Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Problem With Last Night's Chat

Posts

Problem With Last Night's Chat

#1

Problem With Last Night's Chat

Stuart Johnson

>During the prior 3 chat sessions there was a consideable amount of constructive critique. The problem with last night's plate and platter sessions was all of the items submitted were so good there wasn't that much room for any improvement suggestions. I think the closest was a comment about Mac's Cherry burl bowl distracting from the wonderful platter.

I've personally learned so much from these photo chat sessions and hope we can continue in the future. They will make great training tools once we coordinate a log.

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#2

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

Ron in Drums PA

>I missed last nite's chat.

I was hoping there would be a log.

For me, these critique are a great learning tool. I working on changes on my turning from the critiques I received.

Two questions TD

- When will the next critque be scheduled and what will it be on?

- Is there anyway I can help in creating a log?

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#3

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You're right Stuart. However, there was a lot of discussion on form, curves, size of base, proportions, etc. It should have been quite informative for a lot of people. How many times do we get to do a critique on a Richard Raffan piece?

Wally

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#4

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

Carole Valentine

>Hey, Stuart

If you want some pieces submitted that are the epitome of what NOT to do, I think I can accomodate you! LOL Seriously, I learn a lot from examining the work of really good turners. I may not at first know "why" a given piece appeals to me (or not) but the discussion helps me sort all that out. I even think some of the details and form soak into my thick skull subconsciously just from looking. (Ack! Subconscious plagiarism?)

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#5

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

John Lucas

>Sorry I missed the chat. I was too distraught on not winning the Half Billion dollar lottery prize. I did have a platter that wasn't perfect enough and could have taken a lot of critic. I had to work on a problem with my Heat pump last night. It's going to be cold again this weekend.

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#6

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

RussFairfield

>There has to be a universal "Theory On The Discussion and Critique of Objects" that goes something like this.

Whenever objects are presented by members of a group for a series of discussions and critiques by the other members of that same group, the quality of the objects presented will improve with each successive session until that quality reaches a level where there is nothing to offer other than personal opinion and preferences. At that time discussion and critique become meaningless.

Last nights chat reached that level. All of them were impeccable. I had nothing to offer other than a personal opinion. I expect the work submitted for the next session, whatever the topic, to be even better.

This progression of increasing excellence happens because of our innate desire to please our peers. It happens to critiques at club meetings and it happens in the instant galleries at Symposiums. Why should we expect anything different from our Chat meeting??

Platters are difficult to discuss and critique, and even more difficult when all we have is one photograph. My personal opinion on platters is that there are only 2 kinds - those that look like something I would nail to a tree and shoot at, and those that don't. Although I have made many that look like "targets"; I prefer those that don't. Other than that, platters are like weed-pots. There are no rules, only opinions.

I also have an opinion that the bottom of a platter may be more important than what I can see from the top. Just as the outside of a bowl is important, so is the under side of a platter. Women, who are the buyers of plates and platters, always turn it over and look at the bottom, and most of the time they will do that first. If they doen't like what they see, that is as far as their interest goes. I catch myself doing the same thing. The finish of the bottom and the neatness of the signature are important. Better yet is something for them to see while they are there. There were several platters last night where it was said that there was a design or something on the bottom or a bead under the rim, but I wasn't given the opportunity to see it.

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#7

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

Lan Brady

>Russ's idea will work for several discussions. Art bottoms vs function bottoms. Bowls, vessels, and platters.

Lan

Re: Problem With Last Night's Chat

#8

It almost got by me but you are correct

T Daniel

>about the bottom being important. The often overlooked thing you mentioned is the "neatness of the signature". Many forget that the signature is also part of the art piece. We all practice everything else, why not our signature also?