Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Skew difference ?

Posts

Skew difference ?

#1

Skew difference ?

Richard Jones

>Am working with skews, trying to get my proficiency level up, was wondering how much difference there is in a straight skew vs. a curved skew? Not talking about the oval-edged, but a curved edge. If that much more effective, any problem with modifying my current skews?

Many thanks, hope everyone has a great day!!

Rich (no, not Raffan) in VA

Re: Skew difference ?

#2

Re: Skew difference ?

John Lucas

>Richard I responded to this a week ago or so. I personally can't tell a difference in how they handle. In fact I think the straight edge is better for turning beads, at least when it comes to tucking them in at the bottom of the bead. I also prefer the long point to be straight because I have more control when undercutting with the toe. I also find it easier to sharpen. I know there are others who feel differently. Some say they couldn't turn with a skew until they got a curved edge skew but I think they just wanted to learn and worked harder.

The most important thing in using the skew is staying on the bevel. When you get a kick back most of the time it's because you lift the bevel off and the cutting edge digs in too deep. This can also happen when you try to take too deep a bite when planing with the skew. The last reason you get catches is when you let the cut get above the center line on the skew. This makes the skew rock and then you catch the long point or the short point and get a catch.

Practice is much more important than the shape of the skew or the shape of the edge. Nick Cook said it best. "There are a certain number of catches built into a skew, and you just have to use them up before it will behave". I think you know what he was trying to say.

Re: Skew difference ?

#3

Re: Skew difference ?

Ed Moore

>I use a 1/4" round skew when making vee-cuts on ornament icicles and it is ground straight across. This is a very important tool in my arsenal.

I have a MOAS that I got from Alan Lacer and I ground it with a curve. (MOAS = Mother Of All Skews, 1 3/8"). When sliding it on the tool rest while making a planing cut I like having the points pulled back. I can go in each direction and remove wood efficiently and safely.

And I have a Crown PM skew (1"?) that I have ground with the rounded edge. It keeps a good edge and allows me to make the same cuts as the others very well.

The rounded edge makes it a little easier to keep the tool cutting at the 1/3 point when making a shear cut along a spindle.

Ed

Re: Skew difference ?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew difference ?

Keith Tompkins

>I have tried the curved edge, and prefer the straight....I use the tool with the toe down quite a bit, the rounded edge is in the way; it touches before the point does....

Re: Skew difference ?

#5

Re: Skew difference ?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>A curved edge at the short point made a big difference for me, when doing the rolling cut--rounding over a bead or shaping an egg, for example. I fought with a straight skew on these kind of cuts, having kickbacks about half the time using a flat 1" skew. But I also have a 3/8" round skew with a straight edge, and rarely have trouble with it. The round skew seems easier to control on a rolling cut, but you can get a better grip on a big, flat blade.

I think it's good to have a selection of skews, sometimes the straight edge is better.

Re: Skew difference ?

#6

Are these referred to as straight skews?

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>These are two skews that I've had for a while and are pretty much as received. One is a Crown and the other is a Sorby, both with oval bodies. No regrinding has been done.

I downloaded Ken Grunke's short videos (thanks Ken) and have been practicing, but I still get a nasty catch or the oportunity to make a nice variable pitch helix on my practice pieces. Would rounding off the blades to a profile simular to what is shown in Ken's video make these more forgiving for a novice? Do I leave these as is and sharpen to some prescribed angle? In the books I have, I see mostly the straight skews in the pictures. I like the finish this tool leaves, but when they catch it really messes things up.

Thanks.


img

Re: Skew difference ?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Are these referred to as straight skews?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ken, I would consider these a straight grind, with an oval profile. I like the angle of the grind on the left skew better than the right, a greater angle, which gives a longer bevel to ride.

Keep the bevel rubbing, o/w the profile may cause the tool to act " twitchy" with a tendency to catch.

Re: Skew difference ?

#8

Re: Skew difference ?

RussFairfield

>Whether the edge should be straight or curved has probably been argued since the first woodturner stuck a chisel into a piece of spinning tool. In the beginning they had a straight edge and a flat bevel because they were sharpened by hand on a flat rock. Now we have spinning grinders and more choices.

The most important thing about a skew is that it be SHARP. Yhe sharper it is the better it cuts, and the easier it is to use. Everything else is a personal preference. And, that's my opinion.

Re: Skew difference ?

#9

Re: Are these referred to as straight skews?

John Lucas

>Eddie what helped me more than anything was someones description of the skew finishing the bead with the blade at 1 minute after 12. As you may know when you turn a bead there are 3 motions. For example when cutting the left side of a bead you rotate the handle so the cutting edge goes from horizontal to vertical, you move the handle from right to left and you lift the handle. What usually happens is you rotate the handle too much too soon and you come off the bevel so just the point is in the wood. This will cause the spiral. Concentrate on finishing the cut with the cutting edge at about 1 minute after twelve and with the handle horizontal to the floor(this varies depending on where the tool rest is and your height) If you go to 12 or 11:59 you stand a good chance of pulling the bevel away from the bead and getting spirals.

Re: Skew difference ?

#10

very sharp

John Lucas

>You said it Russ. I now sharpen my skew very frequently using a strop. If you keep it sharp and never let it get dull it doesn't take but a few seconds with the strop to get it nearly razor sharp.

Re: Skew difference ?

#11

SCARY sharp

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>You want a polished edge, that you can shave with. I use an MDF wheel on a tabletop drill press, the top FACE is charged with white buffing compound. A nice flat honing surface, perfect for a skew. I also use the edge of the wheel occasionally, the way Lacer shows. I even sharpen X-acto knives with this setup, and the kitchen cutlery too.

Re: Skew difference ?

#12

Re: Are these referred to as straight skews?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Eddie,

It's a good thing you have 2 skews, you can grind a slight curve near the short point on one and keep the other straight.

When I buy another flat skew (not an oval one, don't really like them) I'm going to keep a straight edge on it like Keith's. It's better for using the long point as long as there's enough angle to the edge so it doesn't get in the way.

My current skew (pictured below) isn't quite right, I need to regrind it. The long point is almost at right angle to the blade, which is good for some applications, and I'll keep that. But the curve should be closer to the short point, instead of in the middle. Still, I found it an improvement over a straight edge for turning large beads and other rolling cuts using the short point.

So, soon, I'll have two flat skews, one straight and one curved and have the best of both worlds hopefully.


img

Re: Skew difference ?

#13

Thanks....................

richinva

>Thanks guys, appreciate the input. Maybe I'll peruse a flea market or something and see if I can pick up an inexpensive skew, for experimental purposes only, of course........... :)

Great info here, as always.

Obliged.

Rich in VA