Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

Posts

Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#1

Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

George Van in WI

>Wally said hollow forms are addictive and he is right. Not wanting to wait for my roughed forms to dry I am trying to hollow green and warp for anticipated final shape. When I sanded a hard maple form it went rather well but the sandpaper still plugged a little. I sanded to 600 grit and then hollowed.

Last night I tried a wet spalted white birch blank and the problems surfaced. The paper plugged continuously, I kept a crepe paper cleaner at my side. It seemed the paper (new) was not even cutting. Next the fiber started chipping out. I smoothed that out but then a flat spot. I shear cut the area and more chip out. I applied a heavy coat of Deft and then was able to cut it but realized the form was now wrong so I reshaped the form and tried sanding again. I still had instant plugging of the new sharp sandpaper and it was from the wood, not the Deft. At the end of three hours all I had a sanded to 400 grit form with a hole drilled. The amusing thing, if there is one, is that it is not even that good of a piece of wood. I feel better to learn on this one though than a beautiful chunk of spalted wood!

I have seen in videos where wet forms are sanded and they look great in the video. I understand more hand sanding will be necessary when the form dries but it looked easier to accomplish the majority power sanding, low speed, while still round before hollowing.

What am I doing wrong, or what could I do right?

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#2

2 alternatives:

T Daniel

>1. use a spray bottle and keep it wet while sanding.

2. use a hair dryer and dry the surface just before sanding.

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#3

Re: 2 alternatives:

George Van in WI

>Thanks Terry,

When you wet sand do you use wet/dry paper?

I am assuming if the form includes the pith on both sides that drying before sanding would not be an option?

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#4

Dick Hines

Re: 2 alternatives:

Dick Hines

>Here are a couple more alternative. #3 Soak it in alcohol. #4 don't sand it, need good tool control. #5 Sand plast it.

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#5

Brad Vietje

And another...

Brad Vietje

>I do this sort of operation a lot, so please allow me to add another thought, taking Terry's first suggestion a little further.

When I refer to wet sanding, I mean WET sanding, not damp sanding -- wet/dry paper or cloth and a bowl of warm water. Put a piece of plastic over the lathe bed (and yourself), and dunk the sandpaper in the water, and start sanding. Keep the wood wet. When the paper gets a little gloppy, dunk it again, and as Terry suggests, spray the piece with water. The water washes away the gunk (that would otherwise be dust), and you make no attempt to dry the surface until you've run up to about 320 or so. After drying, you'll need to repeat the last grit used to get rid of the raised fibers, then take it as for as you wish.

You can also do this with mineral oil, if your eventual finish will be oil-based, or use the finishing oil you intend to use for finishing. When I wet sand with oil, I blot the piece as dry as I can with a towel, then squirt mineral oil on it from a ketchup squeeze bottle, and keep adding oil as it dries out (and gets all over you) It's more pleasant than described, especially the warm water in a cold shop, and not so messy as it sounds. Because I'd rather get mineral oil all over my jacket than Watco, I usually use Mineral oil until the final grit, in my case 320, which I do with the finishing oil.

Lastly, Spalted White Birch can be pretty tough under the best of circumstances. White Birch isn't real hard to begin with, and the spalting will make it worse. If the spalting is uneven, you run the risk if bumps & dips. Sand very lightly to avoid this. You might also try drying the surface a little, then sanding in some oil finish, then letting it dry for a few days (after roughing out the inside) to firm up those trouble spots. You might then be able to finish up the outside, then turn the inside to final thickness.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#6

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

George Van in WI

>Thanks Brad and Dick. I have lots of spalted birch and this seems to be the worst culprit.

1) I will try the �don�t sand� with one and let it dry and move. Then hand sand and watch the time.

2) I will do another with warm water and wet/dry paper.

3) I will do another with Watco.

After this I should be able to make a good choice.

Brad does the fact that mineral oil does not dry effect the Watco/oil-varnish finish?

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#7

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

Doug Trembath

>George, i have been experimenting with some new techniques to develop the ability to cut heavily spalted maple cleanly enough to start sanding at 220, which allows you to cut even the loose fibers instead of pulling them out. They emulate torn grain, but it's actually missing fibers, and they can't be replaced. I have had a piece sanded to perfection all the way to 2500, only to have the wiping rag pull those fibers out as I wipe on the finish, which ruins the finish.

