Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

WHY FORM? long

Posts

WHY FORM? long

#1

Keith Tompkins

WHY FORM? long

Keith Tompkins

>Lately here on the turning forum, the subject of form has been a hot topic. There has been much discussion, especially in the chat room on the subject. My question is WHY? Why is good form so important?

Here's my take on the subject. A well balanced, well proportioned piece posesses a quality that is lacking in a poorly executed piece...I refer to this as a dynamic quality.

A dynamic piece suggests movement....in a bowl form this could be called "lift", the piece appears to float over the surface it sits upon, rather than blend heavily into it. It may convey a sense of volume, or give the impression that the slightest breeze may topple it. On the other hand, an unbalanced, poor form would appear to be static...no or little visual impact. Where the eye smoothly follows a dynamic form, the static form appears lifeless and dull.

Consider the automobile: early autos were unreliable novelties...purely mechanical devices where form truly followed function. As the auto became more sophisticated, design elements became more and more important....designers realized that appearance mattered a great deal to customers. Long hoodlines, sleek flowing fenders and aerodynamic bodies hinted of SPEED. Cars began to look fast...even sitting still. Form no longer necessarily followed function...appearance was just as important, if not more so, than function. Autos became more than transportation, they became symbols of power and status. As turners, we can apply the same principles of design as car makers do, with pretty much the same results.

Find a turning (or any any art form) that you consider especially good...then study it. How does the height of the piece relate to the width? Where is the emphasis point? How does the foot flow to the rim? How does the size of the foot relate to the rest of the piece? What gives it a dynamic appearance? Then, begin to apply the same ideas to your own work. Again, a wonderful example of this would be a "Wally" piece. His pieces appear as though they are being filled with air pressure, and may explode or float away at any moment. Not an accident, I bet.

To me, the finish, grain pattern, texture, etc. may contribute to the success of a piece. But, the real key to success is form...if a piece I produce doesn't have the dynamic quality I'm striving for, nothing can save it. It's toast....

I would appreciate your thoughts and comments.!

Re: WHY FORM? long

#2

Re: WHY FORM? long response

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

Sorry, but I think I'm going to end up disagreeing with your basic premise.

You say that "A well balanced, well proportioned piece posesses a.... dynamic quality...(which) suggests movement."

You contend that this "dynamic quality" is the only criterion by which one evaluates the form of a piece, i.e., if the bowl does not float, it does not have form. Well, David Lancaster's bowls do not float, nor does Bill Grumbine's work--in fact very few of Bill's pieces float--instead, he goes for "gravitas". And his pieces have form oozing out of them!

Most pieces that are sculptural in nature do not float--think of the work of the Lindquists. Those turnings were stolid, heavy-looking pieces that sit firmly on the ground. But they have great form! And, forget a gentle breeze,it would take a hurricane to topple them. :-)

Another example of this "heavy" form comes from an area outside of turning, and that is Japanese gardening. If you look at a Japanese garden, there are usually rocks placed in various strategic places to symbolize mountains. In order for them to have a pleasing form, it turns out that you have to bury the rock into the ground so that 2/3rds of it is underground, and only a third shows above. Again, the aesthetic lies in the heaviness of the mass, so that it looks like it sprang out of the ground, and is buried deeply in it--- not just sitting on it.

I agree with you that "the eye smoothly follows a dynamic form". However, a piece that deliberately causes your eye to stop and drastically change direction can also be exciting.

I have to say that while I understand what you were trying to communicate with automobile fins, fenders and hoodlines, the specific example may be unfortunate, as fins, fenders and hoodlines are largely responsible for the demise of Detroit! In fact, perhaps the lesson here is that frills and frou frou on a bowl or vessel, while initially appealing, will give way to true aesthetics, even though it may take time for this to happen. Also, the maxim: "Form follows function" is what the industrial world has returned to, and that might be a good lesson to apply to certain turned objects. Going back to Lancaster's bowls, the form of his salad bowl is pleasing when held, because it is balanced in such a way that your thumb and fingers automatically go to a spot where you can easily carry it. Pleasing form appeals not just to the eye, but also to how it handles.

So, "dynamic quality" may be one way to judge whether a piece has form, but, a piece can have excellent form without having dynamic quality. There's more than one way to get to excellent form.

And that's my take on it. :-)

Dinyar

Re: WHY FORM? long

#3

Form and Function

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I�ll have to agree with Dinyar on this. I don�t have the training in design that many people bring to these discussions, so instead I�d like to offer my observations about my weed pots.

This week I made a few weed pots. The form is my interpretation of a form that is common in glass and ceramics. It�s been a long time since I last made weed pots and with the recent discussions about form, I studied my forms with a more critical eye. The most obvious thing about the form is that it was firmly anchored in the surface it was sitting on. No dynamic floating form here. And that�s exactly what I wanted for my weed pots. Think about it. A weed pot plays a supporting role � the main attraction is (or should be) what is placed in the weed pot. So I want a weed pot that fills this function, one that looks like it is capable of supporting the floral arrangement that is placed in it. The center of gravity (both visual and physical) is low, which gives it a feeling of stability. It doesn�t follow the 1/3�s rule, or the golden rectangle, or whatever you want to call it. Neither do the glass and ceramic pieces that I used for inspiration. Admittedly, I need to tweak the curves a little bit, but I�m darned close to the form I want.

