Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Our first club "critique"

Posts

Our first club "critique"

#1

Our first club "critique"

Mike Schwing from Md.

>The March meeting of the Baltimore Area Turners will be focused on a critque. At present the exact agenda and process is not well defined. I have asked that anyone who is willing to have their work critiqued turn a bowl, platter, or vase form and leave any of their "signature" details off, including signature, and it was also suggested that if they are signed, blue painter's tape be used to cover the sig. Participants are requested to bring their work in a blue grocery or otherwise unidentifiable bag and drop it off on the table. At the end of the critique we will have an exchange of all submitted work for the participants.

I am thinking of putting together a slideshow of anonymous work for the form discussion portion of the presentation, preceded by a chalk talk drawing some forms on paper/mirror, followed by having 2 or 3 chosen members examining and commenting on each submitted piece, then questions, and finally passing each around. We have about an hour and a half, I think, for this whole shebang.

I would be very appreciative for any thoughts on how this might go, good or bad, and how we would improve this evening's activity. Also, if there are any transcripts of the chat room form discussions I would be most appreciative if someone would point me in their direction.

Re: Our first club "critique"

#2

some thoughts:

T Daniel

>Mike, it appears that you are trying to make this critique as impartial as possible and that is the key. No favoritism allowed. Break it down into several areas: form, surface prep, finish, material, etc. Remember, it is a turning club and that should be the main focus. Our club recently had a demo on carving and we got a lot of negative comments afterward. Many said things like: this demo was ok but one per year is enough or "that was interesting but I am not ready to go there". We have several in our turning club that also belong to a carving club. My opinion is that we need to recognise that the two arts can be combined but if they want to learn to carve they should join the carving club. I am in no way suggesting that the two not be combined, I just think a turning club should concentrate on the skills needed to produce good, high quality turnings and let the carving clubs teach the other. Some fluting is ok and other small enhancements but in my opinion the critiques should be on the turning, otherwise things will go totally beyond the purpose of a turning club.

Re: Our first club "critique"

#3

Re: Our first club "critique"

Ed Moore

>Mike,

Consider having two tables, with one for beginners. Then the one doing the critique can tailor their remarks to fit the situation.

Ed

Re: Our first club "critique"

#4

Re: Our first club "critique"

Rick Allen

>Hi Mike

This sounds great. I have been meaning to attend one of your meetings. Maybe this is the meeting I should get off my duff and attend. Could I bring one or two somethings to be critiqued?

Thanks

Richard

Re: Our first club "critique"

#5

Re: Our first club "critique"

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Richard, of course! But if you do, I'm going to ask you to be one of the 3 "critics", and would appreciate your help. We meet on the 2nd Wed of each month at 7pm, Towson, Md. Woodcraft. Let me know and I'll take the afternoon off and we can get some food or something.

Re: Our first club "critique"

#6

Re: Our first club "critique"

Chris K in MD

>We have a new webmaster that is doing a GREAT job revamping the website. You can find directions and other helpful things

www.baltimoreareaturners.org

Re: Our first club "critique"

#7

Re: Our first club "critique"

Ed Karch

>Mind if I Join you for this one? I will bring an item for the critique/exchange.