We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm practicing chasing threads with the traditional tools. I know boxwood or ligum vitae are probably best for this, but I'd prefer to use a domestic wood I can get cheaply for practice...
Thanks for any suggestions (aside from getting a Klein jig! :)
-Phil
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased thread
Vicmarc.fan
>I have used what we call Hedge or Osage Orange here. It dosen't cut cleanly across the grain but you can get a feel for the correct movements. If you add floor paste wax to the threads before the final cut it helps some. We just don't have the climate to grow the type tree needed here. Thank God.
Ron
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased thread
JKJ in East TN
>I wonder how persimmon would work. I have a bunch air drying but haven't tried turning it yet. I know it is hard and dense, a close cousin to ebony.
I suspect a very good wood would be dogwood. (Yikes, that's hard to say!) It is very hard and dense with a fine, tight grain. Do you have it in your area? Grows like a weed around here - makes excellent firewood.
Oh, I just remembered I have the book "Making Screw Threads in Wood" by Fred Holder on my shelf. In the Chasing chapter he mentions the exotics lignum vitae, boxwood, redheart, african blackwood, and osage orange (probably an exotic to your area). For domestics, he mentions oak, black locust, holly, and mesquite. Indicates a little CA glue made apple hard enough for cutting threads and warns to stay away from softer woods.
JKJ
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased thread
Ric Taylor
>I recently finished a large persimmon bowl that was thoroughly dry, and I found it to be some of the easiest-cutting and sanding wood that I have ever worked with. It was pretty dusty, though.
Ric
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>Eastern Hophornbeam, locally nicknamed "Ironwood" might be your best bet (Ostrya virginiana). Extremely hard and fine grained, it grows VERY slowly, like boxwood. A 6" tree will usually be well over 100 years old. It grows pretty commonly around here, so I know where to get some if you need some.
Eastern Hophornbeam is not to be confused with another "Ironwood" (a moniker for whatever is the toughest wood in your region) also called "Hornbeam", a.k.a. Musclewood, or sometimes Blue Beech. If I remember correctly the latin name for Musclewood is Carpinus Carolinium. (Hornbeam, BTW, just means "hard wood".) While this wood is pretty hard, it isn't so fine grained as HOP-hornbeam, is a little more rubbery, and tends to split a lot more.
Hophornbeam is usually only available up to about 8" - 10" diameters, though I've seen a few more like 20" (rare). It is very slow drying, and turns very well wet or dry. If you can't find any in your area, I have some that's been air drying for 3 years, and a small 4" - 5" diameter log section over 15 years old. I may even have a few box rough-outs if you want to try making a threaded box -- we might even collaborate on one !
Another excellent turning wood available in the Northeast is Lilac. While small, and difficult to dry, it is perhaps the finest turning wood common to the area, can have beautiful purple streaks, and smells w-o-n-d-e-r-f-u-l ! Many turners have never even thought of it as a turning wood, but it's as fine textured as they come, and holds detail beautifully. While not as hard as Hophornbeam, its fine grain and waxy texture should make it a fine wood for threads.
Apple wood might also work, and comes with all the difficult drying characteristics of Lilac or many other fruitwoods.
Safe Spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
I learned to chase threads by practicing on a wide variety of domestic hardwoods. You will have limited success on just about anything with tight grain that you saturate or lubricate (I'm not sure which is most important) with mineral oil.
The two species that I've threaded the most I think you have plenty of in the NE USA... Rhododendron and Sugar Maple. Both of these work great with the mineral oil treatment. I keep a small jar of mineral oil and an old toothbrush on-hand just for this purpose. Both species thread very cleanly. The threads aren't as strong as the exotics, but that's the trade-off. As long as you can use an oil finish on the project you are working on these species and this method should serve well.
Good luck!
Matt
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
Do you have a recommendation for chasing tools? I have the Baxter jig but I want to learn the "old" way. I read a review in the last couple of years of three different brands of tools and one seemed to have clear advantages. But I can't find the review now! What do you use?
