Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Keith's words of wisdom

Posts

Keith's words of wisdom

#1

Keith's words of wisdom

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Our moderator and (many of our) email mentor Keith repeats a piece of advice every now and then that has become a mantra of sorts for me, and I have included it in my list of New Year's resolutions.

To paraphrase: "Better to produce one truly wonderful piece of work per year than lots of mediocre ones."

I think this might be the best piece of advice for an experienced woodturner that I have ever heard. Not so much for the new-ish turner who needs to turn lots and lots to learn the valuable skills, but as he improves, it is a concept worth pursuing.

How many of us rush to get something finished so we can post a picture of it, when a few hours more on the finish, sanding, decorating, buffing, etc.. would have taken the piece from nice to "outstanding"? (I'm guilty). How many of us see defects in our own work but hope no one else will, or that the photo will hide them? (I'm guilty). How many of us want to satisfy gallery requirements and just "get things out the door"? (guilty here, too).

I just spent at least a dozen hours re-doing something that I had already finished and shown to my club. It was a large bowl with a pattern pyrographed into it. I thought it was "nice" but I was not thrilled, and Mrs. Schwingydingdingaling thought it was "neat", but she didn't give it a WOW. The club members thought it looked much better from the back of the room than up close. I decided to spend whatever time was necessary to make it remarkable, and it now is remarkable. It got a "I LOVE THAT!" from Mrs. Ding last night when it re-emerged, and I have to say, it is now worthy of my best work. But DAMN it took a long time to get there. I hope my club feels the change was noticeable and worth it at our next meeting. I really disliked spending so much time, probably all totalled 20 hours on one bowl, but I believe it was worth it. I'll post a pic of the before/after soon.

It is a huge eye opener to realize how much work goes into those truly wonderful pieces of work, the ones that get juried into shows and win competitions. The initial realization is often one that results in a very caustic reaction at the prospect of spending so much time on an individual piece, but that is exactly what makes them so unique - the turner/artist/whatever has made that realization and accepts it as required.

I resolve to apply as much diligence to all of my work this year.

Keith, thanks for the mantra.

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#2

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Good thought Mike.

Along with that is a phrase that I first heard atributed to Wally Dickerman - "Good Enough, is NOT Good Enough".

I.E. Only your best is good enough. The best is YOUR best - not THE best - best you can do at your skill level.

This attitude ensures that Your Best get better everytime.

Just my opinion

Mark

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#3

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Chris K in MD

>I know what you mean Mike, It took me 5-6 trys to get the finish just right on my AAW bowl. It was an all day affair just for the finish. I am happy with the results but I didnt feel like I accomplished anything.

I also rechucked the layered orb, to make it less of an orb. I wanted to push myself and If I blew it up, lik eyou say its only wood.

I cant wait to see your pyro bowl, remember your new to pryoing (in regards to the first attempt)

Chris

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#4

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Ken DeMarco

>Thanks Mike, and Keith, for the reminder. It's also nice to hear that I'm not the only one to do that! I sometimes have to remind myself to apply this to every step of the process. Dave Peebles (my mentor) gave me a couple of mantras of my own 1.) Take the extra time to make sure the shape of a bowl (or hf) is perfect before starting on the inside 2). The last pass is worth blowing it up to get the right shape, thickness, smoothness.

Ken DeMarco

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#5

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Scott Hogsten

>I would agree for a piece that you plan on showing/giving away. However there is also no substitute for just going out to the lathe turning wood, making shavings, practicing cuts, working with shape/form. Also it's easy to look back and say "I really should have spent more time on that piece". However at that point in time that piece might have be "The best that you could do". I worry that a statement like this might be over generalized especially by a new turner.

Scott Hogsten

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#6

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Molly Winton

>Mike your words are well taken. It's difficult to admit, but I am guilty too. When I look at some of the pieces I reject as not 'gallery quality' I regret not having taken that last bit of effort that at the time just seemed too daunting to take. I realize now that had I taken a bit more time, I wouldn't have wasted the ENTIRE time of making the piece, since I've now rejected it as a saleable product. It is worth taking that last cut. If I blow it up I've only lost a bit of time. If I don't take the cut, way down the production line I'll end up tossing it anyway.

Thanks for the kick in the butt.

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#7

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Great post Mike. So true....and SO guilty! One of the things that I really get tired of hearing myself say while I'm turning or sanding or finishing is..."that's good enough"....I don't do it nearly as much as I use to...but still too often.

Thanks for jolt of honesty!

Jen

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#8

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I long ago promised myself that I would never ever say "That's good enough"...Instead, I like to look at a piece and say "That's as good as I can do". I have to get after myself once in a while to make myself keep that promise. Especially if the piece isn't turning out quite the way I want it to. Raffan once said that he doesn't make "seconds". If it isn't up to his usual standards he destroys it. I've done that myself a few times.

Wally

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#9

Re: Some examples I live by, and...

JamieDonaldson

>...you veterans know the first- workers who say "that's good enough for government work!" I thought of that many times in the field during Vietnam war- I always prayed that wasn't the guy who made my ammo! And my Architect Grandpa said that "good guality will always find a good home," and that "if it's worth doing, it"s worth doing right" Those last 2 are classic "Universal Truths"

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#10

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I like the saying "Make your mistakes look like that's what you intended to do in the first place" When you've screwed up a piece (not too badly), look at it for a couple of days, then get creative. Some times the results will please you, as well as be instructive.

Wally

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#11

Re: Some examples I live by, and...

Jorge Castaneda

>Jaime

My mother's version: "If it has to be done, has to be done right" and after a brief pause she added "with a smile"

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#12

no seconds

Dale Sherman - Manlius/Pompey, NY

>I've destroyed a few pieces, too, usually when it flies out of the chuck. If I can keep it on the lathe, I will likely have a nice piece, and occasionally a spectacular piece. It's getting all of them to be winners, that's the trick. Making a grand save is where the talent comes in.

Dale

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#13

Re: Some examples I live by, and...

Don Tewell

>Also, if you're going to do it right, it's quicker and cheaper to do it right the first time rather than come back later and 'redo' it.

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#14

I second that

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Sometimes you need batting practice and sometimes you are playing a real game. You don't run the bases when you're doing batting practice and you don't stand there waiting for the next ball when you're playing a game. I think it's important to understand and appreciate the difference between the two.

That's a lesson that I've had trouble learning. (People say I'm somewhat of a perfectionist.)

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith's words of wisdom

Keith Tompkins

>Thank you, Mike! I couldn't have said it better myself! Don't feel bad, I've bandsawed a few pieces myself!