update

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Good morning all

I appreciate all the advice and direction from you folks, both here and via email. I have another alternative that is looking very good right now, and that is the train. Price is about the same, I would not have to ship my tools separately, and instead of worrying about being crammed into a flying tin can I can take my ease a private room complete with its own bed and toilet for much of the trip. The trip would take longer, but it would fulfil a longstanding desire to take a long train trip. I would be stuck in Chicago for almost six hours, but perhaps I can find something to do while I am there. Is there anything to do in Chicago? ;-)

More to come as I get it.

Bill

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#17

Re: Riding in an airplane - update

georgetroy

>I like your flying tin can term Bill, you are right on target. Good luck with your trip. GT

Re: Semi OT - Riding in an airplane

#18

Re: Riding in an airplane - update

Dinyar Chavda

>Hi Bill:

I'm not sure where the train station is, but if you can dump your luggage and et to it, the Art Institute is fabulous.