Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Sharpening with belt sander

Posts

Sharpening with belt sander

#1

Sharpening with belt sander

Pat Mulligan

>Anyone out there using a 1" belt sander for sharpening?Herm DeVrie of WoW fame swears by it so I picked up one on ebay.With all the talk about sharpening I was curious.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#2

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

John Lucas

>I have used one. It was OK but I don't feel it is as good the good quality grinding stones. The grit wears out fairly quickly and doesn't cut as quick so you tend to move the tool slower. When you do this it's very difficult not to rock the tool, then the edge gets rounded and it's hard to control. The first few times you don't notice this but as you sharpen more and more the edge gets more and more rounded and then you lose contol of the tool. If you keep good belts on this probably won't happen.

Frank Sudol uses one with a 400 grit belt that was so dull it cut more like a 600 and polished the edge. If you had a really good touch you could get one heck of an edge on the tools. When I took his workshop I gave it my best effort but by the end of the class my bowl gouge edge was all screwed up.

I think if you used a 220 grit or so you would still get a good edge and it would remove enough metal that rocking the tool or uneven movement on your part wouldn't have the bad results that a really fine cutting belt would do. Herman's work is good so his sharpening technique must be pretty good. I don't know what grit belt he uses.

A decent strip sander will cost you about $80 and you can buy the Delta 8" grinder for that.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#3

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>As John noted, a belt sander tends to round the edge of the tool and this is a problem for any tool where you need to "ride the bevel" -- i.e. gouges and skews. But it works OK with scrapers.

I use my belt sanders for sharpening thing like lawn mower blades and axes. It also is good for shaping or reshaping profiles because it seems to remove metal faster but doesn't heat up the metal as much.

On the other hand, knife makers use water cooled belt sanders and usually work on the area where the belt is going over the lower drum so they get a hollow-ground surface just like a grinder gives.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#4

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

Bill Neddow

>I use a 1" x 42" belt sander all the time to sharpen tools -- in fact, to sharpen everything except the fingernail gouges. For that, I have a Oneway Wolverine system. I have supplemented it with the fingernail jig from the Kelton system, which will take my one inch Crown bowl gouge. On the belt sander I use an 80 grit Blue Zirconium belt that seems to last forever. I would recommend the belt sander to anyone.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#5

Brad Vietje

No, No, No ! -- Gotta disagree Here

Brad Vietje

>I rarely disagree with John, and in fact I often don't post things because John already wrote what I would have. Even this time, I suspect we'll agree in the end.

The problem with rounding the edge is not the belt sander, but the direction of rotation. I don't think Herm does it this way, but for the best results, you have to use the sander with the belt reversed -- yes -- running UP. When the belt is reversed, you have an excellent sharpening machine -- though I think 1" is too narrow.

The reason for reversing the belt is that a spinning belt rides on a thin cushion of air, and when you push your tool against the belt, and against the platten, the belt must make a slight curve to get behind your tool edge, and thus the edge is rounded over. (That's where we will agree.) When the belt is reversed, and sharpens the tool from heel to tip, you get an excellent edge, and any rounding over occurs at the heel, where you probably want it rounded a little anyway. The only "drawback" is the flat bevel, which in many cases is actually an advantage, but that's another debate for another day.

Woodcraft used to have a sharpening system called the Mark II that operated on this principal. It used a 3" belt, and had a large round drum (10" diam., I think) for tools needing a hollow grind, and a flat platted for flat bevels. The key to this system is that the belt MUST go away from the cutting edge to work properly.

The only system I know of that's currently available that works along this principal is a system made by Jon Siegel, in central New Hampshire. His is a 4" inverted sander with a V-block to position the tool handle, and an adapter for Ellsworth or other finger nail profile jigs. There is also a thin buffing wheel that when charged with tripoli removes any burr, and polishes the flute of gouges in about 1 - 2 seconds (any longer would round the edge). It does not incorporate a drum surface, and produces a flat bevel only. This thing works better than any system I've ever seen, and is MUCH faster and easier to use than other sharpening systems, and entirely reproducible. I assert: there is no other commercial system that even comes close to this for sharpening curved skew chisels. You can achieve a perfect bevel, every time, in about 5 - 7 seconds.