(I belong to the "Polish the wood, then add the finish to seal it in" crowd.)

It takes a very steady hand, and lots of body movement, but it will make a good demo subject soon. You really have to see it done. My decriptive ability is slightly limited, but take my word for it, it works.

Sharpening and application of the edge are critical to success. Starting with 220 allows you to reduce the high / low experienced from differing hardness zones, as someone else pointed out. I use water to lubricate the cut, and allow the surface water to evaporate prior to sanding. I don't get much clogging at all, but then again, I'm using very light sandpaper for a very short time to even out very small differences.

Keep at it, you'll reach the saturation point if you continue to try to display some of the most beautiful grain and spalt patterns God ever created. If I EVER get a new camera, I'll post some of my latest.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#8

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

George Van in WI

>Thanks Doug, That is exactly what happened, I had the first tear out when I was wiping after 400 grit, the fiber just fell out, it was a smooth surface before that. I too like to finish the wood, then apply the finish.

�George, i have been experimenting with some new techniques to develop the ability to cut heavily spalted maple cleanly enough to start sanding at 220, which allows you to cut even the loose fibers instead of pulling them out. They emulate torn grain, but it's actually missing fibers, and they can't be replaced. I have had a piece sanded to perfection all the way to 2500, only to have the wiping rag pull those fibers out as I wipe on the finish, which ruins the finish.�

(I belong to the "Polish the wood, then add the finish to seal it in" crowd.)

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#9

A hairy fourth alternative:

adrien

>Jimmy Clewes in England has a DVD, Turnaround in which he sprays "methylated spirits" which I think is largely ethyl alcohol on the wet piece. Then sets it on fire! Turns it so's not to let any one part get singed. He says this raises grain and dries the wood. Then he sands. He's a very skilled turner and the video is quite good.

I saw him do it on the DVD. Honest.

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#10

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

George Van in WI

>Well Adrian, that is one I never heard of before! I would sure like to see it done before I tried it myself and I think I would want a fire extinguisher at hand. I will have to look for his DVD or an article on his method.

Did you try it yet? :>)

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#11

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

adrien

>his site is

http://www.jimmyclewes.com/

I've seen the video. And he demonstrates the technique both on an end grain large bark edge vase and on a beautiful fiddle back stained platter.

I think the video is very good. What he says is as important as what he demonstrates. and his brief section on sharpening using the Wolverine is also great�especially sharpening scrapers upside down!

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#12

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

George Van in WI

>Thanks for the link Adrien; this looks like a good series for our AAW group library. Sharpening scrapers upside down sounds interesting also.

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#13

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

Ed Karch

>I've seen Jimmy do the flame bit in person. He also does it with alchol based dyes.

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#14

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

Duncan Hoyle (uk)

>I've seen Jimmy demonstrate this method a couple of times and I've tried it myself once - it worked very well.

The piece was yew with 2 distinct colours so I didn't want to wet sand and get colour contamination. I'd never tried it before so was a little cautious (cleared any dust from the immediate area and had a fire extinguisher handy)!

I sprayed meths (no idea what this is called in the US - it's what I use in Trangia stoves for cooking whilst backpacking and is purple) onto one end of the vase whilst rotating it by hand to get an even light coating - you just want a light coat so the meths doesn't soak in. Then I stood back and lit the meths whilst continuing to rotate BY HAND. This first spraying appeared to work so I did the same to the rest of the piece.

The flame was no more than 20cm high and died away within 20 seconds. Once out the wood was warm to the touch and the abrasive didn't clog at all.

Remember that if you try this then several lightly sprayed coats with burning off inbetween are safer than one long spray which will burn longer and generate more heat.

PLEASE NOTE - use this method at your own risk.


img

Re: Help, Problem Sanding Wet Hollow Form

#15

Re: A hairy fourth alternative:

George Van in WI

>Well Adrian, Ed, and Duncan, I've got to try this at least one time on my next wet form. I never thought about color contamination Duncan, I will now be aware. I will post when I give it a try, thanks, George