Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Platter pics, comments welcome

Posts

Platter pics, comments welcome

#1

Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Here is a platter that I had planned to enter in the WC contest. I am not sure if I will try something else now that the deadline has been extended. I am considering the name "Apostrophe" for the amrosia marks that resemble such a mark. Your honest comments are welcome, I can not push to the next level without learning. Thanks for looking!

Chris


img

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#2

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Top shot


img

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#3

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Bottom View


img

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#4

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Profile view


img

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#5

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

oscar

>Very nice Chris.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#6

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>I forgot to thank you all for your help/suggestions with the photos. I think that these are much better. Special Thanks to Gerry for cming over and helping me get them just right.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#7

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Chris,

This is really a lovely piece. Each picture I opened I loved it even more. But the clincher was this last one. The profile is wonderful. This ogee shape, for me anyway, is pretty difficult to get dead on and I think you've done it here. I love the wide rim around the smaller inner bowl and the bottom is very nicely done as well. I like the round "donut" ring you've put on the foot. A very nice finishing touch.

The piece of wood isn't too shabby either. Thank you Mother Nature!

I say ....

A+!!

and a smiley face :)

Jennifer

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#8

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Jake Niedling

>Very nice shape, finish and details. Great job.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Keith Tompkins

>Excellent piece Chris. I love the precise detail on the foot, and the form is very nice indeed.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#10

It's a contender

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#11

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Molly Winton

>Absolutely beautiful platter Chris. Your choice of form is excellent, and I really like the attention you gave the foot/base. I have one question for you. I'm not sure whether it was a distortion of the camera or not, but it looks as if your rim bead has a bit of a flat on it. The transition from rim to bowl is a critical one and with such a simple design (I don't mean simple in the sense of easy, but rather simple elegance) crispness of any feature is important. Of course if it was camera distortion, this is moot. You've chosen a stunning piece of wood and shown it off beautifully. Competition will be tight.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#12

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

GaryG in MD

>Great job Chris. The profile is going into my "classic shapes" folder.

I would agree with Molly about the "bead". It looks like you did it flat on purpose (actually a groove feature in an otherwise flat top); that's fine. It is what it is. For future work, you might want to consider how it would look to you, alternately, if it were actually a rounded bead, and experiment. Just a thought.

...Gary

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#13

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Molly and Gary,

You have found it, I had some issues with the wide rim so it took a few times to sand it correctly. This was one of those times that the wave disks hurt me. It messed up the bead so I had to redo it a little, it made it more of a plateu on the op as oppesed to a perfect bead. The picture maginifes it a bit. I have since bought some regular edged sandpaper so I can sneak up on such details.

Thank you all for your comments.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Keith Tompkins

>HI Chris, I wasn't paying attention to the bead until Molly pointed it out. I would avoid power sanding anywhere near a detail such as a bead.That would prevent the problem from occurring.

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#15

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Chris K in MD

>Keith,

I tried to hand sand but after a few tries I couldnt produce a scratchless rim. I was able to do so with power sanding through abralon 4k. I went back and was able to hand sand the bead successfully but there is still the small flat on the top, to sand more would have reduced the balance of the feature.

Any ideas?

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

#16

Re: Platter pics, comments welcome

Rick Allen

>Nice platter (bowl?). The frameing of the wide rim shows off the figure very nicely.

If you made the grove deeper the bead detail would stand out a LOT more.

Sorby has a product called the "Easy Beader". I don't much care for the tool as a beading tool. But the tip of the tool is very narrow and can be used to make the depth of a grove like that a lot deeper. I would use the larger size, as that larger tool has the longest point, which keeps the bead rounding part of the tool out of the way.

You could make this same "point detail scraper" by grinding back a small scraper you might have but aren't using.