Interestingly, I was looking through a book last night (�Wood Turning in North America Since 1930� published by the Wood Turning Center and Yale University Art Gallery). One of the pictures (#24) is a bud vase by Melvin Lindquist. The shape of that vase is very close to the shape of mine. So at least I�m in good company.

Re: WHY FORM? long

#4

Re: WHY FORM? long

Bill Hale

>I believe that form"" is a guide.

What you are turning, a utilitarian kitchen bowl, a highly polished decorative vase,or anything else, has to have special lines.

A bowl to be used in the kitchen is not designed the same as a decoration.

Quality is as important as form.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: WHY FORM? long

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: WHY FORM? long response

Keith Tompkins

>HI Dinyar, We don't disagree really, this is exactly the response I hoped I would get. What I strive for in my work is a sense of movement of some sort. I understand other turners or artists have other goals in mind. The point I'm trying to make is that it IS possible to explore movement, and incorporate that feeling in one's work. The japanese gardens are a good example of a different way of thinking....the tiny bit of rock emerging from the ground has its own sense of movement...what's beneath the surface is left to the imagination. Dramatic! Monolythic pieces have a whole different different quality about them, and may give a feeling of mass, weight, and may give the viewer a feeling of insignifigance. A study of architecture may lead to a wonderful series of turnings based on these concepts.

I really enjoy automobiles from the "golden age". Not only for their visual appeal, but for their technological breakthroughs. By the 1920's, dual overhead cams had appeared, as had the supercharger. Some of the most striking cars ever produced are from this era....the Bugatti family produced examples that will probably never be equalled. In fact, I spoke with a collector recently who turned down a $20 million offer for a vehicle in his collection.

The demise of the American auto really did not have much to do with styling...I believe a refusal to change in the face of growing competition and changing global conditions was the real underlying cause. When Toyota models began to appear in the early seventies, the three Detroit giants scoffed. They aren't laughing now. Old ideas die hard....when the current "gas crisis" hit, Detroit was totally unprepared. While Ford was touting the virtues of its Triton V-10, Totota and Honda had already quietly perfected hybrid technologies.

An excellent book on design has been written by Eva Zeisel, a world renowned ceramicist. The book deals with all sorts of topics, including form and design. Here is a small example: The teacup...a subject that wouldn't be of any interest to most of us...a mundane, everyday object. In the book, she compares the shape of the teacup with the shape of a coffee mug. Drinking from a mug requires one to tilt their head back in order to finish thier drink,and it will hit the bridge of your nose, while drinking from a teacup simply requires a small movement of the wrist. She's right, I tried it myself. The mug lends itself easily to mass production and shipping, while the cup does not...this analysis of form can be seen in her work. A great read if you enjoy this kind of thing.

I know Bill Grumbine does't stress the beauty and form of his work, as many of his pieces are to be used on a regular basis. Yet when I viewed and handled his work, I did not get a sense of heaviness at all, if fact his forms were quite good. Stuart Batty critiqued three of Bill's pieces at the Totally Turning symposium, with very positive comments. Sorry Bill, you're an artist after all!...whether you like it or not. :) I cannot comment on a Lancaster piece, I haven't handled one.

Pieces that have a sudden change in direction CAN be exciting, but are extremely difficult to pull off. I cannot suggest that beginning turners attempt these because they may not have the design skills to execute such a piece... and I think a majority of the information available at this site is geared to the novice. You cannot go wrong by mastering basic forms first. Here, I agree with you completely..."fins, fenders and hoodlines" (or possibly sharp changes in direction) will not add to a piece, especially if the underlying form is poor....and most likely will accentuate the problem while detracting from the appearance.

I think I'll go have a cup of tea!

Re: WHY FORM? long

#6

Re: WHY FORM? long

Chris K in MD

>Thank you Keith and Dinyar for your perspectives, I found both of your comments applicable and indentifiable. It helps me open my eyes to things as I push to learn more about form and which is good (appeasing) and bad (horid) to look at. Thank you both!

Chris

Re: WHY FORM? long

#7

Re: WHY FORM? long

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Good form is ageless. A good example is SW Indian pottery. Today's potters and woodturners strive to copy the forms which were developed and used over a period of perhaps 500 years by the ancient Anasazi and Hohokums. Those forms were functional, and yet they developed into what today are considered to be art forms. With their round bottoms and curving surfaces they are wonderful to look at. As functional pieces it's easy to see, with their closed forms, how practical they would be for carrying water or storing grain or seeds. One can imagine the competition among potters in those days, to add to the beauty of the pots with the various painted designs. A trip to the Heard Museum in Phoenix to view the hundreds of ancient pots on display is well wirth while.

