Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

turning Oak spindles

Posts

turning Oak spindles

#1

turning Oak spindles

wayne

>I built an Oak grandfather clock and had to turn some spindles. I have to tell you being new at turning the Oak was a bear. How do I keep the oak from chipping out. Do you turn Oak at a slow speed or fast. I have looked for information on the web but wasn't able to find any information any help would be appreciated. I don't have a problem with other woods as of yet ha!

Wayne

Re: turning Oak spindles

#2

Re: turning Oak spindles

John Lucas

>simply use sharp tools and the proper technique. You can't scrape and get good edges and if you cut upwill with the grain you will tear off corners and get chip out. The blade should be cutting at a shearing angle rather than 90 degrees to the rotation of the work. I've turned a lot of oak spindles for chairs and I'm sure I had problems early on but I don't remember having any problems in the last 5 to 8 years or more.

Re: turning Oak spindles

#3

Re: turning Oak spindles

Ruth Niles

>John, you're a better man than I am (figuratively speaking!) if you haven't had any problems with turning dry oak spindles! Man, I hate that stuff. Almost 75% of my turning for a lot of years was spindle work mostly for antique dealers and furniture restoration. After turning about 15 spindles (all different; 1 ea. for 4 odd chairs, etc.), I took a piece of cardboard and wrote: "OAK WILL NOT BE TURNED IN THIS SHOP EVER AGAIN!" and taped it outside the door.

Wayne, the advise John gave about sharp tools and the angle is right on. It does get easier once you learn how that oak wants to be treated, namely with a light gentle touch. I usually turn the speed up to somewhere around 2200-2800 rpm and take wispy cuts rather than like you would on normal, nice, well-behaved wood.

Have fun!

Ruth

Re: turning Oak spindles

#4

Re: turning Oak spindles

John Lucas

>Ruth The only problem I've had is getting the damn chairs apart without breaking more spindles. Oak aparently gets very fragile when it is as dry as most houses. I'll be prying them apart and the tenon's just pop. I've taken to heating the wood as high as I dare before prying the joint apart. Fortunately most of the spindles I've turned were kiln dried from my local store and turn pretty well.

Re: turning Oak spindles

#5

Re: turning Oak spindles

Don Henthorn

>Whenever possible I substituted ash for oak when turning spindles. Few people can tell the difference and the turning was easier.

Re: turning Oak spindles

#6

Brad Vietje

Which Oak ?

Brad Vietje

>Wayne,

Hang in there, with sharp tools and pactice, you'll produce pieces you can be proud of. I have found that White Oak and Pin Oak were easier to turn than Red Oak, and green Red Oak (bowls in this case) seemed to have the opposite problem from most woods -- tearout in the soft side grain, especially in any sap wood.

While I tend to prefer less porous and finer grained woods, I had a restoration job a few months back reproducing a missing 4th leg and stretchers on a rare old White Oak player piano stool from about 1880. The wood turned great; my biggest problem was that the other three legs were all slightly different ! Since the original was hand-turned, and thus there were small differences between the turned parts, I had some design latitude, and I even added in a slight but intentional goof so it would look right at home.

As long as you are strict about always cutting downhill, toward the center of the spindle, and avoiding wood with curly figure, you should get good results taking light cuts as Ruth suggested.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: turning Oak spindles

#7

Re: turning Oak spindles

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Wayne

I am like Ruth. I hate turning red oak. White oak is a little better, but I charge people more when they want red oak turned. All this is to say, you are not alone. High speeds and very sharp tools will often do the job, but you may need some serious sanding from time to time. Good luck with it.

Bill

Re: turning Oak spindles

#8

Re: turning Oak spindles

wayne

>I should have noted the wood it is red oak and the problem I am having is with the beading they (most)just want to chip.

Re: turning Oak spindles

#9

Re: turning Oak spindles

john lucas

>Are you using a beading tool. That will tear the top off of beads on Oak. I use the skew but most people use a small spindle gouge. I have been experimenting with the 3 point tool and it works well but I haven't tried it on oak yet.