Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

Posts

Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#1

Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

adrien

>Query: at what point does a bowl become a vase and at what point does a vase become a hollow form? is it a bowl if the sides are convex and the top open, but a vase if the sides are concave? Does it become a hollow form when the opening gets smaller than the base?

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#2

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

John Lucas

>Adrien I've also wondered when a platter becomes a bowl. Ceramics people call hollow vessels, jars. The only thing I'm really sure of is when a bowl or hollow vessel becomes a funnel. I've got that one down pat.

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#3

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

Rick Allen

>I went to a demo that Christian Buchard gave at the Akron Symposium in 1998. He was making a sphere.

Someone asked him: "What's the difference between a ball and a sphere?"

Christian: "About a hundred dollars."

Everyone laughed and then Christian told a story about balls and spheres.

He was at a craft show selling his tunings. As part of his display Christian had a box of wooden balls he had made. The show was crowded and lots of floks were in the isles. A couple came by and the woman paused at Christian's booth. The man continued to troll the show. The woman looked up and caught her husbands attention a couple of booths down. She exclaimed in a loud voice "Hey Harry. You have to come here and see this man's balls!" From then on Christian called them spheres.

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#4

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

Ruth Niles

>I think a "bowl" is when you can use it for popcorn, candy, salad.

A "platter" is when it won't hold enough popcorn so you put crackers and cheese on it. A vase is used for flowers or weeds. It becomes a hollow form when you take the flowers out. The ceramic people have it right; plate, platter, bowl, jar, box. I think "hollow form" is used by, maybe even started by, woodturners.

I have the most difficulty explaining to people who have no idea what woodturning is, how I make a round box (without using my hands!). A box is square after all.

Have fun,

Ruth

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#5

Ric Taylor

It's In the Eye of the Artist

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#6

LOL! Me too, John!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#7

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

T Daniel

>Adrien, this is my take:

an open top piece is a bowl if the height is less than half the diameter of the piece unless it is really short which makes it a plate unless it has a large rim which makes it a platter. If the height is equal or greater than the diameter it is a vase unles it has a small diameter top which makes it a hollow form. In between the height of a bowl (half) and the height of a vase (equal to the diam) there is an aukward area where the piece doesn't qualify as a bowl because it is too tall and it is not a vase because it is too short. I avoid this height most of the time because I feel that it is confusing to the eye unless the piece is globe shaped. Generally, if you cannot tell whether a piece is a bowl or a vase you won't like it except for the globe shape I just mentioned as being the exception. There is a lot of gray area in these definitions and, to my knowledge, no definitive rules.

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#8

Good One Ruth.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#9

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

Phil Powell

>I have been a potter for 35 years! I made pots. For the past 2 years I've

been a turner. I make pots. As a potter I made clay pots, as a turner I

make wood pots. Shapes are similar, outcomes can be similar and the

discussions are almost exactly the same. Is this ART or craft? If I'm not

100% original will I be plagiarist? Make pots! Enjoy the experience! Let

the function of the pot define the pot.

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#10

Rick Allen?

W.C. Turner

>She exclaimed in a loud voice "Hey Harry. You have to come here and see this man's balls!"

ROTFL, That's a good one, Rick!!

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#11

Dick Hines

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

Dick Hines

>I am glad I read Ruth's definition before I gave mine. We were on the same track.

Re: Definition: bowl? vase? hollowform?

#12

Profound! And Ture!

RevDoug

>