We as woodturners develop our own sense of what is good form, whether it is a salad bowl by Dale Larson and sold in a gallery alongside pieces of art, or a rugged piece turned by Todd Hoyer, or a wonderfully carved piece by J. Paul Fennel. However, for most of us who sell our work, it really gets down to how the customer, who seldom knows one turners name from another, sees our work, and whether or not they'll buy it. I, along with many other turners, like to think that we're turning for ourselves, but in reality we're turning what the customer will buy. In most cases, aside from price, it sells because good form is attractive, and leads the buyer to choose one form over another.

Wally

Re: WHY FORM? long

#8

Re: WHY FORM? long

George (Oxford, NC)

>I am not a turner yet, I just took my first turning class yesterday and even the instructor mentioned "form" and such things as floating vs sitting. But, everyone is talking about form as from an 'art' viewpoint, is it art or functional? I have to think about what all the great artists of the past must have thought on the subject. I have to ask you, did Picasso actually think about what the buying community was going to think of his art (cubism, the blue period, etc) or did he simply do what looked and felt good to him? Did VanGogh or Matisse or LuTrec think of the marketability or the critics reviews when they created their masterpieces or did they do what felt right to them? I guess I'm just saying that when I get to the point, if I ever do, that I can turn out 'art quality' projects I really don't think I will worry about anything except how the piece looks to me and was it close to what I had in mind when I started it and am I happy with the results. If I want to make the vase short and squatty and I like it that way, I'll make it that way even thought it doesn't meet some magic 'golden ratio' in form. It will by 'my' style.

George

Re: WHY FORM? long

#9

Re: WHY FORM? long

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I understand and agree with your point of view. However, any artist who wants to earn his living by selling his work eventually has to turn out work that will sell. I've been selling my turnings for a little over 20 years. That amounts to many hundreds of pieces sold. I've tried many things that I liked, but that didn't sell well, so I went off to something else. I'm constantly trying new designs, and if I like what I'm doing I continue, but in the end it has to sell. I'd have a house full of turnings if they didn't.

Wally

Re: WHY FORM? long

#10

SW Indian form

Ruth Niles

>Wally, I understand what you're saying about the pure form of primitive and SW Indian pieces.

The SW Indian form is often cited as example of pure form but I don't think those Indians took a pad and discussed form. I'd bet they formed the pottery until it felt good in their hands. If you hold your hands as if you were holding a pure form, your hands would show you exactly how that form should be shaped. Of course you need a little artful vision to see it, but it's there and, I believe, that's how those primitive pieces were made.

I just read George's post below and he brought up a good point. If a piece feels good to him, what's to say that paying customers also won't find it "good form"? (not exactly what George said but close!)

I've been in 3 unrelated retail businesses in my past lives, one a jeans/t-shirt store, a fabric/quilting shop and an antique shop and now woodturning. I've learned (a few times over) that customers will buy what I don't like and not buy what I do like at times. This is/was true of all the businesses. Like you, I support myself with lathe work so I have to do what the people are happy giving me their hard-earned money for and we're both happy with the exchange.

YES, good form is essential but "good" is relative and a personal observation. Your work is all good form (seriously) because you have a good eye for form. There was a piece posted on WoW that just about everyone gave a suggestion to give it better form and I loved it just the way it was. It looked like a bag full of something. It was fat and flat on the bottom with the wrong sort of neck for a hollow form but the perfect form and neck for a bag of jelly beans! It was good form..... to me.

I do agree with you and Keith that we have to learn what is good form. But we have to learn what is our own good form, too.

I'm learning.

Ruth

Re: WHY FORM? long

#11

Re: SW Indian form

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ruth, I agree that the SW Indian forms probably developed not only for function but for how they felt when they were handled. Even in funtional pieces, salad bowls, etc., how they feel when handled is very important and I'm sure has a lot to do with how well they sell.

The perfect form is very elusive.

Wally

Re: WHY FORM? long

#12

Re: WHY FORM? long response

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Keith

You wrote:

"I know Bill Grumbine does't stress the beauty and form of his work, as many of his pieces are to be used on a regular basis."

I wouldn't agree with this as it is written. I do stress the beauty and form of my work especially since it is to be used a lot of the time! Perhaps you could clarify this a little bit here, since I don't think you meant this this way. I go to a great deal of effort to produce graceful forms and I use the prettiest wood I can find. What I do not do is burn, paint, carve, texture, or embellish in any manner, preferring to let the natural beauty of simple forms and the nature of the wood show through.

Now, if you meant that I don't go around pointing it out all the time, that that would be accurate! ;-)

Bill

Re: WHY FORM? long

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: WHY FORM? long response

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Bill, Yes, you know what I mean...to be more accurate, I should say you don't refer to yourself as an artist, or refer to your work as art. But, it is....and you are!