Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Face Shield or Helmet?

Posts

Face Shield or Helmet?

#1

Face Shield or Helmet?

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Curious...how many of you wear face shields, versus full helmets, such as Trend or Triton? I have been using a face shield and a Dust-Be-Gone, but have been considering the Triton. Any feelings on this?

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#2

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

albertabob

>I use the Trend/Purelite and I like mine. Had it for nearly a year now.

No hoses to tangel you up.

Bob


img

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#3

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Ralph

>I use the Trend, while the price on the Triton is great I like not having the hose and belt pack

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#4

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Fog Tanner

>After having got an Airstream, I just wish I had gotten it years ago. It is better balanced than my Powervisor and the battery lasts over twice as long. I would not consider turning without a face shield and after talking to members of the club I belong to and their experiences with exploding pieces - I would be hard pressed to go without the helmet. I also like the visor on the Airstream better than any of the other visors I have used. My sinus and lungs are much happier these days too.

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#5

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Bill Dotten

>REMEMBER THAT IF YOU ATTACH A FAN TO YOUR BELT AND A HOSE TO YOUR HELMET.....DON'T EAT BEANS

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#6

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Bill Howatt

>I previously used a face-shield and a dust mask underneath it. I bought a Triton a couple of years ago and use it 98% of the time now. (The other 2% is with the face shield, never without one or the other!)

The Triton certainly isn't as easy to put on as the face-shield but with its face-shield, hard-hat and hearing protection, I feel like I am well protected in the head area. Hearing what has happened to some members at our turning club over the years, the hard-hat seems good to have. In fact, my most serious mishap involved a piece flying off the lathe,hitting a lamp and then me on the head. However, if you don't think you are the type to be bothered with a little extra work putting it on such that you won't use it then it's not for you.

Bill

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#7

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

GeeSeaWhy

>I use a regular faceshield except when working with spalted wood, some exotics or sanding - then I switch to the Trend Airshield. I looked at both the Trend and the Triton. The Trend won because the Triton looked like too much trouble to put on.

Graeme

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#8

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Fog Tanner

>The Airstream has the battery on the belt and the fan is in the helmet, so that is not a problem.

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#9

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Stuart Johnson

>I always put on my face shield prior to turning on the lathe plus 3M half mask if sanding. Some day I would like to get a Triton but have many other things to spend my bucks on first.

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#10

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

RPE

>Here is what I use. Safe, protects, P95 filtration. No batteries to fool with and replace. Blocks not only dust, but I can't even smell lacquer. $100. You can get replacement filters at Lowes. I've never changed mine. It fits over glasses fine. It does the same job for alot less. Look around on the web for prices. I've seen them from $78 to $110. Use the $150 bucks you save to buy a Glazer gouge!.


img

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#11

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Like Bob I have used my Trend for some time and wouldn't be without it now. Heartily recommend.

Regards Peter.

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#12

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

GeeSeaWhy

>I didn't mention - I have a beard and most respirators won't seal properly over it. And I'd probably scare the kids if I shaved it off :-)

Graeme

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

#13

Re: Face Shield or Helmet?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>George, I have been using a powered respirator since 1993 or 1994, I can't remember. For the last eight years I have been using what is now the Airstream by 3M. I bought mine when it was the AH-5 by Racal. It was very expensive then, and it still is, but it has saved my lungs as well as my face on numerous occasions. It has even been called into service in some home remodeling situations, and once it got me onto a jobsite to gather some logs where a hardhat was required. I had all sorts of inquiries from the local construction workers on my space hat!

I cannot wear a regular filter like the cheapie rubber ones because of my beard, but when you take the cost of mine and amortize it over the years used, even with battery replacement, it is worthwhile. The hard part is getting the initial purchase price together. Another benefit of the powered air is that there is little to no fogging up of my glasses because of the airflow. Once you get used to having one on, it is uncomfortable to NOT wear it while turning.

Bill