Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

new tool on the market

Posts

new tool on the market

#1

new tool on the market

John Lucas

>This is just a teaser, more info will come after I spend some time with the tool. John Jordan is marketing a new shear scraper. I just got it in the mail to test and this is one sweet tool. The blade is double ended and stored in the handle. You pull the blade out and swap ends to make it a right hand or left hand scraper.

I just did some brief tests this morning and took some photos. I will try to run a better test tomorrow on something larger so I can get a better feel for how long the burr holds up. Keep tuned right here on your local channel for more information.

Re: new tool on the market

#2

Re: new tool on the market

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi John,

I got one at the FL symposium. While I haven't used it much yet, I really like the design. It looks like a fine tool, and it makes a slick cut. I know John J. uses one like it for his own finishing cuts. His just has a wooden handle rather than the aluminum. He told me that so many people had asked him about his that he finally decided to make one for the turning public.

Be sure and post pics when you get a chance. I wanted to, but my camera is pretty much wasted.

By the way, Ruth has some of them for sale, or they can be gotten directly from John.

Gary

Re: new tool on the market

#3

Re: new tool on the market

David Propst

>Hey John,

I looked at the scraper on John's website. I have two questions about this tool. Does it produce a better finish than a 45 degree shear scrape with a bowl gouge? Secondly, how do you like the short handle? I find I get better flow to curves when I brace the gouge against me and use by whole body.

Jus' Wonderin'

David

Re: new tool on the market

#4

Re: Jordan scraper

Bob Elliott

>David,

If you think about what you said, "I find I get better flow to curves when I brace the gouge against me and use my whole body." The tool you just mentioned...the gouge, used for removal of wood and establishing shape / form. Use of the short handled scraper or even a bowl gouge in a shear scrape fashion is not an execise in shaping curves, you are really just removing tear out and knocking off high spots / ridges caused by a gouge.

John Jordan advocates the use of a short handled scraper and sometimes demonstrates the use of that scraper without a tool rest. The majority of his work is closed forms. I'm sure he would not attempt to use that short handled scraper on the interior of a bowl!

Re: new tool on the market

#5

Re: new tool on the market

Joe Flemig

>David,

I took a class with John several years ago and he had the homemade version back then. I went off and made one for myself. John uses the tool AFTER he uses the bowl gouge turned to 45 as a shear scraper. He takes very light cuts. He sharpens on a wheel, hones off the wheel's burr, then uses a diamond hone to raise a consistent burr across the edge.

I use mostly a gouge as previously described. I also have a longer handled scraper sharpened with two edges (left and right ) to do the same as John's tool. I tend to prefer the tool with both cutting edges on the same end because flipping John;s tool back and forth, while easy, is just one more little step that lazy people like me try to avoid. With both cutting edges on the same end, you just shift to the other edge.

I still use the Jordan tool, but not as much. I also use a burnisher to raise my burr now. For people that travel, you will find John's excellent for that.

Joe FLeming - San Diego

Re: new tool on the market

#6

Re: Jordan scraper

GaryG in MD

>Bob,

Would you expand a bit on how and when a scraper can be used without the tool rest? Scraper type and shape, woods, projects, use angles, safety factors, etc.? Thanks,

Gary

Re: new tool on the market

#7

Re: Jordan scraper

Bob Elliott

>Gary,

I'm not sure why one would use the scraper free hand, unless you are John Jordan and you do it because you can. Could be he does it to save a little time by not having to move the tool rest as he follows the shape of the hollowforms he creates.

If you scroll up, John Lucas has posted pictures of the shape / description of the scraper Jordan uses. The tool is used with the blade skewed to the work, using the "hook" created by grinding / burnishing.

As far as safety is concerned, the lathe does not run at full speed. In fact, I know of turners who use this type scraper at slow speeds.

I've seen Clay Foster use a modified cabinet scraper (card scraper) with the corners eased / rounded to prevent dig ins. He uses this tool on turnings in a free hand manner also.

You might want to contact John Jordan @ his web site, I'm sure he would be happy to answer your questions.

Re: new tool on the market

#8

Re: new tool on the market

RussFairfield

>We use a scraper without the tool-rest, and with or without the lathe running for several reasons; and we don't have to be a big name woodturner or have a special tool to do it.

We would use a scraper without the tool-rest for all of the same reasons that we would use sandpaper or a scraper on a piece of furniture - to make the lightest cut possible on the surface of the wood. We would choose the scraper because we can remove more wood faster than with sandpaper, it leaves a better finish on the wood, and there is little to no rounding of sharp corners.

Using a scraper without the tool-rest can make the lightest cut possible with a steel tool on a piece of wood. Warping in of no consequense when the lathe is running because the tool is following the wood without any restrictions from the tool-rest. It is impossible to get a "catch". Overhang beyond the tool rest is not a concern when there is no tool-rest.

If the lathe is ON, a small amount of wood can be removed around the entire piece; or a small amount of wood or torn grain can be removed from a small area when the lathe is OFF.

Lathe speed is not a factor, and it cuts equally as well whether we are passing the wood across the scraper, or the scraper across the wood.

Either a cabinet scraper, or the tool we call a scrper can be used. They are the same tool, and they cut with or without the same burr. The burr on the woodturning scraper lasts longer because its steel is harder. If the lathe is running, the woodturning scraper doesn't get as hot as fast because of its greater mass and that there is a handle to hold. It is also less likely to chatter because it is heavier.

Re: new tool on the market

#9

Russ: question

GaryG in MD

>When working with a scraper with a burr and no tool rest, do you hold it with the handle fairly high? Do you work in the lower quadrant as you would with sandpaper? ...Gary

Re: new tool on the market

#10

thanks Bob

GaryG in MD

>

Re: new tool on the market

#11

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Russ: question

Leo Van Der Loo

>In "The Craftsman Woodturner" by the late Peter Child(1986) there is a picture and description of the scraping freehand, and also the advantage of reversing the lathe and scraping freehand on the back site of the lathe, it is done below center as to your positioning.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: new tool on the market

#12

Thanks Leo

GaryG in MD

>