Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Natural Edge Question

Posts

Natural Edge Question

#1

Natural Edge Question

George Van in WI

>How do you turn your Natural Edge Bowls and Vases? Turned green in one session, or rough turned and allowed to dry then returned, or?

Re: Natural Edge Question

#2

Both

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I do them both ways. Turned green and left "thick". Anchorseal the endgrain and finish turn in about 6 months, sometimes sooner. I also finish turn green in one step. When I do this, I turn rather thin, sand and apply oil. I've lost a few to both methods, most notably cherry but, most survive.

Mike

Re: Natural Edge Question

#3

Re: Both

George Van in WI

>Thanks Mike, the one I did today is maple, I was worried about the bark holding while it dried as a rough. I guess time will tell, turned 10% wall thickness and anchorsealed as a standard bowl.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#4

Re: Both

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Winter cut wood seems to retain bark best and I've rarely lost bark after turning.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#5

Re: Both

George Van in WI

>My main concern Mike is the bark shrinkage vs. wood shrinkage and the bark holding. This is winter cut. I assume the burl grain will be less likely to elongate and act more like end grain bowls.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#6

Re: Both

Phil Powell

>George,

Why worry about shrinking out of shape? No matter what you do these things

always look oval. I'm of the mind that finishing as fast as humanly possible

is best. Finishing before much shrinkage and shape changing occures. Bag the

bowl to slow the drying and on to the next! See ya!

Re: Natural Edge Question

#7

Re: Natural Edge Question

Bill Hale

>George

Keep the CA handy. I check that type of turning at least weekly as they dry. Any bark movement and hit it with CA.

Good turning and be safe.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#8

Re: Both

George Van in WI

>The shape I chose will look better if it is uniform Phil, I brought it in the basement where it should not dry too quickly at first. 55 degrees and the other recent roughs have been doing well. Are you going to make the next meeting?

Re: Natural Edge Question

#9

Re: Natural Edge Question

George Van in WI

>Thanks for the warning Bill, I have CA right by all the drying bowls and will keep an eye on this. Maybe we will run into each other at the symposium!

Re: Natural Edge Question

#10

Re: Natural Edge Question

adrien

>I'm too chicken to turn 'em thin. Besides, I like the wide bark rim, especially with locust and (just today) black oak. It's nice and gnarly. As Bill Hale noted, a little CA glue to ensure that the bark stays put is a good idea.

With evenly cut bowls, despite their being 3/4 inch thick, I've only had a few that cracked badly.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#11

Re: Natural Edge Question

George Van in WI

>Thanks Adrien, I too like some of the thicker burl rims that I have seen.

Re: Natural Edge Question

#12

Re: Natural Edge Question

adrien

>another point: there are the usual natural edge bowls of side grain, but also end grain ones. How one would differentiate them from vases, I don't know, but they can also have bark, in this case on the side, rather than the end of the edge. I find them a bit easier to turn thin, since I can pull from center to rim and don't have to desperately hunt for that wildly fluctuating irregular rim on a cut from the edge to the center. Also, the rims tend to be a bit more regular. Here's a picture of Bert Marsh's book cover:


img