P&N tools
Patrick Capobianco
>Has anyone used P&N turning tools like the bowl gouges from Lee Valley, and are they any good?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
P&N tools
Patrick Capobianco
>Has anyone used P&N turning tools like the bowl gouges from Lee Valley, and are they any good?
Re: P&N tools
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Yes, I use most of them. For HSS Gouges, they are as good as Taylor, Sorby, and the like.
Mark
I agree
Mike Cunningham (Cape May)
>I have a 5/8" supra-gouge, a 3/8" detail gouge and a recently obtained 3/16" spindle and like them all. They take and hold an edge well.
Several outlets carry them but Lee Valley seems to have the best price.
Re: P&N tools
George Van in WI
>Yes Patrick, I have several and they are as good as the others. The bowl gouges seem to be more "V" shaped than the Sorby.
Re: P&N tools
Bill Neddow
>The price is good and the steel is just as good as any of the regilar Englilsh HSS gouges like Sorby, Hamlet, etc. I have five or six of them. However -- look at the flutes carefully. Both my spindle roughing gouge and my 5/8 inch bowl gouge have flat spots on the inside of the flute, which show up on the cutting edge. The flat spot on the spindle gouge was there from the beginning and I did not notice it when I bought it. The spot on the bowl gouge did not seem to show at first, but is gradually getting worse. It is not an error in sharpening. I have spent considerable time checking that out.
Re: P&N tools
Glenn Hodges
>Patrick, I have all of the bowl gouges and their skew. I like them and use them. I like making my own handles and the tools hold an edge as well as other known brands. The roughing gouge has a much more substantial tang than others I have seen. I also buy mine from Lee Valley.
Re: P&N tools and handling
Mike Hamilton
>I bought a P&N square end scraper from the local Woodcraft (clearance IIRC). I've yet to make a tool handle and looking at this tang makes me wonder. The tang seems fairly short for the torque a scraper might experience. Any hints (epoxy, burn to fit, etc.)? I assume the skew has the same flat tang as the scraper.
Regards,
Mike Hamilton
Plainfield, IN