Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Bowl Coring Systems

Posts

Bowl Coring Systems

#1

Bowl Coring Systems

Rick Davenport

>The McNaughton bowl coring thread begs the questions:

Which system do you use?

Which do you recommend?

I will need to get one someday and they aren't cheap.

Wax poetic please.

Thanks,

Rick Davenport

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#2

Re: Bowl Coring Systems *LINK*

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>If I'm going to core a bowl

I don't go with any that's sol'

I don't want to end up with a hole

so I do what I was tol'.

McNaughton will do the trick

it makes cores thin or thick

With practice you can take your pick

once the subtleties all click.

Well you said to wax poetic. I have been coring with the McNaughton for years with good success. There is a learning curve. If you want, check out an article I wrote a few years ago which is on my personal website. The link is below.

Bill


Bowl Coring

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#3

lol

T Daniel

>

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#4

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

Rick Davenport

>Bill,

An amazing turner AND a poet.

What a guy.

One finger huh?

Which one?

Rick

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#5

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

Phil Lieberman

>Oneway looks like the best, for a few reasons like the cutter tips that are removed for sharpening which really means the tool should last forever by just buying new tips as needed and the fingers with the same curve so you have way more steel backing up the cutter. Thats my take anyway.

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#6

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Rick

There are a couple of things that I can do with one finger, but I am a bit confused. I can core with two, but not one - not yet anyway.

Bill

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#7

OT: I can see a list...

Raymond Overman in SC

>of "Facts You Don't Know About Bill Grumbine" developing but I'm just too lazy to get it started today...

Well maybe just a few:

Facts You Don't Know About Bill Grumbine

1) Bill can core a bowl with one finger. Just don't ask him which one, or he'll show you, the hard way.

2) Bill makes salad bowls faster than you make salad.

3) Bill has 60 years of turning experience under his belt. Yet, he's only 35 years old. He also has a stack of pancakes, some bacon, and a small walnut tree under there but we aren't allowed to talk about it. Refer to rule one and the finger if you're thinking about discussing it.

4) Bill has honed his psychic mind power to lift 100 lb. blocks of wood for mounting on his lathe.

5) Bill's motto is, "If it ain't blue, it won't do." You should change your motto.

6) Bill can hear a tree fall in the woods. Zen ain't got nothing on Bill.

7) When Bill rides through the countryside, he can smell the fear in the trees.

8) When Bill talks, trees tremble.

9) Bill uses his xray vision to see inside hollow forms and check wall thickness.

10) Bill makes friends as fast as he makes shavings. Just don't ask him which finger.

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#8

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

Bill Neddow

>Rick, I have both the McNaughton and Oneway systems. I bought the McNaughton system first and really liked it. Then I saw the Oneway system in use. I swallowed hard, coughed up the cash and bought it as well. (My friends say I am a tool junkie -- I don't know why!) Since then, the McNaughton has rested peacefully in the birdseye Maple case I built for it while I core with the Oneway. I probably core over 300 pieces of wood a year, most of them over 20" in diameter. The only time I use the McNaughton is when I need a straight knife to take a "picture frame" shaped ring off the bottom of a very expensive piece of wood. You know' the part you usually trim away when shaping the outside of a bowl.

Both are good systems, but I find the Oneway much more stable -- and it is easier to predict how thick the bottom of that cored bowl actually will be. Also, having replaceable tips on the cutters saves a lot of money.

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

#9

Re: Bowl Coring Systems

Joe Flemig

>I have used both the Oneway and the McNaughton. I have the McNaughton system and love it. I have an article that you might find useful.

Joe Fleming - San Diego