Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Need critiques

Posts

Need critiques

#1

Need critiques

Jill

>OK here it is. My first turning of this type of form. I have been turning apx. 6 months so be gentle. Not really, I would love any critiques I can get. The piece is 5-1/2in dia X 1-1/2 inches tall made from some maple I had taking up space. I used Tung oil as my finish. Photos aren't my cup of tea but I tried to do the best I could. Happy Turning, Jill


img

Re: Need critiques

#2

Re: Need critiques-smaller pic I think 

Jill

>


img

Re: Need critiques

#3

Re: Need critiques-smaller pic I think

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Jill,

It looks pretty good! For someone turning 6 months it looks excellent. A view from the side that shows the profile would help other turners to critique your form. I think I would prefer to see curved surfaces instead of flat ones around the opening and a little more rolling over of the outside edge. That's just my 2-cent opinion. There are other people here much more qualified than I am to comment on form. Think you have graduated from the beginners level.

Tom

Re: Need critiques

#4

Re: Need critiques

john lucas

>Jill I saw it on Wow and wanted to comment but got called away. I think You've done a wonderful job. My only comment is the flat cove area. I would have liked to see this some other shape. Possibly taper the sides a little. I love how you undercut the rim.

You did a pretty good job on the photography. John

Re: Need critiques

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Need critiques

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jill...nice work! My thoughts are that there may be too many details here that compete for attention. For example, this is one of those pieces that would work with a sharp change in direction from the flat top to the bowl form. The narrow flat area between this area seems to detract a bit.

The opening is a bit busy as well, I suggest something a bit simpler, even just continuing the flat top, and a plain opening in the center or a small bead or detail.

You have chosen a tough form to execute well, and you have done a nice job of it!

Re: Need critiques

#6

Re: Need critiques

GeeSeaWhy

>You're doing very well - it took me longer than six months to produce anything like that. I wouldn't have put in the groove round the rim but as it's there, why not dress it up a bit? A string of glass beads, the same diameter as the width of the groove, would do it. And I wouldn't have left such a wide, flat top surface unless I intended to put some decoration on it - pyrography, painting or something. I would slope the top surface down towards the outside, enough to lose the narrow face you have now.

Graeme

Re: Need critiques

#7

Re: Need critiques-Thanks Keith

Jill

>Thanks Keith for your input, I appreciate your expertise. I wanted to place some epoxy in the grove of this piece but was not certain I could pull it off so I just left it as you see. I love this type of form and I am happy you gave me a nice job comment. I want to work on this form more so I guess I better get busy.

Thanks for your energy and time,

Jill

Re: Need critiques

#8

Re: Need critiques-Thanks Graeme

Jill

>Thank you for your time and energy in addressing my work. Yes, my original idea was to place cobalt blue epoxy in the grove but I have never worked with epoxy and I couldn't get it to harden. I was worried I would mess the piece up so I just left it off. However, with your comments I am certain my next piece I will give it a try. I like your suggestion of sloping the piece down. I just purchased a pyrography machine and have been practicing so maybe soon I can be brave and burn away. I admire your work and hope someday to have a fraction of your skill. PS I am on the alternate list for your class in TN.

Thank You,

Jill

Re: Need critiques

#9

Re: Need critiques-Thanks John

Jill

>Thanks John for your critique both my turning and photo. I got a long way to go with both. I am really getting to a point where I want more instruction as I have not taken any classes and I don't have a mentor. I am very excited that our turning club just made a mentor list at the last meeting so maybe soon I will have someone to drive crazy with my million questions. My original plans for the cove was blue epoxy but haven't figure the darn stuff out just yet. I love working with this form and will attempt some more forms and give a stab at embelishments in the future. I will have to sign up with you for photo classes. "-) Thanks so much for your energy and talent to wood central. Jill

Re: Need critiques

#10

Re: Need critiques-smaller pic I think

Jill

>Hi Tom, Thanks so much for your input. I do have a view from the side but my photos aren't very good so I didn't bother to boar the public with more horrible photography. Seems the flat top wasn't very appealing to most. I will try embellishing in the future. Thanks for your nice comment and time. Happy Turning, Jill