Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

Posts

Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#1

Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

T Daniel

>Every few months there is a debate about which is better, the Tormek or the 8" grinder with a fingernail profile jig of some sort. I have both as do quite a few others here. For a long time I swore by the Tormek because I felt that my tools lasted longer when sharpened on the Tormek and still think they do. The Tormek is a wonderful tool for sharpening scissors, kitchen knives, skews, etc but I will list some things I do not like:

1. The stone is very expensive

2. Dressing the stone with the dressing jig supplied by Tormek takes forever

3. When going from a gouge to a flat tool like a handplane blade you must dress the stone. See #1 and #2

4. With a Tormek you still need another grinder to shape the tool and for scrapers if you want a good burr edge.

5. The refined, polished edge from the Tormek may feel sharp and it may cut you more easily than an edge off the standard grinder but it has less "bite". I refer to "bite" as being similar to a serrated steak knife. there will be times when either one will cut better than the other but generally I get a better cut with the edge with some bite.

6. In summation, I feel the Tormek should be a dedicated machine for either flat tools or for gouges and it should be used as a second machine, not the primary one; otherwise you will dress away the stone in short order if you use it a lot. On the othr hand, if you only turn one day every couple of weeks then it will serve you well.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#2

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

Bill Hale

>Terry

I think if you can afford it that you need both. If you can only afford one the grinder is the way.

I do all of my shaping on the grinder and use the tormec to maintain an edge. I also grind freehand.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#3

I 100% agree with you!

James McClure

>As a matter of fact, I just bought a new 8" bench grinder and will be setting it up to use with my Ellsworth jig. Up until now, I have been using my Tormek as my primary grinder and had a crappy 6" grinder for auxillary stuff like you mentioned. The stone on my Tormek is very close to needing to be replaced so instead of buying a new stone, it is going into semi-retirement.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#4

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

John Lucas

>Terry I don't own a Tormek but have several local turners who do that I regularly help out. I agree with all of the above statements but would like to add one more. I have several tools that I grind by hand because the shape won't fit any jigs. I find it extremely difficult to sharpen by hand on the Tormek because I can't watch the sparks come over the edge.

It is a fabulous tool for sharpening plane blades and chisels and if I could afford one I'd have it in a heartbeat.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#5

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

Bill Stehman

>TD,

I loved my tormek for about a year then aquired a good slow speed 8" and installed the 54 and 100 grit oneway wheels.... my tormek gathers dust now and I like the cutting egde off the grinder better ... strange but true.

Bill

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#6

Steven Antonucci

The Tormek rebuttal:

steve antonucci

>Not Tormek owner will disagree with some of the generalities here, but there are a few inaccuracies. Firstly, I had my original stone for 4 years before I replaced it, and I turn many hours a week and "used to shape tools' on the Tormek (I now use a beltsander for speed and to preserve the wheel). When I replaced the wheel, it was still 7.5", and I replaced it simply because I wanted to, not because it needed to be.

The argument of speed and truing are bizarre in my opinion. When I am in my shop, I am not attempting to break any speed sharpening records. If it takes 10s or 30s, who really cares? I do know that the extra time spent at the Tormek is worth it to me, since I walk back to the lathe with a superior edge on my tools. I also know that my tools will last much longer, since I remove considerably less metal every time I sharpen. When you start to factor in all of the costs, it starts to become obvious that things are not what they seem.

In the time since I first bought my Tormek, I would doubt that most of my gouges have lost 1/2". The steel the "slow speed"-1725rpm wheels- sends all over the shop costs money too. And I would never attempt to grind a flat blade on a skinny little 1" wheel. Tormek wheels cost more because they are twice the width of a standard grinder wheel. And I've never seen a Tormek wheel explode.

I don't own a standard grinder. I use my belt sander to grind lawnmower belts, barstock, and the like. I'm sure there's a reason to own one, but I haven't found it yet.

Steve

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#7

Ditto

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Steve,

I agree 100%. The only exception, unlike you I have a regular grinder, a half speed that I use for rough work, reshaping edges and wire wheel stuff. Honing, etc. I do on the Tormek and love it. It does a great job on my scrapers as well.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#8

Re: Ditto

Jeff in Topsfield, Ma

>As another point of reference, today I used the Woodcraft 10% sale to pick up the Wolverine wheel truing jig. I was getting a little skip on the 1750 rpm grinder wheel that I couldn't make go away with a dresser. I would say that there was about 1/8th of an inch variation in either wheel.

So I trued the two wheels, it took me a little more that 45 minutes for both. This is about the same time it takes me to true up my Tormek if I let it get too far gone. So I would have to say that for me the maintenance time is also about equal for both systems.

So I still think that if I had to have only one I would keep the Tormek, but it is great to have both systems. For me they are complementary.

Jeff

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#9

Re: Ditto

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I true my tormek with one of those diamond sharpening "cards"...........fast.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#10

ps

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>The truing device that Tormek sells is a PIA and sits unused in a drawer.

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#11

Re: ps

Jeff in Topsfield, Ma

>That's a good idea. I have started using the tormek diamond for a last pass. I have come to use an inexpensive diamond dresser in one of the tool jigs to bring the wheel close.

You are probably aware that the diamond cards have an "arc" to them to aid in honing. I think it is around 0.004 inches. this could be throwing your stone off! ;)

Re: Tormek vs 8" grinder with Wolverine

#12

Aha

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Thanks Jeff, that 0.004 explains it! ;^)