Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Burl Harvest Question

Posts

Burl Harvest Question

#1

Burl Harvest Question

Gary Ratajczak

>Anyone with experience, I need a recommendation. If properly coated with pruning spray, would a healthy tree be damaged by removing a burl. Nothing large - maybe 6 to 8 inch diameter.

Trees are maple and cherry.

Thanks for the input.

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#2

Steven Antonucci

Not the answer you're looking for...

steve antonucci

>but anytime you cut into a tree, the answer is maybe. Some folks might tell you that you can do it safely (which is probably true), but I think it also depends upon the size of the tree relative to the burl. If it's a 12" burl on a 15" tree, leave it alone. If it's a 12" burl on a 5' tree, it can probably be taken without damaging the tree IF DONE CORRECTLY.

My personal opinion is that I will never cut a tree "just for the wood"- since there is so much downed timber available in my area. Once the tree is on the ground, I'm the first one there with a chainsaw.

Steve

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#3

Re: Burl Harvest Question

Bill Hale

>Gary

The removal of any burl is like the removal of a tumor on a human.

If the tree is large and the burl in on a med size branch there should be no problem. All is relative to size of each.

If the tree loses its leaves ( hardwood ), do the removal in the winter and seal the wound. Make a nice clean cut and do it the proper way. Do an undercut so when the branch breakes that it does not strip the bark down the side of the tree.

One point to remember, as I have read, is that a very high percentage of burls are not usable.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Burl Harvest Question

Dick Hines

>If the burl is on a branch cut away. If it's on the trunk just look and think of what could have been.

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: Burl Harvest Question

Ric Taylor

>Although pruning spray used to be very popular and commonly used when removing branches and other trimming, everything I've read in the past few years and everything I've seen on gardening shows the past few years says that pruning sprays have no value at all.

Ric

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#6

Re: Wound Dressing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Arborist here uses 3lb dewaxed shellac for through-the-cambium injuries to prevent moisture loss while the tree heals. Specifically un deer-rub and on pruning cuts over over 2" in diameter. Uses the dewaxed shellac because he says the resin's broken down and absorbed by the tree as it recovers the injury.

3rd-party info, but . . .

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#7

Think of what will be.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Someday that tree will be old and gray and die of natural causes. By that time the burls could be huge and you might still be physically able to make use of them.

Like Steve, I don't like the idea of damaging a healthy tree just for the wood or the burl. Whether we want to acknowledge it or not, trees are living creatures. Ask yourself whether you would want to take a chance on opening up a 6" diameter hole in your own side? Anytime you break the bark on a living tree, you are allowing the opportunity for the introduction of insects or disease.

Gary

Re: Burl Harvest Question

#8

Re: Wound Dressing

JimQ

>When I was doing tree work back in NJ (30+ years ago) I used to wash pruning cuts with a 50% solution of Clorox prior to coating with almost any Shellac. The bleach is a preventative which helps fight fungus.

JimQ