Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

Posts

Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#1

Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>This issue has been raised several times. Attached is my interpretation of the minimum cutting radius situation. It should be fairly straightforward to calculate the minimum radius for a given blade width, thickness and kerf (or tooth set). I figured it out this summer, but can�t find my notes and my brain just isn�t cooperating today. Perhaps someone else could figure out the equation for the minimum radius while I try to get my brain restarted.

Note: I�ve assumed a symmetrical set on the teeth. An wider set to the left (outside) would move the pivot point towards the front of the teeth while a wider set to the right (inside) would move it back towards the middle of the blade.

I hope the picture works. This is my first attempt to post a picture and considering how much trouble I had getting a decent sketch and scan�


img

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#2

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

JKJ in East TN

>Brian,

Thanks for posting this. So the variable between blades of a given width is the set.

One other factor to consider but it may not contribute much to the geometry: a radius on the back of the blade would change the rear contact point and the effective blade width. On advice I've read in several places, I usually (if I get time!) radius the back significantly and it does seem to give a smoother cut and allows a tighter cutting radius. (Maybe failing to remove the sharp factory corners accounts for some of the difference in minimum cutting radius some people experience.)

One thing confuses me about your drawing, however. If we consider the case of an ideal blade with only teeth and zero (or very small) width, the ideal pivot point would be on a line perpendicular to the blade and through the front of the teeth, causing the direction of travel to be a vector straight ahead of the blade, right? Now if the pivot point is moved back for this ideal blade, would not the cut be less efficient? (i.e., the further back it is moved, the larger the angle between the blade and the direction of travel, forcing the teeth to cut at an angle instead of straight ahead.) If I'm thinking straight here, would moving the pivot back decrease the efficiency of the cut, regardless of the width of the blade, until you reached the point where a small turning radius forced the back of a real blade against the outside of the kerf? Until hitting that limit, however, should not the optimum pivot point still be aligned with the front of the blade? I have the feeling I'm not getting the whole picture.

Also, concerning sharpening: I may have asked this before - have you considered writing an article on sharpening bandsaw blades, especially as would interest woodturners, for cutting very thick green wood? Perhaps there is already such an article on WC but I can't remember seeing one. (I did find and save detailed instructions by Steven Russell but I think it was in a message, not a permanent article.)

(BTW, sometimes I find it easier to take a digital photo of artwork rather than go to the trouble of using my scanner)

JKJ

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#3

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

john lucas

>You guys think too much:) It hurts my head to go that far. I just put the blade on and cut. If you adjust the set on one side of the blade it might change the pivot point of the cut but wouldn't it also make it wander on a stright cut. I'm basing this on what happens to a dovetail saw when the set gets off. I assume a bandsaw blade would work the same way.

I made a circle cutting jig for my bandsaw this fall because I had to cut out 100 different size circles for the Tuba Instuctor at school. I set the pivot point at the front of the teeth. It seemed to work perfectly but then I was using a 5/16" blade and only cut circles down to 6" so this may not have been a good test of what you are talking about.

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#4

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>Rounding over the back of the blade helps in getting a smoother cut


Minimum Cutting Radius

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#5

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>John,

You nailed it with the set being a very important factor in determining the minimum cutting radius. A wider set gives a wider kerf witch gives a smaller circle.

Rounding the back of the blade helps because it moves the back corner contact point forward, effectively shortening the length of the blade slightly. This effect is more pronounced on narrower blades.

The limiting case on the small end is a blade that can turn inside its own kerf. I think they make scroll saw blades like that. But I wouldn�t want to cut a 6� thick bowl blank with that blade. Even for narrow blades, the optimum pivot point is still behind the front of the teeth. But in practical terms, the difference isn�t significant. As you mention, the blade is cutting at an angle and that reduces the efficiency of the cut, but that is true for all scenarios where you�re not cutting in a straight line. The real problem is that it makes narrow blades more susceptible to wandering due to variations in wood density (i.e. grain).

The pivot point for the minimum radius is always behind the front of the blade unless the blade has no set to the inside. However, as you move away from the minimum radius the pivot point becomes less and less important.

