Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Lidded Box-2nd Try

Posts

Lidded Box-2nd Try

#1

Lidded Box-2nd Try

Chris DiCiaccio

>Hi folks, this is my second practice try at a lidded box. Its a cut-off from a table leg on the dining room table I made some time back. Hard maple. I did better at getting the inside hollowed this time-down to a point. I drilled a 1/2" hole to start with and then used my 3/8 spindle gouge. It worked great to about halfway down. Had to stop. Guess it was too much gouge hanging over the rest. The only other tool I have for this is a 1/2" scraper which I did not try since I am not sure whether its the right tool or not and since I have never used one. So, since its just practice I left it and finished it as is. The lid was a good workout for me. Have a great day.


img

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#2

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#3

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#4

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

John Lucas

>Good job chris. I usually use a bowl gouge because it's thicker than my spindle gouges. If it really starts to chatter I have a boring bar than I use. It is 3/4" thick and doesn't chatter until it gets about 8 or 10 inches deep.

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#5

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

Chris DiCiaccio

>John, Thanks for the info. I'm just learning so I didn't know I could use a bowl gouge in end grain on a piece like this. I'll have to try it next time.

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#6

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

Eduardo sarmiento

>Well done I make a lot of boxes believeme is good and you will get better a it so just queep on making them my 2cents

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#7

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

Barry Turner

>Actually Chris that's a little deep for a second box. The deeper they are, the more difficult they are to turn. If it were me, I would try several more boxes about a third to half the depth of this one before I tried the deeper ones. You will probably find that a hollowing tool, like Sorby's multi-tip hollower, will work better at hollowing these deep boxes than either spindle gouges or scrapers. Spindle gouges and scrapers work very nicely up to about three (3") inches in depth. Nice box though. Good detail work.

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

Brad Vietje

>Nice job, Chris !

I agree with Barry that taller boxes are harder because you have to reach rather far over the tool rest. As you can tell from the replies so far, the beefier the tool, the less vibration and chatter you'll get, and the better the result.

What no one has mentioned, though, is that the 1/2" scraper is a fine tool to use for finishing off the botom of the box, though I'd recommend you work on a shorter profile while getting used to it. There are quite a few details of its use for box bottoms, so you might want to consult a good book or video on box turning methods.

Richard Raffan has a very good book and video on making boxes for additional info.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#9

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

john lucas

>chris Drill a hole first. (You don't have to but it does make it easier). The I use the bowl gouge with the flute pointing about 9:30. Start in the middle at the hole and swivel the gouge from middle out toward the edge. Your cutting with the bottom flute. The trick is to keep the top flute within a few millimeters from the wood with the bottom flute cutting. It cuts cleaner if you try to make the middle deeper than the sides so you are cutting in an arc. Cutting from the center out in an arc will be cutting downhill with the grain.

Some people cut with the flute pointing up at 12 oclock and moving the handle down so cut travels from center to 12 oclock. It all works.

I use a spindle gouge in the same way for smaller boxes.

Re: Lidded Box-2nd Try

#10

Warning ! ! !

Barry Turner

>If you are going to use the 1/2" scraper to finish the inside box bottom.........be careful, it tends to catch badly. The juncture of the bottom and box side is the worst place, because you are suddenly cutting both bottom and side. I still have a scar upside my right temple.....because nobody warned me about this...........