Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Invitation to Critique

Posts

Invitation to Critique

#1

Invitation to Critique

Allen Neighbors

>This is a Natural Edged Bowl/Vase/Thing... call it something...

Its 6 1/4" wide at the top, 5 3/4" tall... Peach Burl. Lots of CA to hold the bark on. It's 7/16" thick. I was afraid to turn it any thinner, thinking it might come apart on me. To tell the truth, I'm not to sure I'm holding my tools right, and I hope Monday that I will solve that problem... An excellent turner, from Lawton, OK, is coming to my shop to spend the day with me. He's going to turn with my tools, on my lathe, and give me some pointers.

Trading wood for training... can't get much better than that.

Critique this piece, please... I want to learn. Thanks,

Allen


img

Re: Invitation to Critique

#2

Re: The other side

Allen Neighbors

>Turned green, CA to stop the cracks while turning.


img

Re: Invitation to Critique

#3

Re: Some of the inside 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Invitation to Critique

#4

Re: Some of the inside

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Allen,

Although I've been a serious woodturning amateur for almost 20 years, I'm not a pro, a turner with a well-known name, or a very prolific turner. So I don't feel qualified to give a "critique" so to speak, but I can just tell you what I like and don't like about a piece and you can take it with a grain of salt.

I think you did very well with the form of the lower half, the curve looks right-on with no flat spots. If you followed that curve on the inside, you did twice as good. I love the globular shape. Looks like you tucked the foot in nicely, the curve down there isn't overly abrubpt at all.

There's 2 things I don't like about this piece--one, the rim seems to overwhelm the rest of it. Maybe it would look better without bark, I'm not sure. Could just be the photograph.

The other thing is the finish, it looks overly glossy, and highly built up. Again, could just be the photograph. I like a semi-gloss, in-the-wood type of finish that gives a natural look to the surface, but still pops the grain.

So that's my 2 1/2 cents worth, if the pic were bigger I might be able to go into more detail.

Re: Invitation to Critique

#5

Questions and afew suggestions

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Did you start this piece between centers?One of the benefits of starting a natural edge piece between centers is that you can roughly establish the rim and then move the piece so both the high and low spots are on nearly the same plane and that helps the finished piece look balanced as well.If you`re are going to make either the high or the low points of the rim different from each other then it should look as though you planned it that way and the difference should be more pronounced IMO.

I also prefer either a matte or semigloss finish on natural edge pieces,sort of a hand buffed wax finish is as high gloss as I go on my nat edge pieces.The move from high gloss to the flat finish of the bark is just to jarring to my eye and it`s hard to make a clean transition in any case.Gloss finished bark is just too artificial and not in keeping with the "natural" feel.Again this is just my opinion.

I`d also like to see a pic of the bottom and also ask you why you put a foot on it.

The piece has a nice line to it.As others have said,turn it upside down if you`re in doubt.

The only folks who are impressed by thin walls are other turners so as long as the walls are in proportion to the piece and the balance of the piece when held seems right then 7/16th walls are no problem as far as I`m concerned.

It looks as though the rim is even all the way `round and that`s the hardest part to get right in natural edge work.

Two last questions,what would you change if you were to turn this piece again and why?

Mainely,Bob

Re: Invitation to Critique

#6

Re: Questions and afew suggestions

Allen Neighbors

>Ken and Bob, I appreciate you both taking the time to give me some pointers. And I also agree with what both of you said.

I did start this piece between centers, but never had a thought about changing the position to get the top balanced. I'm glad to know that, and I'll give it a try when I do the next NE piece.

As far as the glossy finish is concerned, Ken, I believe you said the same thing about another piece of mine you critiqued for me. I thought about that, but didn't know how to polish the uneven top while it's on the lathe... duh... never thought about doing it by hand after I removed it from the lathe, either. :o( Just too dense, sometimes. I'll give that a go next time, too. :o)

It doesn't have a foot on it. I continued the curve all the way until it "dimpled" so to speak. There is a 2 1/2"dia convaved area on the bottom, and in the center of that, a little 1/2" dia button.

If I was going to turn it again?... I'd do the things you both suggested. Because when I look at it, and think about those things, they seem right on.

Again, many thanks for your comments. That's helping me out. :o)

Allen