Because I've had no spare $$$ for the past two years, I have not bought one, though I have used them quite a bit when demonstrating at area symposia. A number of well-known New England turners use these. I adapted a 12" disk sander to sharpen most of my tools on the UP side of the disk, though that's less critical than with a belt if the disk runs true. I've recently sold my house and have some money to invest in turning tools, and I'll be buying one of Jon's sharpening machines this spring, when I get my new shop on-line. For those interested, e-mail me directly at brad@hollow-tree.net, and I can give you Jon's e-mail address; I think his web site is down these days. I have absolutely no connection to Jon's tool sales; I think they cost about $350.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: No, No, No ! -- Gotta disagree Here *LINK*

Brad Vietje

>BTW: Jon's web site is not there -- his web site link has been re-directed to the site for Amherst, NH, near where Jon lives... a pretty place, but not helpful for tool sharpening !

Here's a link to a PDF brochure about Jon from the Furniture Master's Guild. It has his address, e-mail, and phone, for those interested.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Jon Siegel Brochure (PDF)

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#7

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>For reshapeing tools the blue zirconium belt works several times faster than a 60 grit stone. I use 1 x 42, 80 grit for this and as Bill says, it seems to last forever. The brown alum. oxide belts wear out quickly.

Wally

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#8

Re: No, No, No ! -- Gotta disagree Here

John Lucas

>Actually I will agree with you Brad. The only ones I've uses spun down but one of my good friends who is the best carver I know sharpens his carving tools using a 1" belt sander with the belt spinning up. He used one to establish the bevel and shape and another one to strop the edge. His tools are razor sharp and controllable.

I can't reverse mine to try it out but I'm looking for another one to use at my carving station and will give it a try. You've given us some good information to play with.

I do use a disc sander regularly when I visit my dad. it's the only way we have to sharpen his tools. I usually use it on the downside.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: No, No, No ! -- Gotta disagree Here

Brad Vietje

>Glad you're with me, John !

I actually use both sides of my 12" disk when using my Ellsworth jig because it's mounted on the end of an old ShopSmith, and I can't easily swing the longer tools all the way from side to side the way my baseboard was built (baseboard with paired holes accepts the V-block). As long as the disk runs w/out wobble, this works fine.

I use 150 grit for routine sharpening or touch up, and a 60 grit disk to re-shape.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#10

Leonard Lee's sharpening video

Craig Daymon

>I have Leonard Lee's sharpening video and he uses a 1" belt. Good video covering (mostly) more than just turning tools. The belts and the sander are available from (surprise) Lee Valley.

-Craig

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#11

Re: No, No, No ! -- Gotta disagree Here

Jerry Bickenbach

>Brad, I have used one of those Woodcraft sharpeners at a hobby shop and found it to really work great. It had a built in jig for a straight grind. It cut fast and produced a nice finish. Good for cleaning up the gouges that others have tried to sharpen by hand. I would like to have one of these if I could find one.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#12

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

Pat Mulligan

>Thanks for the response ,guys.I sent away for 80 and 120 belts and I'm looking forward to trying them out.I'm hoping the belt sander will be better for the skew chisel-I'm not too good at sharpening that yet-or using it either,but if I could learn to use the gouge then the skew will follow.

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#13

Brad Vietje

Another belt sander possability

Brad Vietje

>Here's another thought...

One could use a horizontal bench mount belt sander to sharpen tools, without the need to engineer the reversal of a vertical belt sander. Various jigs can easily be built that will hold the tools at the precise angles desired, and working with the belt running away from you, you'd be all set. The hard platten would still result in a flat (non-hollow) ground bevel, but there would be no round-over, and sharp tools would still result.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

#14

Re: Sharpening with belt sander

eaglesc

>After reading all the replies I am not sure if this has been covered.

The slickest, economical use of a sander I have seen was posted on Wood net a while back but I can't find it.

The author showed a picture of a 4" bench sander mounted to a vertical 2x8.

The belt ran vertically.

The were stop positions on his bench for the location of the handles for repeatable results.