Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Soooo...what next?

Posts

Soooo...what next?

#1

Soooo...what next?

David Breth

>I'm enjoying turning enough, and feel after a year that I'm going to stick with it for the long term, that I've found myself willing to part with a few items from other hobbies to grow the turning. That means I'm going to generate $1,000 - $1,500 in the near term. Here are my thoughts (I could use help with #2)

#1 priority: Dust Collector - I've researched several, will probably spend $700-ish here.

#2 priority: Bandsaw - I could use some help here - models, features, be-sure-to-avoid hints. I'm guessing I would use this a couple of times a month. Mostly this would be used to turn square blanks round, and to cut the odd slab in half. I don't think I need tremendous capacity, just a machine with enough substance to do the job without dancing around the shop. can I do something credible for a couple hundred bucks (used or new)?

#3 priority: I told my wife if there is money left over at this point, I'll give her $100 or $150 play money. Basically, I'm going to make sure that happens.

#4 priority: Lathe - I might be able to put a few pennies aside for someday or maybe find something used. I'm using a Fisch (mini-lathe) now. It is ok, not great, and I'm starting to get a little frustrated being restricted to 10" diameter.

#4 alternate priority: save pennies toward a gas chainsaw - I've got a decent electric chainsaw, but I'm tethered to the driveway. Ever since I got the thing all I find is availble wood too big for me to take home to the driveway.

#4 alternate priority: turning classes. I think I've got that covered through some events my turning club is hosting.

Any thoughts are appreciated, especially bandsaw comments - there are zillions out there, and I just don't know what I'm looking at relative to makers, features, capacity, power, etc. I could use some help narrowing the field even just a little bit.

Thanks for reading a 2 a.m. rant for help.

David B.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#2

Re: Soooo...what next?

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>David

I can answer #2. You will always want more capacity than you have. Get the biggest band saw you can afford and never look back. You might want to increase #3 a little. I try to make it an even split. After all she does put up with us and our crazy hobby. You know the old saying "if momma ain't happy, ain't nobody happy".

Terry

Re: Soooo...what next?

#3

JL

Re: Soooo...what next?

JL

>#2 - bandsaw - Scout around for an older Delta 14" maybe. You figure that it has a throat capacity of about 6". That's typically enough for most bowls (and many other things). There are a lot of bandsaws out there. The older Deltas are nice.

#4 - lathe/chainsaw/turning classes - Take a turning class (or more) - try out a couple of lathes. You might find a lathe that you really like in one of the classes.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#4

Re: Soooo...what next?

John Lucas

>I'd go for the Chainsaw. I cut my blanks round with the chainsaw long before I had a decent bandsaw. I do love my bandsaw but until I got a decent one with a riser block it was mostly useless for rounding turning blanks. A good chainsaw lets you get more free wood and cut it to size. Unfortunately that will make you want a bigger lathe which will make youwant a bigger bandsaw.

I do feel dust collection is important and if you still use all your other woodworking tools this is really important. It will not pick up the majority of chips thrown from the lathe but it will pick up much of the fine dust, especially when sanding.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#5

Re: Soooo...what next?

David Breth

>The dust collector was really the reason for raising the cash. I just don't want to ignore that fine dust hazard.

David B.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#6

Re: Soooo...what next?

David Breth

>Is a Rockwell 14" basically the same thing? There's one in the paper at the moment.

David B.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#7

Re: Soooo...what next?

Bart Rhoads

>If you are sure that all you will be using your bandsaw for is cutting blanks, go for a good chainsaw. This will get you a bowl blank cutter plus it will get you into the woods or down the road for more wood. You can cut a bowl blank pretty good with a chainsaw. Of course you neighbors might complain if you are out cutting up a bowl blank at 2:00 am.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#8

Hey Ladies

Ron in Drums PA

>What do you think about question #3

Would you let you guy get away with that ;-)

Re: Soooo...what next?

#9

Re: Hey Ladies

georgetroy

>Get a 12" Height Bandsaw, your limits will much less and you will have no regrets if you got a smaller height capacity. Also a power chainsaw is great for the wood and freebies. GT

Re: Soooo...what next?

#10

Re: Soooo...what next?

Barry Irby

>If you are hooked on turning, plan for a bigger lathe. Get the chainsaw. You can do harvesting away from home with it and you can prep bowl blanks even for the bigger lathe. I have an electric saw also, but I had not realized what a weeny it was until I decided I did not want to sharpen the chain one day and fired off the gas one to finish a cut. Man! What a difference! Of course, only a fool would run it in the shop, DAMHIKT.

Dust collection seems pretty useless on the lathe. No one has posted any collection scheme that gets even fifty percent of the debris from a lathe. (If I'm wrong, somebody show me the money) So if you are not hooking it to a bunch of other machines, its a chip collector and basically a giant shop vac as far as the lathe is concerned. It does work well for collecting sanding dust if you bring a collector port up close, but $700 for that may be over kill. Also, it really is a chip collector and there will still be plenty of fines in the air. Maybe you want an air cleaner instead.

I think I would be looking at a bigger lathe, a chainsaw, large shop vac, Air cleaner, broom and shovel, trash can on wheels, Dust mask, and a bigger share for the wife and a band saw with a riser block.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#11

Re: Soooo...what next?

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I now round my blanks with a chainsaw. Cutting green bowl blanks on the bandsaw was a lot of trouble, its cumbersome, gums up the blades, and rusts the bandsaw table if not cleaned up immediately.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#12

Re: Hey Ladies

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Add another zero on the end of those numbers and we'll talk :)

Re: Soooo...what next?

#13

Double LOYL's money and pay her NOW!!!!

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Soooo...what next?

#14

JL

Re: Yes, that's a Delta Rockwell..

JL

>If the price is right, buy it. Very solid bandsaw.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#15

So, to sum up....

David Breth

>Posts that request guidance like this are always kind of fun because you get contradictory advice and have to sort it out. Aka, if there was a giant teachers' edition to answer questions like this nobody would ever have to ask the question to begin with. Here's the wrap up:

1) Buy a bandsaw

2) Don't buy a bandsaw

3) Buy a chainsaw

4) Look at upgrading the lathe

5) Buy a dust collector

6) Don't buy a dust collector

7) Take a class

8) Give your wife more money

Allow me to address these:

1/2/3 - I'm not sure what I'll do, but I do appreciate all the input.

4 - I would love to, but I think I need to address other areas first.

5/6 - I'm very likely going to pick up a dust collector. That's the whole reason for this selloff.

7) - Take a class - I'm on deck for a hands on class sponsored by my turning club.

8) - This money is effectively trading from investment hobby to enjoyment hobby, in which I could at least partially recover by selling out or generating income. My wife has been very encouraging, and I want to share some of the proceeds with her so she can have some rare, no-strings-attached fun money, and she deserves it, but I'm not good with converting a lot of this hard-earned investment money to dead-end consumables. $150 free money in our house equals winning lotto. She'll be quite happy, and can get about four months worth of massages out of that.

David B.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#16

Re: So, to sum up....

adrien

>Dave, can you turn outboard on your lathe? the biggest piece I ever turned, 22" diameter was outboard on a Myford, with a very small inboard swing. my toolrest was on top of a pipe set in a 5 gallon can of cement.

Re: Soooo...what next?

#17

Re: So, to sum up....

David Breth

>Nope. It would be nice. There are a couple of things I have in mind for the next lathe - reversible, outboard, larger capacity, HP, and as I think on it I'm sure the list will go on and on. Actually, the Nova DVR mentioned in the club demo (new thread today) sounds very interesting.

David B.