Perhaps a better way to visualize this problem is to draw a kerf arc and make a cut-out of a blade cross-section, and then play with them.

I was planning to post the sharpening instructions on the AAW forum with pictures. And the pictures are the hang-up. I just can�t work up have the enthusiasm to take the pictures. (For me photography is like paying taxes, I do it when I have to, not because I want to. My 35mm SLR might still have film in it; if it does, the film is at least 20 years old! My 35mm point-and-shoot does have a 6 year old roll of film in it and a dead battery. And I�ve pressed the button twice on my digital camera just to see if it works, but the pictures are still inside the camera.)

Brian, hoping my brain will eventually restart in this sub-zero weather.

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#6

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>>You guys think too much:)

LOL That's what my carpenter told me when he was building my house!

I agree that fiddling with the blade's set will make it want to drift -- good if the drift is in the direction of the circle you're cutting, bad if you're trying to cut a straight line.

You're also right that the pivot point position really only applies to cutting close to the minimum radius circles. So for most situations it's not an important factor.

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#7

Re: The problem

RussFairfield

>The problem with your picture is that there is more than a blade inside of the saw kerf in the wood. It is also filled with sawdust. The ability of the blade to clear the sawdust has more to do with determining the radius of the smallest circle than anything else. Ideally, there should be no sawdust along the sides of the blade because it has all been removed by the gullets of the teeth. It real life, there is sawdust there.

If we are cutting wet wood, we have to also allow for the fuzz that is on the sides and bottom of the cut as the blade starts to get dull. The fuzz pevvents the sawdust from being dragged out of the cut by the blade. Depending on the grain of the wood and the wear pattern of the teeth, there will be more fuzz on one side than the other, and it becomes a significat steering factor to the saw blade. And this gets worse with thicker wood and a duller blade.

In real life, the blade has to cut a circular path that is a lot straighter than what we will get from drawing a picture of a blade inside of a kerf width. I have read the same books that have told me for the past 50-years that I can cut a 5" circle (2.5"R) with a 1/2" blade; but saying that in print doesn't make it so. A 5" circle might be possible with a sharp blade in nothing thicker than 3/4" plywood. It is impossible to cut that small a circle with a 1/2" blade in thicker wood, and especially in wood that is wet. I will be lucky to cut a 7" circle in thin wet wood, and 10" would be closer to what I can do. Most of the time a 12" circle in thicker wet wood will be the limit, and if there is any wear on the blade it might be difficult to follow the line of a 14" circle in a 12" thick piece of wet wood.

Rounding the back side of the blade does little to change the geometry of the blade and kerf. What it does do is allow easier passage of the sawdust that has escaped the tooth gullet, prevent the uneven sides of the cut surface from steering the blade, and reduces friction on the back side of the blade.

Bottom line - we cut what we can with what we have, even if it doesn't agree with the theory or the books.

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#8

Totally agree

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>And it�s even worse with many of the newer blades. That�s what made me look at this in the first place.

I was trying to cut a circle under �ideal� conditions (thin, hard and dry wood with a �scary-sharp� 1/2� blade) and I wasn�t even close to the values in the tables. The bottom line is I was using a narrow kerf blade. (Reduced drag, blah, blah, blah�) What they don�t say is that it is miserable for cutting circles. And the picture showed me why. (I�m one of those people that likes to know why.)

Now I don�t even try to cut circles with a 1/2� blade.

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#9

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

JKJ in East TN

>>...I just can�t work up have the enthusiasm to take the pictures.

Perhaps a collaboration, have someone else take pictures and you write the words? If it can wait six more months, I might be interested - you could "call the shots" as they say. (If I volunteer for one more project right now, I'm sure my long-suffering wife will finally dump me after 36 years of patience!)

I think it would make a great WC article, as well as one for the magazines.

JKJ

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

#10

Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I originally had someone lined up to do the photography, but life intervened and the project has since lost momentum. But it's not dead yet and I might still be able to get something organized. Just don't hold your breath waiting.