Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Am I on the right track??? re: form????

Posts

Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#1

Am I on the right track??? re: form????

kevinT in T Bay

>I'm driving myself and the rest of the family Nuts around here....Form this ,From that.... Am I on the right track? Please be up front. P.S. the segmented vase/ bowl is out of Birch, Maple, and Padauk. Its' 7" tall and 8" at the widest point. The base measures in at 3 1/4" ... Thanks Kevin T in T Bay


img

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#2

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

georgetroy

>Of course you are on the right track, just by doing. Looks good. With or without rim. GT

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

Keith Tompkins

>HI Kevin, this is a very nice piece....I like the fact that you kept the design simple. Too often segmented turners feel they need to include every technique they know in every piece they make.

Something to keep in mind: The strips that devide the padauk segments should run in the same grain orientation as the rest of the pieces, otherwise, expansion and contraction will cause the joints to open up eventually.

If I had a critique, it would be that the area containing the "beauty ring" is a bit flat, and this affects the overall form. Partially because of this, the emphasis (largest diameter of the piece)_seems to be very near on center...a piece usually appears better balanced if that point is off-center a bit. I like vessels with large openings, that's just a personal preference. The contrast between the size of the opening and the size of the foot work well in this piece; if they were the same size, the effect would be lost. The fit and finish on this piece appear to be very well executed.

This is a very well done, well thought-out piece.

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#4

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

George Van in WI

>Boy Kevin, pat yourself on the back, you are making big improvments! Looking forward to your next one.

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#5

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Gettin' there Kevin

Like your last one, you joint alignment is great and joint look tight.

Like Keith says, watch the grain alignment - you really do not want any cross grain joints longer than about 3/8 of an inch - none is better. Don't learn the hard way.

My main critiques would be - 1) on artistic pieces (vs functional) keep the foot no larger in diameter than 1/3 of the widest diameter on the bowl, 2) on most hollow forms, make the widest diameter either 1/3 (of the total height) down from the top, or 1/3 up from the bottom - most pieces don't work with the wide spot in the middle. Making the wide spot 1/3 from the bottom is hard to make work - they tend to look heavy.

Mark

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#6

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

Tom in Red Deer

>Lookin good Kevin. A HUGE difference from what you were doing last year.

Tom

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#7

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Way to Go Kevin,

I feel that you have all the right comments here from some excellent turners. Take a look at Mark Kauder's web site for some inspiration my friend. Your work continues to improve so keep pushing your limits...you are on the right track...Great to see you posting here as well.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Am I on the right track??? re: form????

#8

Thank you fellows

kevinT in T Bay

>I'm thankful for all your comments and direction that you have offerred. I'm a little overwhelmed with this whole Feedback thing. But find it very helpful. I'm still learning the terms that some folks offer. I really learn best with watching someone/ demonstrations etc.... Little hard to do, while all the wood turners hide in there closet around here.

I liked Mark's piece about starting his own club, But I do not want to teach, I want to learn. Thanks for giving me that oppurtunity here.... Cheers Kevin Turner in Thunder Bay.