Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Securing segmented turning - first time effort

Posts

Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#1

Securing segmented turning - first time effort

David Lykins - Marietta GA - guitardude

>I've got another questions on turning this segmented Urn I'm making for my roommate. This is my first attempt at turning any type of segmented piece. Things went well when I first mounted the urn on my lathe spindle plate and then applied a scrap piece of wood with double sided tape on the open end to but up againts the tailstock to stablize it. However, when I removed the urn from my lathe after I turned the outside, I noticed that the screws securing the spindle plate had loosened a tad. Since I was ready to start hollowing out the inside, I assume I needed larger and longer screws to re-mount the piece onto my lathe in order to turun it without any support from the tailstock.

So I go to Home Depot, pick up some #14 x 1-1/2" screws to mount the spindle plate onto the bottom of the urn. I drill three larger and deeper holes into the bottom of the urn (its Jatoba) and begin to mount the spindle plate. Just when I'm about to get the spindle plated secure and flat againts the bottom of the urn the head on one of the screws breaks off, then as I tighten the other one it breatks off.

OK, I'm basically done for that day as I'm frustrated and figured all I'd do now is screw it up more.

Anyway, here's how I figure I'll proceed, I'll go buy some more screws, drill new holes (and larger holes) in the bottom of the urn, and file/grind off the old screws before I mount the spindle plate.

However, my concern is, will those screws hold the urun for turning without coming loose, or am I going to some sort of support (like a steady rest) in order to turn the inside of the urn? The urn is about nine inches in diameter and bout 11 inches high. The picture shows the (only) plate that I have at this time and the size and length of the screws I had intended on using. As much as I'd like to have one, I don't have a bowl chuck, but its been on my wish list for quite a while.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks a bunch.


img

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#2

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

Bob Fawcett

>You probably need a slightly larger pilot hole. Also make sure it is deep enough for the screw. Usually when I break screws like that, there is too much torque required to set the screw. You are probably breaking them with the "twist" rather than exceeding the tensile strength of the screw. Make sure you buy the best quality screws you can find.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#3

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

Carole Valentine

>What kind of screws are you using? You are not using drywall screws are you? They break easily. I use sheet metal screws.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#4

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

David Lykins - Marietta GA - guitardude

>The Screw is Stainless Steel which is a size #14 x 1-1/2" long, like the one in the picture. I'd never use drywall screws for something like this I know they wouldn't hold up.

But my MAIN concern is, will the Stainless Steel size #14 x 1-1/2" long screws hold that urn in the lathe without using additional support? I'm concerned that the spindle plate may come loose.

Thanks

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#5

Re: Maybe I should re-phrase the question..

David Lykins - Marietta GA - guitardude

>In short, if I mount the spindle plate with the Stainless Steel #14 x 1-1/2" (long) screws, will I need additional support like a steadyrest to turn the urn, or will the screws suffice? That's my concern.

I'm aware I need to drill the pilot holes for the screws larger and all that stuff.

Sorry I didn't phrase the question correctly the first time.

Thanks

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#6

How About Brass?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi David,

I was using steel screws and , well......long story.......I really damaged a turning tool once when tool met screw.

I now use brass screws when I am doing any face plate work....just in case.. Works for me.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#7

Re: Maybe I should re-phrase the question..

Nelson

>David, more screws should solve the problem. Drill holes between existing holes and this would double the screws,more screws hold better even if they where shorter,just my experiance.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#8

Re: Maybe I should re-phrase the question..

Nelson

>PS,also sand or carve out a little on the base to make sure only the rim of face plate is touching the wood, this will keep it from "rocking", good luck.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#9

Masonry screws

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I would suggest using masonry screws. The ones I have are 3/16" x 1-1/4 and 1-3/4. I think I got them Home Depot. They are designed for power driving into holes in concrete so they are a lot stronger and thicker than standard screws.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#10

Re: Maybe I should re-phrase the question..

Steve in NC

>A couple of things that have worked well for me.

Use a coarse thread sheet metal screw. The deeper threads will hold better. Tapered wood screws will typically loose thier grip and once they get loose the taper makes it get bad quickly. Some extra holes in the faceplate will help also.

It is important to keep it all wooble out of the piece from the start. Be sure the face of the glue block is flat and all screws are tight. Sometimes I use double sided tape in addition to the screws.

Finally, at some point I would invest in a larger face plate. The extra surface area helps a bunch.

Good luck.

