Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Posts

Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#1

Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Dick Anderson

>There seems to be some mis-conceptions about negative rake scrapers. Several days ago I responded to a post on the subject and will now augment that with information directly from Stuart Batty�s own writing, which is as follows ad covers regular scrapers and negative rake scrapers.

�Regular Scraper � with Burr: Usable angles 65-degrees ofter woods up to 80-degrees medium woods � common angle 70-degrees. Suited to soft or medium woods. Extremely aggressive on exotic end grain.�

�Regular Scrapers � without Burr: Usable angle 70-degrees medium woods up to 80-degrees dense woods, with the burr honed off � common angle 70degrees. No burr means it is less aggressive but not usually good on softer woods. Best suited to medium and harder woods, can still be aggressive on exotic end grain but can be excellent on exotic side grain.�

�Negative Rake Scraper � Always with a Burr: Included angle 50-degrees to 75-degrees � best angle 60-degrees. Best suited to dense woods, it will cut some soft woods. Not suited for bulk removal of wood or rough turning, too slow. Excellent for final cuts � requires a lot of resharpening.�

�What is negative rake scraping? It is when the blade is ground on the top at an angle nd then ground fro beneath to produce a burr on the upward edge � it is only the burr that does the work. It is an excellent way to refine shape and take out small tool marks � it is an easy technique to learn and a great way to get accurate shapes or thickness.�

�What�s the down side? Negative rake relies on the burr and so the life of the cutting edge is very short and the tool will need to be sharpened a lot. Once the burr has been won away you must re-sharpen immediately. Life of a negative rake scraper is very short � approx. 15-20 seconds per 3/8 inch wide cutting surface for M2 steel.�

That is a portion of Stuart�s write-up. I also use an oval skew chisel as a negative rake scraper (no you do not ride the bevel, but us it as a scraper), since I don�t like an oval skew. It has worked very well in doing the finish smoothing cut on thin wings of coolibah and red mallee bowls. As Stuart says, the cutting is with the burr, which does not last very long and you must re-grind often. I use a 46 grit blue SC wheel for grinding the burr. A course grit produces a burr with less grinding than the finer grits.

Stuart�s email is: stuart@stuartbatty.com and his address is 1437 N. Studebaker Road, Long Beach, CA 90815

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#2

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

GaryG in MD

>Dick, Thanks for the continuing dialog. OK, if I use a burr (as I always do on a scraper for all but the hardest woods) and I don't ride the bevel (use it like a normal scraper), then I fail to see the difference between a negative-rake scraper held "handle level" and a normal scraper held "handle slightly up". It looks to me like the resulting burr angle entry into the wood and tool top angle are the same relative to the wood -- and that's all that counts. I don't see how this changes anything regarding letting the wood get by, or whatever. The angle of the bottom of the tool is irrelevant. If this is true, I don't see a benefit for regrinding my tools -- all I have to do is raise the handle a little. What am I missing? ...Gary

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#3

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Ed Moore

>Gary,

If you raise the handle of a regular scaper sufficiently to duplicate the presentation of a negative rake scraper, then you would find it to be awkward and unsafe. Your best tool control is close to horizontal and it decreases dramatically as you raise the handle.

Ed

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#4

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Raising the handle works, theoretically. So does changing the height of the tool rest (higher inside a bowl, lower outside).

But, the "sweet spot" angle or height keeps changing as you move across a curved surface like a bowl. So you have to constantly keep adjusting positions and doing only small sections at a time. Having a negative bevel on the topside of the scraper gives a good negative rake angle all the way across a curved surface when you're scraping from the center position.

Another possible effect is that changing the handle or tool rest position will change the angle that the burr is presented to the wood. I don't know if this is significant or not, but it is another point to ponder.

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#5

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Gary

In Albany at the Totally Turning symposium, I attended one of Stuart's demos on the use of this tool. He mentioned specifically that one could not duplicate the function of a negative rake scraper by tilting a regular scraper up on edge. I talked with him one on one for a bit about making my own scraper from one of the many tantung blanks I have lying around, and he reinforced that, giving me a few reasons having to do with the tool angle, etc. I have not yet had a chance to grind a tool, but I hope to get it done soon.

As an aside, from time to time I encounter turners who scoff at the use of scrapers and enjoy stating that real turners don't need or use scrapers. I would like to see some of them make those comments to Stuart.

Bill

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#6

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

Dick Anderson

>Gary:

Ed's point is very appropriate. I have tried a regular scraper with the handle elevated to simulate a negative rake scraper as described by Stuart. It did not work satisfactorily. My regular scrapers are ground at about 70-degrees whereas the negative rake angle formed by the top and bottom grind is 60-degrees or less. It is important to remember that the presentation is for the cutting edge to be at or ever so slightly below center on the outside of a turning and at center or ever so slightly above center on the inside of a turning. In all cases you want the handle to be kept as level as possible and the tool rest as clse as possible to the turning. Now on the inside of a turning you are not going to use a square across negative rake chisel, but will use a radiused tool with the grind at the front and part back along the side of the tool. You do not want to raise the handle on this tool, but keep the tool as level as possible. Raising the handle will produce an extremely hazardous situation.

My suggestion is to take your least favorite skew chisel, produce a burr on the top edge (determined by how you will place the tool on the rest), use the skew as a scraper and not as a planing or shearing tool, and use it on a tight grained, hard wood (two words describes chracteristic). Hardwood and softwood (each one word are classifications.

Give it a try. Good luck, be always safe and have fun.

Re: Batty on Negative Rake Scraper

#7

Thanks to all

GaryG in MD

>Ed, Brian, Bill, Dick,

Thanks for your thoughtful replies. (My reply is late because I've been out of town over the weekend.) With all this support, there must be something to it. ;-) I'll definitely give it a try.

Regards, Gary