Re: Band Saw Minimum Cutting Radius
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>John,
You nailed it with the set being a very important factor in determining the minimum cutting radius. A wider set gives a wider kerf witch gives a smaller circle.
Rounding the back of the blade helps because it moves the back corner contact point forward, effectively shortening the length of the blade slightly. This effect is more pronounced on narrower blades.
The limiting case on the small end is a blade that can turn inside its own kerf. I think they make scroll saw blades like that. But I wouldn�t want to cut a 6� thick bowl blank with that blade. Even for narrow blades, the optimum pivot point is still behind the front of the teeth. But in practical terms, the difference isn�t significant. As you mention, the blade is cutting at an angle and that reduces the efficiency of the cut, but that is true for all scenarios where you�re not cutting in a straight line. The real problem is that it makes narrow blades more susceptible to wandering due to variations in wood density (i.e. grain).
The pivot point for the minimum radius is always behind the front of the blade unless the blade has no set to the inside. However, as you move away from the minimum radius the pivot point becomes less and less important.
Perhaps a better way to visualize this problem is to draw a kerf arc and make a cut-out of a blade cross-section, and then play with them.
I was planning to post the sharpening instructions on the AAW forum with pictures. And the pictures are the hang-up. I just can�t work up have the enthusiasm to take the pictures. (For me photography is like paying taxes, I do it when I have to, not because I want to. My 35mm SLR might still have film in it; if it does, the film is at least 20 years old! My 35mm point-and-shoot does have a 6 year old roll of film in it and a dead battery. And I�ve pressed the button twice on my digital camera just to see if it works, but the pictures are still inside the camera.)
Brian, hoping my brain will eventually restart in this sub-zero weather.