Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

end-grain spindle turning

Posts

end-grain spindle turning

#1

Keith Tompkins

end-grain spindle turning

Keith Tompkins

>Here is a photo of my end-grain spindle turning technique. The project shown is a lidded box, the box is hollowed, the lid is jam-chucked, and the tailstock is there only for support. The lid is turned, and I am beginning to turn the knob. The wood is mahogany, reportedly hard to cut cleanly.

Notice my tool is pointing straight into the center, the flute is facing away from the turning.(can be done cutting to the right or left.) The tool rest height isn't the important factor; the fact that the tool is cutting at center is the key. This method won't work if the tool is at a tangent to the work, it must be cutting right at center. Here is the advantage of this method.

I don't have to roll the tool while raising the handle to keep the bevel rubbing as in conventional spindle turning. My handle remains on the same plane throughout the cut. The tool is easy to control, and catches are a rarity. I can make these cuts with one hand. Also, the tool rest is no longer a factor in the shape I can obtain. There is nothing obstructing the shape I can achieve. I can easily cut as far into the turning as I want. I can brace the tool handle against my hip, and use my whole body for control.

I am cutting , not scraping the end grain; if you look closely, you can see the cut this tool is producing. The grind is approaching the wood at a nearly 45 degree angle, producing a clean shearing cut.

This cut can be done straight into end grain,and will cut clean coves and beads. The same method works with a skew chisel, long point down works better for me.

Most spindle turners cut near the top of the turning with the flute straight up, so this method has more in common with bowl turning than conventional spindle turning. Not a spindle turner? If you turn hollow forms, goblets, lidded boxes, and similar items, you ARE a spindle turner!

I would be interested in any feedback....especially if you are getting torn end grain. try it, and let me know.


img

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#2

I was doing that this afternoon!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I was using that very same cut this afternoon to clean up the bottoms of some weed pots. It is the only way I've found to safely get a concave surface on the bottom.

I don't remember how I came upon that method. I might have read it in a turning article or I might have developed it naturally as I learned how to turn. But I've been using that technique for many years.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: I was doing that this afternoon!

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Brian, I use the technique for the same process....I turned furniture pieces for years this way, and turned bowls with spindle tools this way before I knew of the existance of bowl gouges.

Have you tried this for details, such as beads and coves, or end grain surfaces, such as box lids? I believe this technique will greatly expand the possibilities of spindle turning to those who give it a try.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#4

Re: I was doing that this afternoon!

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Keith,

Are you rubbing the bevel?

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: I was doing that this afternoon!

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Gary. yes, bevel's rubbing. Makes a catch almost impossible. Sometimes a cut must be made from air, no chance to ride the bevel. In those cases, I rest the shaft of the tool on the turning itself for support if possible, until the bevel makes contact.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#6

Yes, it's a great method

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use the same technique for beads and coves. I'm still "skew-challenged" so it's the best way for me to do spindle work. As you said, it works great.

I also started turning before bowl gouges were available and learned to turn everything with a spindle gouge, even bowls. I really appreciated my first HSS spindle gouge that was ground from round stock (like virtually all gouges are today). It was such an improvement over the forged gouges. My turning hobby has been pretty sporadic over the years and I'm finally wearing out that original spindle gouge. (I also do more bowls than spindle work.)

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#7

Help - need more info

MA

>Sorry - I'm a newbie and am slow in figuring out the type of tool you are using and the motion to make the bead. Is it a bowl gouge or spindle gouge or other?

To make the bead are you pushing and pulling the tool away from the spindle or still doing the rolling motion but not lifting the handle along the way?

I'm really interested in learning this technique as creating a nice even bead without catches is still a challenge for me. Thanks.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#8

Re: end-grain spindle turning

Raymond Overman in SC

>Ken,

I've been using that technique on small boxes recently. Turning the top of the lid and outside profile with my spindle gouge then hollowing with a 1/4" home grown hollowing tool. It makes an extremely clean cut and little sanding is required because of rubbing the bevel.

I have had a little bit of problem starting a cut with the gouge wanting spiral down the box but it's a matter of paying close attention to make sure it's supported.

Here's an example of the work. The first is Cherry. The second is dogwood. Both are about 3 1/2" tall bottom to finial and finished with laquer. Thanks goes to Bill Stehman for inspiration with the finial on my exchange piece. Sorry for the picture quality.








Re: end-grain spindle turning

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Help - need more info

Keith Tompkins

>Hi MA, The tool I am using is a 3/8" spindle gouge; specifically, a detail gouge. This tool has a bit more mass under the flute for support than a regular spindle gouge.

I am riding the bevel (the long angle created by the grinder)and pushing the tool inward from the largest diameter to the smallest. If I attempted to pull the tool towards me, I would be cutting against the end grain, tearing fibers in the process.

There is NO rolling of the tool in this case. The flute points away from the cut at all times. I think it's one of the reasons the technique works.....the process of rolling the tool while raising the handle is eliminated. The tool is moving on one plane only.

It's a technique worth trying....it may be something to add to your bag of tricks!

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Yes, it's a great method

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Brian, try this.....without adjusting the tool rest height, try the same cut with the skew, long point down. ride the bevel, just as though it was a "flat gouge". It cuts the same way.

I seldom get a catch, which lets me focus my attention on the form I'm producing. As you can see from the photo, there is NO wood under the tool....a catch simply drops the tool harmlessly into air, rather than forcing the cut deeper and deeper into the cut. I am not aware of others using this skew technique.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: end-grain spindle turning

Keith Tompkins

>Hi RAymond, Nice looking pieces....!

A tip..When starting a cut with the gouge, be sure it is right on center. A bit above will cause it to skate away from the cut. Also, just touch the tip of the tool to the wood, without applying pressure. It will form a slight groove around the turning. this groove is enough to allow you to now begin the cut without too much worry, as the bevel has something to guide it.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#12

Re: Yes, it's a great method

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>That is one of the few uses of a skew that I'm proficient with. It is especially good when space is limited -- like undercutting or parting right next to the drive center where the gouge flutes would catch the drive spurs. (I really should make the blanks longer, but...)

Yesterday I was using elm crotches with the vases running straight up the crotch. As a result, the grain on the ends of the vase was more side grain and it didn't break away as I cut it with the skew. It gave a really nice surface, but I ended up using the spindle gouge because it ejected the waste wood better.

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#13

Re: Help - need more info

Jorge Castaneda

>Keith,

It works great, just tried with the detail gauge, I still have to try the skew. This technique is a keeper!

Gracias

Jorge

Re: end-grain spindle turning

#14

Re: Help - Thank you!

MA

>Hi Keith,

Thanks for explaining the technique -> I'm going to give it a try this weekend. Can't wait!