Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Turning Walnut

Posts

Turning Walnut

#1

Turning Walnut

DougJ in Crawfordsville, IN

>Anyone ever have a walnut blank with some sap wood still in the blank during the finishing process?

More than once I have had this problem, where the sap wood in the bowl will start to disform. It just won't stay in form with the rest of the bowl. Not sure how else to describe it.

Re: Turning Walnut

#2

not only walnut

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Sapwood and heartwood respond differently to drying stresses in almost any species. It can be right dramatic as you noted. The sapwood is usually more active and will shrink more than the heart.

Re: Turning Walnut

#3

ebd

Re: Turning Walnut

ebd

>I've turned quite a bit of walnut, a lot with some sapwood running through the blank. I've never had a problem BUT I rough turn the green wood, then bury the blanks in the wet chips. Once winter hits I uncover the blanks and pile them face down. They sit in my barn frozen pretty much all winter. In the spring I re-pile them face up. By the time I get to the final turning, they are dry, haven't/don't check, and the wood doesn't move.

Re: Turning Walnut

#4

Re: not only walnut

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It also depends upon other factors such as how quickly the tree grew, under what conditions, where on the tree the wood was gathered and how old the tree is, etc. I have found that generally speaking walnut is one of the more stable woods.

Re: Turning Walnut

#5

Re: Turning Walnut

Barry Irby

>Wait until you get some apple. Actually, most of the "fruit" woods seem to be worse than many others. Apple can be beautiful, but if I want the best chance of the piece surviving, I turn away all of the sapwood.

Re: Turning Walnut

#6

Re: Turning Walnut

Jim King

>Maybe this will help explain some of the problem. Heatwood is dead and sapwood is alive. Sapwood conducts the sap and liquids to the leaves and keeps the tree alive. Just think about how many live hollow trees you have seen that are still healthy and growing. Also a common practice for drying a standing tree is "girdeling" it, or cutting a ring around the tree the depth of the sapwood thus killing the tree and allowing it to dry for a few years standing up. The heart wood has no presence of nitrogen and the sapwood does. Maybe this will help explain the difference in movement.

Re: Turning Walnut

#7

Re: Turning Walnut

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Girdeling! Never knew that! Ingenious. Thanks Jim.

Re: Turning Walnut

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: not only walnut

Brad Vietje

>Another factor is that the sapwood is almost always softer than the heartwood, so additional care must be taken in sanding and finishing -- this is sort of like sanding spalted areas in sound wood.

I also agree that Walnut is quite stable, so the sapwood may be moving no more than in other species, while the heartwood moves less.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Walnut

#9

Re: Turning Walnut

RevDoug

>I turned a bowl for Christmas that not only was heartwood and sap wood, but it had cambium on it too. Was a bit difficult to sand, but it did not move at all.

Turn 'em round,