Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

A "different" form... and a different opinion

Posts

A "different" form... and a different opinion

#1

A "different" form... and a different opinion

RussFairfield

>All of the discussion on form in these threads and Chat Rooms is centered around shapes that we consider to be good because they are natural to us, they fit our hands, we see them in our environment, or they fit within the concepts of form that we have either learned or have become familiar with by association. We accept them without thought because they are "comfortable" forms that present no challenge to either our sensibilities or thought. They play to our natural laziness.

We see forms that are slightly outside of these parameters as being "awkward" because we can't make them fit into our perceptions of "good form". And, we are told that these are not good form by those whose opinions we respect.

But, what about those shapes and forms that are the antitheses of everything we know about what is "good". Everything about them is a challenge to our mind and senses. Do we avoid these forms because they present us with a challenge and a puzzle that needs to be solved? Do we ignore them as being too "artistic", when the reality is that we are too lazy to accept the challenge they present? Do we fall back into our confort-zone, and then wonder why all turned wood looks alike?

It seems to me that, if the impressionists and cubists had been woodturners, they would never have been because the "form police" would have prevented them, and they would never have had a following for fear of "plagiarism". It seems to me that this is exactly what we are trying to do.

How many of us have looked at something and immediately disliked it, but after some time we found that we started liking it? Could this be that our first impression was that it didn't fit into our preception of a good form, but after time we could start to see that it had its own merits.

Mark Mandell put up two pieces like this on the Chat Room last Wednesday. The immediate reaction of a lot of the folks there was they were not good form , but that opinion started to change as time passed and we spent some time looking at them. I am wondering how many would not have changed their mind had they not been forced to look at and discuss them as part of the group.

This acceptance of forms that are uncomfortable to us may be the larger lesson learned from such discussions.

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

#2

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

John Lucas

>Wonderful Russ. I was this way early on with Todd Hoyer's work and sometimes with Robyn Horn. I have since learned to really like both artist's work. Todd's pieces have a form that you have to look for. It doesn't slap you in the face. When I first saw his work in person I was bowled over. I didn't really like his work in print but live you can walk around it and start to see the structure and effort that went into the piece. In some of his earlier pieces he was angry with the world and attempted to show this in his work. I think it was quite successful but some will find it disturbing and Ugly. Art after all doesn't have to be pretty. I think a good piece of art speaks to you. It could be pretty or good form or texture that speaks to you so I won't rule out pretty and there certainly isn't anything that says art can't be good looking. Good discussion. I look forward to reading the replies

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

#5

Right link

Ron in Drums PA

>simplyturning.com/WoodCentralChat3/photos/photo11.html

simplyturning.com/WoodCentralChat3/photos/photo16.html

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

Keith Tompkins

>Believe it or not Russ, I couldn't agree more. Here is my take...education is power. The more we educate ourselves, the better equipped we are to produce successful pieces. I think that too often people want to produce wonderful art pieces without understanding the basics of their craft. Their growth is stunted, and they become frustrated by their lack of progress. I am mainly referring to beginning turners here, and a great many of wc viewers fall into that category. the study of form is a great learning tool, a starting point from which to explore and build.

I think the important thing to keep in mind is that these rules are not written in stone...a realization that these design elements really can make a difference is the important thing. I think it's good to at least have a working knowledge of design before attempting highly individualized work.

Then, if someone wants to explore their creative side, they have a better chance of creating a successful piece. I understand these rules and regulations can actually begin to stifle the imagination. Some of my pieces , including the one in the photo, were turned intentionally to break every rule I possibly could.

By suspending the hollow form, I no longer had to obey rules concerning the size of the foot, and could explore the negative spaces created in the process. I do believe a knowledge of form was helpful in spite my attempts to break the rules....as an aside, it's amazing how many turners found inspiration in these pieces...either through demos, classes, or seeing the work.

In my own personal experience, the rules were beginning to hinder my progress. My design experience in flat work often resulted in pieces that fit neatly inside the box. That is what I was paid to do. When I attempted to break free, I usually got a slap on the wrist. You are correct...the pieces were predictable and boring. When I design a turning, I have no "self imposed" limitations....I am FREE!

Like a jazz musician, study, study, and study scales, modes, theory, and then toss it!


img

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

#7

I'm feeling a little dense today

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I wasn't at the chat and now I'm trying to understand why people might complain about Mark's forms. Personally, like that shape a lot better than many of the currently popular hollow-form shapes.

What am I missing?

Re: A "different" form... and a different opinion

#8

Re: Rules

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Keith,

The local radio station had a quilter on recently who said that we have to learn the rules so that we can know how to break them intelligently.

Gary