Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

Posts

Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#1

Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

Greg in Oshkosh

>I attended a demo by Curt Theobald yesterday. He used a curved scraper sharpened like a skew on two sides on the inside of the bowl. It somewhat reminded me of the hardwood scraper I've seen in the catalogues but looked more like a skew sharpening. The bevel on the top and bottom were at the same angle but they didn't meet in the middle of the scraper thickness. The top bevel was much longer than the bottom. Seemed real strange to see what looked like a skew sharpening on a roundnose scraper. He said it cut with a better finish and wasn't as grabby as a big scraper usually is.

Any one heard of this before?? Is there more information on the net??

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#2

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

John Lucas

>Greg This is called a negative rake scraper and Stewart Batty demonstrated it at last years Southern States Symposium. I have yet to try one but he certainly used it well and claims it cuts cleaner and is safer to use. I think he is trying to market them but someone else may know more about it. I plan to make one but just haven't had the time to dig up the metal and get to work.

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#3

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

Craig Daymon

>Cindy Drozda swears by it and so do all the turners in our club that have tried it after seeing her demo.

-Craig

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

Ric Taylor

>After some hands-on training with Cindy Drozda, I made similar bevels on my straight-edged scraper to match her's, and it works great. I haven't gotten around to doing the same on my curved scraper yet, but I'm going to soon.

Ric

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#5

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

JKJ in East TN

>I haven't sharpened one just like that, but I do use both the top and bottom of a conventionally sharpened scraper. For example, I have some rounded-end scrapers that have a long curve on the left for use inside a bowl. I often turn these upside down to use the long curve on the right. This just requires holding the tool down a bit.

I've seen recommendations from various experts to grind scrapers at angles from 45deg to nearly 90deg. Since the working edge of a scraper is really the turned up lip (or burr left by the grinder if you use that method) it seems to me that the angle of the grind doesn't matter much.

JKJ

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#6

Picture, someone?

adrien

>

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#7

to burr or not to burr?

GaryG in MD

>The thing that confuses me about dropnose scrapers is that some people use them with the traditional burr, while others hone it off. Without taking the time to look, I seem to recall that the Sorby "hardwood" scraper is a honed dropnose. There have been threads here before about dropnose scrapers, but I don't recall hearing a definitive answer to this disparity.

So what's the deal? When and why do you hone or not?

Gary

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#8

Re: to burr or not to burr?

JKJ in East TN

>GaryG,

I'm certainly no expert, but I have good luck honing the top flat surface of the scraper, then turning up the edge using a hardened rod or pin, very similar to the way you prepare a cabinet scraper. (I think this is called burnishing or ticketing) I bought a little bench jig to make this easier, but you can roll the edge with any hardened rod such as an old valve stem or even another HSS gouge shaft. The metal is actually deformed upwards to make a razor-sharp edge.

When prepared this way, the edge seems to last far longer than the burr directly off the grinder. This makes since to me, since under the magnifier the burr is a ragged edge while the burnished edge appears much more uniform and substantial. When properly sharpened, you actually get fine ribbons of shavings from the scraper instead of dust.

I've also used the scrapers without this burnished edge and they still work, but don't cut as well. However, they seem less likely to catch if used improperly!

JKJ

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#9

Re: to burr or not to burr?

GaryG in MD

>John,

I agree with what you say. I also use the Veritas scraper burnisher on my normal scrapers, and I like it. I can get good shavings from two or three good edges between trips to the grinder.

Most people in past threads on "negative-rake" or "dropnose" "scrapers" agree with you about the burr.

My problem is this. If you go to www.robert-sorby.co.uk and click on "instructions" and then on "hardwood scraper", you get a sheet of instructions for its use and sharpening. It is clear from the diagram that it IS a negative-rake scraper. The final diagram shows the top surface being honed flat. The official Sorby word appears to be that their tool is meant to be used with no burr whatsoever.

This may not seem to make sense to a lot of people -- the majority appear to think the tool is a burred scraper regardless of the angles involved, and use it as such -- but one must consider the following. Most people also agree that negative-rake scrapers are used on the bevel. That means it's not really a scraper at all, but rather a cutting tool. This fact was pointed out by John Lucas in an earlier thread. So, does it really need a burr to work?

So where does that leave us? I don't know, but it seems to me that there are several different tools and techniques all mixed up and confused here. Some people are using burrs and some are not. Some people are riding the bevel and some, I suppose, are not. Little wonder "your experience may vary". FWIW. ;-)

I'd like to hear more comments on this, but I suspect this thread is already too far down the chain for most, so I'll probably have to restart it if I want an answer.

Gary

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

#10

Re: Scrapers sharpened on top and bottom

GeeSeaWhy

>The scraper Curt used sounds like Stuart Batty's negative rake scraper. Red metal handle, like Glaser tools? My partner got me one of those for Christmas and it works beautifully. It's a finishing tool, not intended for hogging off lots of wood. It does a great job of cleaning up inside a bowl - I find it much easier to get a smooth stroke than with a regular scraper and it shows no sign of catching.

I saw Stuart use this tool at the Totally Turning symposium in Albany last year. According to him, the burr is essential. That's why he uses Jerry Glaser's A11 steel - the burr lasts a lot longer than it would using M2. The only trouble I've had is getting the burr back. The grinder doesn't seem to do it (my coarse wheel is 80-grit). Burnishing seems to work better.

Graeme