Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Stubby bearings

Posts

Stubby bearings

#1

Stubby bearings

Ed Moore

>At the same time that I moved to SW Virginia I purchased a Stubby 500, which is no longer imported into the USA. It was purchased used, with sufficient wear that I chose to replace the belt before I used it very much. Now the headstock heats up sufficiently that I am concerned that I did something wrong in the belt replacement process. It may be exactly the same as before the belt change, I simply don't know.

In the thread where George Troy gave his excellent review of the Robust lathe he just got, I asked a question to see if the Robust has any heat issues. Brent gave a great response and mentioned the heavy duty 6300 series bearings that he puts in the Robust. So my question to Brent becomes, "Is it possible/feasible to replace the Stubby bearings with the 6300 type bearing?"

My main lathe use is on a Oneway 1018. I'm getting ready to turn 14 collection plates for our new church building on the Stubby 500 and I'm a little nervous about the Stubby making it through. There's plenty of time, so I don't have to make it a full bore production situation.

So, I guess I'm also asking if Stubbys have problems with heat in the headstock bearings and if so, how big a problem is it?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Stubby bearings

#2

Re: Stubby bearings

Marvin ewing

>Join the stubbygroup at yahoo there is over 320 members go to yahoo groups then join the group called stubbygroup and ask that question good group of people

Re: Stubby bearings

#3

Re: Stubby bearings/Stubbygroup

Ed Moore

>Thanks, Marvin. That is the obvious place to ask the question, but it might be like going into the Seahawks locker room and saying "How about those refs?". And, I admit to some inertia because I don't want to learn another secret handshake. ;^D

Ed

Re: Stubby bearings

#4

Re: Stubby bearings

Jake (SoMN)

>I don't have any experience with a stubby, but when changing belts and bearings on a Conover, care had to be taken not to preload to the bearings too much. This would cause the bearing to be too tight and overheat. Also, is the belt at too high of a tension?

Jake

remove the 2 for email

Re: Stubby bearings

#5

Re: Stubby bearings

Ed Moore

>Jake,

I don't know what it means to pre-load the bearings. I have loosened the toothed locknut which applies pressure to the main bearing. It is possible that I have too much tension on the belt. I'll check.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Stubby bearings

#6

Re: Stubby bearings

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Ed

Stubbys are still imported in to the U.S. Sending you an email with his address.

Terry

Re: Stubby bearings

#7

Mr. Ed *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

Since the 500 is still made but not imported into NA, it is not supported by Bill R. You should therefore contact Rob Caddaye at Omega. He makes the things, and can give you the straight and narrow. You can e-mail Rob direct through the company wedsite at the link.

Mark


Omega-Stubby

Re: Stubby bearings

#8

Re: Mr. Ed

Ed Moore

>Thanks, Mark.

Yes, "Mr. Ed" was my nickname in 1961-62, when I was a Master at St. Andrew's School in Middletown, Delaware, where "Dead Poets Society" was filmed. Even the other Masters called me that. On Fridays I would find the verses to the song written on the chalkboard when I went to my class after lunch.

I would not expect Bill Rubenstein to support the 500 since it is well beyond any warranty considerations. I've had it almost four years and I suspect it is around twice that in age. The previous owners upgraded to a 750.

At someone's suggestion, I loosened the belt just a little this morning. It was fairly tight since I don't like belts to slip. I haven't tested it yet since I have been working on a fool-proof method of aligning grain on threaded boxes.

Thanks for the link,

Ed

Re: Stubby bearings

#9

Re: Mr. Ed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

Small pun on going straight to the horse. |;-}} [of course]

Stubby bearings warmth have come up before, and the response has been not to worry because they are designed/rated to run at up to 250* F. However, with the uncertain history of your machine, I'd still suggest you write to Rob at Omega. Heat can be caused by things other than the bearings, and Rob will be able to tell you the "how-to" and "why" better than anyone. Nice guy too.

Mark

Re: Stubby bearings

#10

Re: Stubby bearings

Jake (SoMN)

>When I mentioned pre-load I was talking about the toothed lock nut. I know you don't want the nut too loose or too tight. There is probably a recomended spec, but I tightened mine so that it didn't get the headstock hot, but eliminated play.

Sorry I can't be of more help. Sounds like you are on the right track talking to the new manufacturer.

Re: Stubby bearings

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Stubby bearings

Keith Tompkins

>Jake, it sounds like you are on the right track...while the lathe was apart, were the bearings inspected, cleaned, and packed with new grease?

The correct preload is probably going to involve the use of an inch-pound torque wrench to get a precise adjustment.

Ed when you tightened the bearings, did you really crank down on the nut to ensure it was tight, or just enough to eliminate play?

Re: Stubby bearings

#12

Re: Stubby bearings

Ed Moore

>Keith,

I didn't even realize that repacking the bearings was an option, and I'm not sure what steps are involved in that process. That was over three years ago.

I probably tightened the toothed locknut too tight originally and the belt as well. In the interim I loosened the locknut some, and now even more. The belt is not as tight, but it is still snug.

If the bearings go, I wonder if one can replace them with heavy-duty bearings, such as the 6300 series, like what Brent English uses on the Robust lathe.

Ed

Re: Stubby bearings

#13

Re: Stubby bearings

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

If you get the spec from Omega, I believe you will find that you already have "heavy duty" bearings as Omega only uses top line stuff. If you had "regreased" the bearings, it would account for the heat because greased bearings, especially over-greased ones, run significantly warmer that oil-bath bearings.

The bearing preloading parts, the retaining washer and castellated nut toward the front end of the spindle, might account for some of the warmth if over tightened, however, I'd more suspect the belt since any friction in the v-groove will warm the entire spindle and could account for what you feel.

Again, you have to "talk" to Rob Caddaye at Stubby.

M

Re: Stubby bearings

#14

Re: Stubby bearings

Ed Moore

>Thanks, Mark.

Good info. I'll have a chance to evaluate the situation better in a couple of weeks. I bought some 12/4 mahogany that is 14 inches or wider that I plan to use to make the 14 collection plates for our church. I'm going to let the wood adjust to my shop before doing more than cutting the blanks. I am considering rough-turning the plates and letting them sit for a few weeks before getting down to details. I don't want the plates moving after I final turn them. So, there will be lots of work on the Stubby then.

I'll keep an eye on belt tension. That might cause some of the heat issues.

Ed