Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

maple bowl...critiques please

Posts

maple bowl...critiques please

#1

maple bowl...critiques please

LT

>spalted maple...approximately 7 1/2 by 2 1/2...finished with just wax and buffed


img

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#2

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

Don Tewell

>I like the stair step feature on the rim. I don't think I've ever seen it before. I love the "roundness" in PIC2. Give me something to aim for.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#3

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

Mike Schwing from Md.

>That is a very pleasing shape, I'd be happy to wind up with that profile on a bowl of mine. The form has plenty of lift, making me unsure that the foot was needed at all, but its definitely not a big deal. Probably I would have left the protruding foot off and simply finished the bowl level, but since you asked for critique - there you have it. Its so slight that if you simply asked for comments I'd have never mentioned it.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#4

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

George Van in WI

>I agree with Mike on the shape, good lift, you did a good job continuing the curve. I think the steps in the rim compete with the great natural spalting. I think the bowl would show the spalting better if the rim were sloped inward or possibly a single cove or bead. Others will see it differently. Either way it is a very nice bowl!

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#5

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

LT

>Thanks, Don...can't take credit for the steeped rim. I saw it some where, I just can't remember where.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#6

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

LT

>Thanks, Mike...I went back and forth on the foot, but decided to keep it since I thought the curve might flatten a little if I left it on...still not sure if I should leave it on.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#7

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

LT

>Thanks George...you might be right about the rim...after I cut the steps, I looked at it for quite a while deciding whether to leave the steps on or take them off.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#8

I like it

Jake Niedling

>LT - How about sending it to me so I can take a closer look. Trust me I will send it back some day. Great bowl, the shape is excellent. I think the foot is perfect and I like it. The top edge of the bowl is very interesting and at first I liked it, but more I look at it I am not sure that perhaps a simpler flat top edge slightly tapered to the inside would be better. Nice finish.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#9

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

Bill Neddow

>This is a lovely bowl. The lines on the outside flow beautifully with no flat spots, and I think the little base gives it just the "lift" it needs to make it float. The steps inside the rim are not something I would have thought of, but they give the bowl that something special that transforms it from a utilitarian piece into a work of art. A fine detail is all it takes sometime. It is also a beautiful piece of wood.

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

#10

Re: maple bowl...critiques please

LT

>Thank you Bill...that is quite the compliment. I've been really concentrating on form and I tend to like clean, simple shapes.

LT