JKJ
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>My favorite is one that was made by Mark St. Leger. It has a double-ended tool (inside and outside threads) that fits into a Cocobolo handle and locks into working position with a nylon thumbscrew. When not in use the whole tool slides into the handle. It's pretty slick. I have a set I bought from the Woodturners Catalog too.
I don't think that the brand of tool matters as long as the cutting teeth are accurately ground. Hand thread chasing is a low-speed activity so there's no danger of bluing the steel and ruining the hardness of the steel. That being said, high-speed steel tools will hold their edge a lot longer, and since you only hoan these cutters a good set will last a lifetime.
If you are just beginning, smaller threads are easier than larger ones. I started with 20tpi. Get a good video... Alan Batty's is the best I�ve seen. Mark St. Leger's has a very good section on threading as well as many other great projects.
The problem with the tools that you buy off-the-shelf is that they are made by non-turners and need modification before they can be used with any success. They usually need a tooth ground off and some minor modifications that are easily done by anybody. I let this scare me off for a long time, but you really shouldn't let it scare you. It�s easy. Watch the Batty tape. Go ahead and buy the auxiliary tools too. There�s a reason they were used by the masters� you need them!
I hope this helps; I'll answer any questions I can!
Matt
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>Thanks! Google had a lot of info about Mark St Leger's demos and work, but I didn't find any chasing tools made by him. This wasn't a custom tool made just for you, was it? I'll look some more and also for the tape you mentioned.
I have several books and magazine articles which should also help. One old FWW article even described making the tools. I make threads for my gavels with a tap and die and have a thread cutting jig for boxes, but it was Holder's book that got me interested in in learning to cut them by hand. This all seems like good clean fun. :-)
JKJ
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>The tool was not made specifically for me, but I got the first one he sold. Mark doesn't mass produce his tools, he makes each one by hand and sells them at his demonstrations. If you belong to a club in East Tennessee you should be able to see a demo of his if you are motivated. He teaches at Arrowmont and John C. Campbell regularly as well.
If you are interested I'll see if he has any of them left. You would still need to buy or make the auxiliary tool rest and relief cutting tools somewhere else.
Matt
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>>...If you are interested I'll see if he has any of
>them left. You would still need to buy or make the
>auxiliary tool rest and relief cutting tools somewhere else
That would be great. If the toolrest is like the one Holder recommends, with a turned up end, it should be easy.
I haven't taken a class at Arrowmont yet, but I've seen their catalogs. Some extended courses are on my list. (Retirement is 18 work weeks away, yea!!!)
JKJ
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>Is that tool described in the St. Leger video? Can it be bougth or is it a home made operation? I use both the Crown and Sorby tools as well as a shop built Klein jig (after taking a class from Bonnie). Lubrication is very important. I use creamed beeswax, also walnut oil works well (sort of along the mineral oil line). I live in Oregon so we have a whole differnet set of woods. My quest is the same, find a local wood that threads well. So far Pacific Yew is among the best (box on the right), as well as plum wood. Fine grain seems to be the key more than hardness, as well as slow speed (200 rpm) and very sharp chasers. I've also had some luck chasing thread in the plank dimension, that is with the side grain rather than across it.
I'm glad to see I'm not the only one interested in hand chasing. I have a class with Alan Batty in June. Study with the master is always good.
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
No, I don't think that Mark uses this tool in his video, but he does in his live demonstrations. It's not something that you can make at home unless you are a machinist either. I checked with Mark recently and he doesn't currently have any more in stock... sorry.
Matt
Re: Northeast domestic wood for hand-chased threads?
>I just came from a workshop on thread chasing by Earnie Newman from Australia. He uses thread cutting dies sliced up and silver soldered to steel holders then inserted into handles, They arn't beautiful but work as good or better than commercial chasers.