Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Flat guy with Another question

Posts

Flat guy with Another question

#1

Flat guy with Another question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi folks.

Thanks for the responses yesterday to my question(!). I know which method(s) I will try.

Here's another noob question- When creating a tenon or a taper, which is the best tool to use? Spindle gouge doesn't seem to do too well. Skew chisel? Scraper?

I have one of those cheapo Harbor Freight HSS sets which somebody here suggested as a good starter set some time ago. So that lets you know the variety I have.

Thank you.

Joe

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#2

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Joe,

For a planing cut like that on a spindle I would use a skew, but some people have troubles with a skew. You could always use a scraper I think too, but the surface might not be as clean as that left by a skew...sanding may be in order....from one flat guy to another..

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#3

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Joe

From a fat guy to a flat guy, just about any tool you have will do the job. I like a roughing gouge to do a taper if I have enough room. Properly applied, it can leave a very smooth finish. A spindle gouge will do it, but not quie as smooth. As Jim mentions, a skew will give you a great surface, but it is not the easiest tool to use. For tenons that are going to be concealed, I will often use my parting tool.

Bill

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#4

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Ron in Drums PA

>If you want a tenon and not a taper, use an open end wrench.

Sharpen the top jaw like a scraper, and ride the bottom jaw on the wood until the wrench slips into the tenon.

Now when you drill a hole, just match the size of the wrench to the drill bit and you will get a perfect fit each time.

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#5

JL

Re: Flat guy with Another question

JL

>For tenons I like to use a bedan. But that's me. If it isn't too large of a tenon, a parting tool works quite nicely (clean it up with a flat scraper).

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#6

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>If it`s along taper then why not use your block plane?Here`s where that extra money for(and time sharpening)that A2 iron pays off.

MB

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#7

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>What would the technique be if using a parting tool? A slicing cut down to the end (small end) of the taper?

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#8

JL

Re: Flat guy with Another question

JL

>For a tapered tenon, I part down just over the size that I want the large size of the taper to be and just over the size for the smaller size on that end. I have made taper blocks out of maple that are fitted to my reamers. These have been cut almost in half so they'll fit on the tenon taper when it's the right size. I use the roughing gouge to get the taper close. I then "fit" the block on the tenor taper. I "trim" the excess with the skew and sandpaper. My $0.02.

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#9

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Joe, a parting tool is a scraper, so it doesn't really slice. If you are turning a tenon that is tapered, a parting tool is not going to be a good choice, not so much because it scrapes, but because it is not really that easy to turn a tapered section with it. The tool is designed to be used in a straight in cut perpendicular to the long axis (on spindles). It makes a nice square cut, although it can leave a little bit of ragged end grain on the shoulder. If you angle it, you have to be careful of how far you part down so that you do not pass your target diameter. Of course, you could always grind the tip to an angle, but you would probably have to do a lot of the same cut to make that worthwhile.

If the tenon is straight, then it will work well most of the time. If you need a clean shoulder - i.e. one that is going to be exposed, then a better choice is a skew. You can make a pommel cut, shearing the end grain very cleanly, but it is not the easiest cut to learn, or to start out with.

Bill

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#10

Re: Flat guy with Another question

John Lucas

>Rarely do I get to disagree with Bill. Must be my lucky day. Well OK actually he's right in that most people use the parting tools as a scraper. You can however use it just like a miniature skew. I do this quie often on short tenons. I don't just hold the parting tool horizontal and push it in. I set the bevel of the tool on the wood and lift the handle until it starts cutting. I part down to the dimension I need or just a hair over. I'll do this several times to get the tenon. Then I twist the parting tool very slightly and skew it slightly so the edge is cutting like a skew and I will clean up the short tenon using this method. It's not as catchy as the skew because you have a very long bevel rubbing the wood. This is much quicker than changing tools to cut the short tenon.

I probably wouldn't do this when cutting the #2 morse taper because an inch long is a bit much to use the parting tool. When cutting the short morse taper it's not critical to have a perfect finish because when you drive it in the taper it will compress the wood. It does work better if you have a reasonably smooth shape without excessive ridges. You can usually do this with a spindle gouge or skew but a flat scraper would also work.

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#11

Are there any....

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>on-line videos anywhere showing any of these techniques?

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#12

Re: Flat guy with Another question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>John, you still don't get to disagree with me, just my wording! ;-) I use my parting tool as you describe, riding the bevel and pivoting it into the cut. I usually don't skew it though. If I have a longer tenon than the width of the tool, I part down successively several times, and then sort of drag the tool along using the one corner. It works pretty well for me.

Bill

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#13

Re: Are there any....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Joe,

Not sure about On Line videos.....but check out the Ernie Conover video, I think I remember seeing him do soming like this on Turning For Furniture..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#14

Re: Are there any....

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks Jim. I see my local library has the book of that title. I'll check it after work. Maybe I'll order the video.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#15

Re: Flat guy with Another question

John Lucas

>Bill sounds like we still do aproximately the same thing. Darn, when are you going to change.:)

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#16

Re: Are there any....

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi folks.

The other day in a thread Jim Shaver said:



Hi Joe,

Not sure about On Line videos.....but check out the Ernie Conover video, I think I remember seeing him do soming like this on Turning For Furniture..



This had to do with my questions on making Shaker pegs and so on. The thread also tailed into making the taper thingy John Lucas suggested (and supplied a picture of) that attaches to the face plate thing.

Well, I just want to let you know that I went to the library and took out the Conover book that is the campanion to the video. The book looked pretty good so I found Ernie's web site and ordered the video. It arrived the next day. I also found out Ernie lives a short 40 miles from me. Hmmm. That might be fun. Here's a thought - there are several WC folks here in Cleveland. Jeff Jewitt is about 3 or 4 miles from me, Ernie is 40 miles... that would be a great WC get together, eh? Wish I had a bigger yard...

Anyway, the book and video are/will be a huge help. I haven't had time this week to really sit and watch it. Just scimmed through it real quick. Thanks Jim for suggesting that.

John, I glued up some scrap Cherry and Ash I picked up off the floor last night and that will end up as my taper thingy. Wish I could remember what that thing is called. Oh, the Conover video also shows using this same thing. He said to turn a small ring to put over the end - instead of the hose clamp. I'll see if I can figure out a way to turn a small ring.

Maybe. Just maybe. I'll get a few minutes of shop time this weekend to play with this.

Thanks all.

Joe

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#17

Re: Are there any.... *LINK*

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>The Northcoast Woodturners meets in the Basement of the Rockler Store on Broodpark Rd. The first Saturday of each month. We have a great library and a bunch of friendly turners who will share knowledge. The doors open at 9:00 A.M. and the formal meeting starts at 9:30 A.M. The library is open from 9:00 to 9:30. Check out our website

Tom


http://ncwt.org/index.htm

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#18

Re: Are there any....

John Lucas

>Joe a wooden ring may or may not hold together very well. The short grain on 2 sides will break easy. Go to the hardware store and by a metal ring. They often have them about 1 1/2 or 2". If not there try a farm supply place. You can make your "Collet"(at least that's what I'll call it) to fit this ring. It is much safer than a hose clamp. I just use hose clamps because I have a whole box full.

Re: Flat guy with Another question

#19

Re: Are there any....

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks John. I will try to find a metal ring.

Joe