Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Upcoming Chat topics

Posts

Upcoming Chat topics

#1

Upcoming Chat topics

T Daniel

>Suggestions please: do we keep going with the critique chats or maybe just do one critique per month? I have received requests to do a segmented chat, a night on lidded boxes and finial lidded vessels, pens, cremation urns, textured/enhanced pieces, plates and platters, and the list keeps growing. I am learning a lot from these chats. I appreciate those of you who are brutally honest; I have had to go back and look at several of my pieces again. I apologize to those who I may have offended; it was not intentional. I have learned that some things are regional and some of us just don't like certain shapes while others love them. I have also learned that some shapes are universally liked and appear to be timeless. I think I see a trend in moving away from the tiny foot popular in the books that I used when learning to turn; I also see a trend toward a shorter foot or no foot. What do you folks think?

TD

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#2

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Chip Peterson

>I am lovin' our chats. I just wish they would start earlier!

I am learning so much about design, turning and tastes. I'm almost starting to feel guilty for not paying my tuition yet. (Remember, I said almost!)

One of the keys to the success of this type of chat is the brutal honesty. We all have our tastes and our opinions. As long as these are not presented in an attacking way on someone's work, I think we all benefit. I hate when someone posts something that they made and 250,000 other posters simply say something like "wow!" or "nice work". There is nothing perfect on this earth, and all things can be improved upon. If someone asks for a critique, I think we owe it to them to be honest.

Thank you to all who tell me what I should do differently instead of just saying "nice work". If it is nice work, I love to hear it. However, please don't pull punches with me. That is how I will improve as a turner.

Someone last night mentioned having a topic on dyeing wood. With some of the beautiful effects we talked about last night, I would be very interested in that topic.

Other ideas include urns, threading, surface embellishments, and finishing (although that is always a component of what we have been discussing).

Just my rambling thoughts.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#3

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Stuart Johnson

>I can't begin to say how much I've learned in the last two weeks. I would like to see another session covering hollow forms and then a regularly scheduled monthly session. The scheduled session wouldn't need to be just on turnings but could be expanded to things such as grinds, tool storage, lighting or even guest speaker demos. For example Molly could do a session on how she does her burning. Russ,or now you TD, on dying. Of course if we keep it up we might need to give Ron some sort of support.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#4

Hey Boss...come here a second...

T Daniel

>We have been talking about our needs for a John Madden board for a long time. It has been here all along. The dual screen is allowing us to do things we thought we could not do. Stu has some good ideas here. What does top management think?

TD

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#5

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Don Tewell

>I have enjoyed the last two weeks. Although, I don't contribute a lot, I am still learning a lot by listing to critiques/reasons for or against a certain piece. And how to maybe make it better. There are so many subjects we may have to settle for an 'open forum/chat' once per month and the rest of the time on specific subjects. Just my two cents worth. BTW, my one year anniversary in turning is coming up in February.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#6

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Ron in Drums PA

>I think the chats we had over the last three weeks where great. I have learned a great deal. At the very minimum we should do this once a month. For now it might be fun to continue each week with some other shapes and forms until we covered the bases.

But the best part of all this is how civil we where. Every one was polite and some even took brutal criticism the way it was meant, to try and help another turner get better. Not one person lost their temper or started whining. I tip my hats to everyone who was on the last three weeks.

I would like to make a suggestion.

When we have so many forms as we did last nite, might it be a good idea to stop somewhere in the middle and continue where we left off the following week.

Also, I plan on keeping the chats links up on my website for a while, I think it might be a good idea to be able to go back and look over the turnings and remember the pros and cons of each piece.

For those who have asked, I barely scratched my monthly bandwidth quota. So I have no problem continuing on doing my part by setting up the webpages.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#7

Ron, if you can hold these images for a few weeks

T Daniel

>we could log the chats. Logging the chats without having the pics available would have no value. What do you think?

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#8

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>TD, last night was the first time I've been in a critiquing session and I really did enjoy it. It's nice to hear critical responses to our pieces rather than the usual .."oh, it looks great" and way to go..type stuff. I do find it difficult to sometimes say exactly how I see a piece because I don't want to offend anyone...however, I really do appreciate it when others critique my work honestly. I learn so much from it. The chat room allows a more in depth critique where we can do just that. I think every one knows that they may need to put on an extra layer of skin in there when their pieces are being critiqued...but it's all about learning. I'm all for a couple of these a month. The chat room is a great resource and wonderful place to get to know the fantastic people here on WC even better.

Jen

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#9

JL

Re: Ron, if you can hold these images for a few we

JL

>No reason why you couldn't edit the chats and have the pictures right beside the dicussion. I do this often for reports. I'll even volunteer to do the editing and picture incorporation. We could then forward the chats to Garrett to post in an appropriate place in the articles section?

