Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Give this a critique, I need ideas

Posts

Give this a critique, I need ideas

#1

Give this a critique, I need ideas

Ed Kelle

>Originally roughed out last summer as a bowl, after all the chats, I decided to turn it into a hollow form. First real try at that. Finally got the hang of that darn hollowmaster, though it dulls in a few seconds. It is cherry with a walnut lid.

Shapewise, I like the vessel. It is 6"W by 3" high. The opening is large, but since it was not roughed out as a hollow, I couldn't put wood back. But it did make it easier for me to get the hang of hollowing. The top curves into a slight flat, and I wanted it this way. The foot is small at about 1" but I liked the artsy look of it. It does balance well. Hollowed to 3/16".

I am just not sure of the lid. I did a test lid, and found that at 4" diameter it flowed better with the curve of the form. I just had no good ideas what to do with the lid. I like it low, and I didn't want to do a Cindy-like finial. Not that I could anyhow. Any good ideas on what I could do for the lid? I can still make more.

I've been looking at this for days, and went back to touch up a few spots on the form just as we have ben saying, so it is as good as I can do. Even the finish. Deft rubbed down with steel wool to give a natural look.


img

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#2

profile view

Ed Kelle

>I looked at this quite a bit off the lathe while still on the chuck. Even using the black background. Hopefully there are no flat spots.

I like the lid height, but not too much the handle part, though I tried to mimic the vessel shape with it.


img

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#3

Lid or no lid?

Ed Kelle

>Doubt it works without a lid at all. I made some beads under the lid. I finally figured out how to do beads on face work. Not perfect but at least no major catches. Any other ideas for the underside of the lid?


img

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#4

wrong wood

T Daniel

>Ed, in my opinion the two woods that you used don't go together. Try a lid from some other wood and see how it looks. What do you have available?

TD

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#5

Re: profile view

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ed, I really like this...and I'm not sure I agree with TD that the walnut is wrong for the lid. It picks up the dark colors in the cherry in my opinion....but If it were mine I might play around with the lid some more. This one isn't bad...but I feel like it might be a tad bit too flat on the top. The vessel is so plump and lovely and the lid just kind of squashes it ....to me anyway. I'm thinking of a lid that might have more of a convex curve or dome to it?

Just my measly 2 cents :)

Jen

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#6

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

RevDoug

>I'm feeling like the lid is the problem. TD might be right, that the walnut is too dark. But, I think I would go another way. I believe that a top that is more of a nice compound curve, concave leading to convex, would be very nice. The knob is perfect, IMVHO. Over all I really like what you've done. The sharp edges of the lid are what I think throws is off for me.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#7

Re: profile view

Ron in Drums PA

>I like the profile, did you give any thought in making the lid into a collar?

I like cherry and walnut together. THe nice thing is it will look even better once the cherry ages.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#8

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Barry Turner

>I like the shape of the bowl and the lid. It's the little bitty knob I'm not crazy about. The knob looks so small that I'm sure it would be difficult to get hold of. I'd like a bigger one on the lid. But the lid and bowl are fine. Just my opinion. You would like any of mine.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#9

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Barry Turner

>I meant to say you wouldn't like any of mine! :-)

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#10

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Pat Mulligan

>Nice shape on the vessel,Ed.I don't know about the lid-a little on the big side.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#11

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Ed Moore

>Ed,

When I asked about my ugly blue box, I think it was Keith who pointed out that the knob was too "blah". So, I have been experimenting.

When I took a look at the picture of your form and lid, my immediate reaction was that it needs a finial and not a knob. Maybe I have seen too many pieces by Cindy Drozda, or ones influenced by her, or I have become sensitized to knobs versus finials.

The nature of your lid is such that designing the right finial might be a real challenge. If it is too fussy then it won't work, but something dramatic about 2 or 3 inches tall might be stunning.

My two cents, and you deserve change.

Ed Moore

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#12

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

JKJ in East TN

>My first impression (before reading any of this) was that the shape was very good but the lid was a little too "strong". It might be that the combination of the dark wood plus the complexity of the detail on the lid overwhelms the simple lines of the vessel a bit. I like the knob but I'm not sure about the bead detail just under the knob - it somehow seems inconsistent with the other elegant detail of the lid. Simply softening the sharp detail and/or tapering the rim of the lid a bit may resolve this. It would be nice to see how it looked with a simpler lid.

But this is a very nice piece! I do like having the lid and the detail inside the lid - a nice surprise to discover.

JKJ

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#13

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It seems to me that the lid and bowl are two different styles and this is causing conflict. The bowl is a nice flowing form and I think a lid that compliments that form would look better. I would also make the knob consistent with the bowl form (i.e. no spindle).

Just my two cents...

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#14

Steven Antonucci

Lid too big, wrong wood, needs rim on base

steve antonucci

>Other folks have already pointed out that Walnut might not be the best choice, maybe something dyed and a lid that that has some components from the main bowl.

I would also add a "connection" to the main form by attaching a rim for the lid to sit on. It would enclose the opening, which would look better if it were about 30% smaller.

There you go. Another opinion.

Steve

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#15

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

John Lucas

>Ed I'm going to go against the grain apparently. I like the lid. I like the way the graduation in size mimics the flow of the top of the vessel. Usually I don't like small knobs but for some reason I can't explain I like that one. If I did anything I would put a very small detail in the top of the knob that resembles the raised details in the lid.

I like the darkness of the lid. If I did anything to it at all I would dye it darker. Probably not black but darker.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#16

Ditto

Juergen

>

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#17

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Chris K in MD

>Ed,

I like the form, like the color of the lid, like the beading under the lid. I have to aggree about the knob its out of place with the rest. IMO I would go for more of a finial or dainty knob wth a more elegant trasition from the top. my .02

Chris

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#18

Lots to think about

Ed Kelle

>Thanks for all the comments and ideas. As far as wood choice, I wanted a darker wood to contrast the lighter cherry and add some weight to the top. Other wood I have is some maple, mahagony, and lyptus, all in 3/4" thickness. I might even do a lid from cherry and ebonize it. Design wise, I am planning on sketching a few ideas and see where it goes. Spent last night going thru many books and 3 years of turning mags, yet nothing really gave me much of an idea at all. At least it has a decent body and I can keep making lid until I get one I like. Maybe I'll do a few and let you vote. I'm going to take some more time to look at this and play around on the computer with it. I'll keep working on other projects until I figure out what to do with this. Thanks for the help

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#19

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Carole Valentine

>Ed, I have been looking at this since you posted it, and it suddendly struck me this morning that one thing that bothers me is the inconsistency of the detail on the lid. The top ring is sort of beaded and soft while the other steps are hard. How about softening those, or even doing away with the stepped appearance all together and just using beads for detail? I happen to like Walnut and Cherry together, especially after the Cherry ages. I would also like to see the knob a bit more spherical. JMHO

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#20

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Ed Karch

>The nob is appearently what grabs peoples eye judging from the comments. Think about how it would look if the knob was the same wood as the body.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#21

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

John Lucas

>I really like the top and the steps. I would agree that the soft edge of the beaded detail might not fit as well. I would love to see the top textured and dark. I think I like the idea of making the knob out of cherry. You could make one as a finial and one as a knob and see what you like.

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Give this a critique, I need ideas

Keith Tompkins

>I agree with John and Ed Karch....texturing on the rim with a cherry finial would be great...