Steve

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#11

Yes

Ron in Drums PA

>When in doubt build stout

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#12

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

RussFairfield

>You don't need a chuck, but you do need more than 3 screws. There is nothing wrong with the faceplate, and nothing bigger than #12 sheet metal screws, but you should have at least 6 in something that size.

My opinion only. Others might have different mileage.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#13

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort *LINK*

georgetroy

>When I use face plates usually 3/4" pentration is enough. If you get a big catch: I don't care how long your screws are, you may lose the whole thing. Sheet metal screws are best, I don't use a power drill to fasten screws to wood, a pilot hole and wax works for me. You will be subject to shake, rattle and roll on a segmented bowl hung over 11". You need a captive system and a bowl steady to be safe. Larger bowls takes more resources and that is just the way it is. Showing a link with steady and captive system. GT


Captive system

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#14

Richard Allen

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

Richard Allen

>A few of things come to mind.

First it is important to mount the waste block on the faceplate and then true up the waste block. If the waste block and faceplate are off just a little you will be off by a LOT at the opening end of the urn.

Second is to use steel screws. Stainless steel is usually softer than the non stainless.

Third the screw should have deep threads with a straight shank. Sheet metal screws are good for this. There are other screws which offer a straight shank and deep threads.

Fourth your faceplate has countersunk holes. Those holes will promote screws breaking. Drill out the holes enough to take a #12 or #14 screw that has a pan head.

The other recommendations are also good.

Because this is an urn you could avoid turning the inside, except near the lip. Of course the farther you are from the headstock the greater potential for disaster. But it is easier to take light cuts when you can see what you are doing. Anyway, if you avoid turning the inside you can keep the tailstock involved. You shouldn't have any problems with the tailstock.

Good Luck

Richard

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#15

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

john lucas

>david the number of screws is the first thing I picked up on. 3 is definitly too few. I use #12 sheet metal screws. Another trick not mentioned above is to counter sink the holes very slighly on the front side of the faceplate. When you screw in a screw it tends to pull the wood out slightly. By counter sinking the holes slightly you give this wood a place to go and the wood will sit flatter on the faceplate and consequently will vibrate less. I pre drill all holes in dry wood.

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#16

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Maybe I should re-phrase the question.. *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi David

David I regular turn large bowls with just 1" total length screws, all the extra length does not do anything for you, you could screw 2 foot long screws in there and not get anymore holding than a 2" screw, case in point, if you have a screw 1" deep in solid dry wood and you would try to pull that screw out, good chance you will pull the head off before the screw comes out, so what would all the extra length do for you ??

Putting in more screws does give you more hold.

I'll put a link to an album that shows you the faceplate and screws I use on an 20+" bowl blank.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum26.html

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#17

Dave Shombert

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

Dave Shombert

>David -

Many good suggestions have been offered, particularly using more screws. I'll second that suggestion. I often turn segmented pieces this size, so I'll add a couple other thoughts from my own experience that come to mind :

(1) If you had one, a chuck wouldn't necessarily make this go any better. I have a couple of big chucks, good ones, but I almost always use a faceplate for something like this. I guess it's a little different for me since I don't use a waste block - I screw the bottom ring of the piece to the faceplate and turn the excess away when the piece is reversed. But, same principal. I'm skeptical of chucks for something like this. Getting a good grip with it is not as easy as you might think, and it can loosen without you realizing it.

(2) I know it sounds like stating the obvious - it IS stating the obvious - but it bears repeating anyway: keep the tool sharp! I think we all have a tendency to push the envelope, to want to go just a little further before we stop and go to the grinder. I know I do. But dried glue is harder on an edge than just the wood is, so the tool will need to be sharpened even more often in segmented work. The better the cut, the less torque transmitted back to the screws. Yeah, you knew that, but I find I have to remind myself all the time.

Hope this helps,

Dave Shombert

Elkins, WV

Re: Securing segmented turning - first time effort

#18

Re: BIG THANKS!

David Lykins - Marietta GA - guitardude

>Hi everybody, I took you're suggestions and re-mounted the segmented urn this morning and about an hour later I had a nice pile of shavings covering my feet and most of the rest of me. I was able to start to hollowing the inside, considering I only have a conventional set of Chinese HSS chisels things went fairly well. I think I may have to purchase one of thos teardrop shaped blades and make a chisle (just can't affort to purchase the whole thing right now) to finish hollowing out the inside.

For my first time effort, I'm fairly pleased so far with the results.

Thanks to ALL who provided their help and support.

I'll post a picture when I get it finished.

Thanks again!