I really have liked the way the chats have been going and really wish I could stay for all of them but bedtime does beckon.

My $0.02.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#10

Thanks Jenn

T Daniel

>I hope we all see it like you do. I think we are all giving good advice as we each see it. Of course we all have likes and dislikes and so do our customers. Very few pieces will score a 10 from everyone so we just have to take each comment and look to see if it is valid. I get a lot of negatives on my dovetail base but it works for me though I have seen a lot of dovetail bases that were out of place. When we have our gathering in April and you all see my dovetail base in person any negative comments then would have a lot more weight with me than they do from a photo; still, I appreciate the honest comments. Comments I am getting from new turners is that they are really looking at details now after seeing things pointed out that could make a piece better. We will have to trim it down next week so that we can keep it in an hour show.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#11

Re: Ron, if you can hold these images for a few we

Ron in Drums PA

>I was thinking of holding them for a couple of months unless there is an overwhelming request to hold them longer. These are too important just to quickly delete.

If you forward me the log for any chat, I can setup a page so anyone can view the whole log on a single page.

I don't think I have the time to crop, edit and proofread the log so the comments for each photo is on the same page. It's not hard to do, it's just time consuming. If someone is interested in helping me code the pages. This can easily be accomplished and I can upload them so they can be viewed anytime.

Also, I have the html code and jpgs for the first chat in a zipfile. I didn't get the chance to do that with the second chat yet, but I will. Maybe I can put together a link so anyone can download it if there is any interest.

Thoughts anyone?

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#12

Re: Thanks Jenn

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I agree TD....like maybe the first 10 entries....or maybe you pick the ten out of what was submitted?

I dunno?

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#13

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Mac

>Call me............no foot............

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#14

JL

Re: Ron, if you can hold these images for a few we

JL

>I am willing to do this. Besides, it will let me read the comments that happened after I went to bed :).

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#15

Re: Ron, if you can hold these images for a few we

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jeez....now we have to think about keeping the conversation clean. I might have a problem with that!!!.....:>))

Wally

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#16

Re: Ron, if you can hold these images for a few we

Rick in Lincoln

>Not being able to attend these wonderful chats (prior engagement on Wednesdays), a zip file of the chat would be greatly appreciated. Also, is the url for the pieces discussed publicly available? I'd like to see what's being critiqued. thanks

rick

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#17

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

RevDoug

>My thought is that we do indeed need to keep these up. Maybe once or twice a month would be good so that we don't wear it out. I also think that you bring up a good thought for one of the topics. Let's talk about foot/no foot, round bottom/dimple bottom, etc.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#18

I can see it now....

T Daniel

>" oh, you are one of those WC folks that does not believe a vessel needs a foot." :)

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Keith Tompkins

>I will be participating more in the chats soon. The critiques interest me very much, but my schedule is keeping me away...almost caught up! I appologize.

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#20

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>TD,

I would like to see a chat on the creative process. Nothing to deep, but I would like to hear how others create their work - mental process, not so much the mechanical process.

I some may see the wood that they have, and go through an in depth planning process - drawing out the design. Other may pick up any piece of wood, and just turn serendipitously. As a segmented turner, sometimes I have already done a piece and just want to change the makeup of the wood in the next one. OR I think of a totally new design, and plot it out on paper, and then transfer it to my segmenting programs and spreadsheets.

I love to hear how other come up with their work.

Mark

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#21

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

Carole Valentine

>TD, as I have already told you, I find the chats a great adjunct to the learning process. There are endless topics that could be discussed...all of them important. Since probably none of us can attend 100% of the Wed chats, I think it is important that they be logged with an archive of the pics relevant to each log. I think the "formal critiques" for lack of a better name, should be twice a month...otherwise I think we run the risk of the whole process getting "old". We also still need the occasional open chat and a few guest chats as well. I know Ellis is looking at new chat programs...I just wonder if there is a chat program that provides a split screen where the moderator can control the current photo being discussed? I think this would help to move things along and ensure that everyone is on the same page, so to speak. I also think if you, or who ever is moderating, has to choose x number of photos from those submitted, you might run into problems. I think you would be better off to say that only the first 10 or 15 pieces submitted will be discussed that night. That way it is up to the individuals to get their pics in early if they really want a review and the moderator is not burdened. Just some random thoughts...;)

Re: Upcoming Chat topics

#22

Hmmmm a lot to think about...

T Daniel

>Good ideas Carole. Please email these ideas to Ellis so he can see what is available to accomplish the split screen. Input such as this really helps us to develope a better format. I think WC is onto something here. With help from several of our regulars things are really getting better. Thanks All!

TD