Re: to burr or not to burr?
GaryG in MD
>John,
I agree with what you say. I also use the Veritas scraper burnisher on my normal scrapers, and I like it. I can get good shavings from two or three good edges between trips to the grinder.
Most people in past threads on "negative-rake" or "dropnose" "scrapers" agree with you about the burr.
My problem is this. If you go to www.robert-sorby.co.uk and click on "instructions" and then on "hardwood scraper", you get a sheet of instructions for its use and sharpening. It is clear from the diagram that it IS a negative-rake scraper. The final diagram shows the top surface being honed flat. The official Sorby word appears to be that their tool is meant to be used with no burr whatsoever.
This may not seem to make sense to a lot of people -- the majority appear to think the tool is a burred scraper regardless of the angles involved, and use it as such -- but one must consider the following. Most people also agree that negative-rake scrapers are used on the bevel. That means it's not really a scraper at all, but rather a cutting tool. This fact was pointed out by John Lucas in an earlier thread. So, does it really need a burr to work?
So where does that leave us? I don't know, but it seems to me that there are several different tools and techniques all mixed up and confused here. Some people are using burrs and some are not. Some people are riding the bevel and some, I suppose, are not. Little wonder "your experience may vary". FWIW. ;-)
I'd like to hear more comments on this, but I suspect this thread is already too far down the chain for most, so I'll probably have to restart it if I want an answer.
Gary