We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>That is very good to hear. This has been frustrating me.
There seems to be a lot of confusion in the literature. It seems to me that not everyone has the same thing in mind when discussing "negative-rake" "scrapers".
I hope his article will CLEARLY discuss ALL the aspects of the tool nomenclature, theory, variations, benefits, sharpening, and use.
I hope he addresses the question of whether a tool used on the bevel is really a "scraper" (or a cutting tool) and whether or not a burr is to be used -- considering the fact that most people say they use one, but the Sorby site shows it being honed off on their "hardwood scraper" which is clearly a negative rake tool.
>When using scrapers to cut "Hard Woods" such as the Robert Sorby HardWood scraper, there is no burr left on the scraper, because on "Hard Woods" the scraper becomes a cutting tool and will produce shavings. The problem that we woodturners often have is defining what is "Hard Wood." I remember when I started to learn to hand chase threads, the instructions said to use hard wood. I thought Maple was a hard wood, it seemed awfully hard to me at that point in time. I simply couldn't master the making of threads. Then I re-read the description in the Holtz book and discovered that hard wood was things like boxwood, African Blackwood, Cocobolo etc. On those woods, a chaser works great and so does a hardwood scraper, which has no burr.
The somewhat new grind, which is growing in popularity, and I suppose this is what you call negative rake, have a top bevel ground on it without a burr, I believe. This tool works extremely well for the very hard woods and especially well for the plastics and epoxies. I have not seen them used on normal hard woods nor have I tried them myself.
>Since there has been so much discussion about this topic lately, I'll try to describe some of the aspects of the tool, and how it is useful to those of us that need a good finish on the inside, primarily, of a side-grain bowl or vessel.
The basic concept is that the top of the scraper is beveled, and with the exception of the "Hard Woods" that Fred talked about, it is used with a burr. Dense woods don't tolerate a burr on a scraper, so if you're using them, hone it off to get the best use from the tool.
However, for the bulk of the woods we use here in North America, you will definitely want a good burr on the beveled surface. Now, Stu has his scraper beveled on both top and bottom, and that creates some of the misunderstanding of the negative rake bevel. He does this so that he only has to grind one bevel in order to restore the burr, the bottom one.
All you need to know is that you want the top bevel to be ground away from the edge, rising toward the middle of the tool, to allow the wood to bypass the climbing that occurs with a normally shaped scraper. The bottom bevel angle is not critical, and can be anything you want, as long as it is relieved enough for the tool to be applied to the wood.
Stuart says he adapted a concept from British ivory turners, ala Bill Jones. He added the burr for less dense woods, and created the "most user friendly tool on the Planet", as he says and demonstrates. (Anyone having the opportunity to attend his demos and classes should definitely take the time, as it's about as good as learning gets.)
To further explain the concept, while the transition zones from end grain to side grain to end grain are encountered, a regular scraper, with or without a burr, will attempt to dig into the surface as it cuts. The end grain fibers try to pull the edge into the wood, then get torn out, and the surface is rough. What the negative rake accomplishes, is the wood cannot ride up on a beveled surface, so all you are presenting to the wood is the burr, (or the honed edge if Hard wood is being turned). Basically the burr is presented to the wood surface as a shallow, low angle plane blade. This should illuminate it for some of you, but it does definitely resolve the problem of being just a bit uncomforable in sticking a sharpened scraper into a side grain bowl. Been there, done that.
I say side grain, and this discrimination is important, because if you were to use the negative rake scraper in an end grain hollowing situation, it could react very badly. In this case, a regularly shaped scraper is the answer, where it is well behaved because of the orientation of the fibers.
Before you all get really fired up about this concept, remember, the only cutting edge is the burr, for regular woods, and it is destroyed quickly as it is used. For best results, you need to use a high Vanadium (read very hard and well heat treated )steel, and you will be restoring the burr a LOT if your basic cut isn't pretty darn sweet.
Used in the right circumstances, it really works as advertised, but if you're serious about it, buy a really high quality, very hard tool before you try this at home. Stu's adding to and developing the Glaser line of tools, and is really busy.
This is by far the clearest explanation of this tool I have ever seen.
You ought to consider submitting this posting to the WC "articles" archive so people can easily refer to it in the future.
I'm still unclear about a couple things, however.
1) Am I reading you correctly that this tool is used with the bevel rubbing? If so, is it correct to call it a "scraper" (a non-bevel-riding tool, right?); and
2) In order to have the bottom side of the tool flat on the tool rest and rub the bevel, isn't it correct that you have to be in a "handle down" position? Most people tend to say "handle level", and I can't see how it is possible to do that and simultaneously rub the bevel at some arbitrary angle in the 40-70 degree range. If the bevel is not rubbing, then it's certainly a scraper, but then I fail to see the difference or advantage from a traditional scraper.