Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Chuck comparison - advice

Posts

Chuck comparison - advice

#1

Chuck comparison - advice

Brad Thompson

>Hello all,

Looking to replace my current multi-jawed chuck. As an aside, it is a MulitStar that I picked up when stationed in the UK. Great chuck, except the company has gone out of business and I didn't get all the jaw options and accessories.

Am looking at either the Oneway Talon or the PSI Barracuda2 based on price, described features and size based on my needs. (The OneWay Stronghold seems to be overkill for me).

Any experience with these chucks? Am I missing any others on the market in the same price/feature range?

Finally (as if I haven't asked enough...), the Jumbo Jaws for the PSI seem to be significantly smaller capacity that the OneWay. True?

Thanks in advance,

Brad

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#2

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

georgetroy

>I would not get the PSI. The Oneway products are a good way to go, at least you can get all the accessories you may want for it. You really can't get to many chucks. Of course it depends to some degree on the size and swing of your lathe. For a 10" swing the Talon is very good, but then again so is the Vicmarc 100. You can check the ranges in the Craft Supplies USA catalog. GT

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#3

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

Steve in NC

>I have been using the Talon for 18 months. I have 4 set of jaws including the Jumbo. It has worked great for me and I am considering buying another so I do not have to change Jaws so often.

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#4

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

Allen Neighbors

>I use the SuperNova2. I have the Cole Jaws, 50mm standard jaws, 25mm jaws, and 45mm Spigot/tenon jaws. I bought a second one, just so I wouldn't have to change jaws so often. I love it. The only thing I need now are the Jumbo Jaws for it. It does everything they say it will. www.teknatool.com

Allen

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#5

Re: Chuck comparison - advice *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I think it would help to know what size pieces you are planning on turning with it.

If you want to save a few dollars and still get a top grade chuck, check out the Axminster line available from Craft Supplies. I don't own one, but I know they are a well respected brand and they are on my list to get when I get my next chuck. Their 3" chuck would likely be comparable to a Talon and it is $159.99. (I say the 3" because if you were looking at the Barracuda, I suspect you have a 1"x8TPI spindle. The 4" is available for larger spindles.) It also has a very low profile, closer to the OneWay Chuck (not to be confused with the Talon) but still uses a key which doesn't require 3 hands.

The other big plus to any of the Axminster chucks (as I understand it) is that they can all use the same jaws...and there is a large set available for different uses.

-Craig

P.S. If anyone has actually received a PSI Barracuda, it would be interesting to hear their impressions. For a mini lathe, it sounds like a very good choice.


Axminster 3" 1-8tpi chuck

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#6

Re: Chuck comparison - advice *LINK*

Brent English

>Hi Brad: If you are interested in the Vicmar 100, per George Troy's suggestion, we have them and many accessory jaws at very competitive prices. Brent


http://turnrobust.com/Robust/Vicmarc.htm

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#7

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

Phil Joines

>There was something in one of the mags, maybe "Woodturning" from England about 6 months ago that the Multistar was being put back into production. Haven't seen anything since.

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#8

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

Roger

>Brad,

Check out Russ's Corner to the left here. An extensive article on his use of most of the chucks available, is among a good bit of other great info.

Roger

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#9

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

Brad Thompson

>Roger,

Thanks for pointing me to the article. Very informative and helpful.

To answer other's previous questions, am using a 12"x36" CM from HF lathe. Very similar to the Jet model of simliar capacity with the swivel headstock and reeves variable speed drive. I know it's not the "premo" lathe, but works well for me.

My turnings are bowls, vases and spindle work for parts of furniture I make. No hollow forms or massive bowls nor small pen work (though am toying with trying some).

Based on the advise here have replaced the PSI with the Axminister on the list with the only reservation being the rust commentary in the article.

Thanks to all again,

Brad

Re: Chuck comparison - advice

#10

Take a good look at the chuck materials

Guy in Cuba

>When I took my first bowl turning class we used Nova chucks, so I bought a Nova Super chuck and am very happy with it and all of the accessories available that have further lightened my pocketbook.

Since then I have also used the Oneway and like it too. I have seen some chucks that looked awful and since have read articles that suggest staying away from chucks that are made out of steel that can rust over time. I live in a very humid and salty ocean environment, buy my hardended nickel Nova chuck is as shiny as it was new, but the chuck material may be a consideration for you as well.

Good luck, Guy