Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

How much pith to remove?

Posts

How much pith to remove?

#1

How much pith to remove?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Got some elm off a recently felled tree. Center is significantly darker than the remainder of the wood. How much of the pith do I need to remove when rough turning wet wood to minimize cracking? I noticed in the picture of the ash bowl below, it seems as if most of the pith remains.

Re: How much pith to remove?

#2

Re: How much pith to remove?

JKJ in East TN

>Doug,

I don't think there is one "right" answer. For the least risk, remove more pith. However there are more factors. One is the particular wood itself and how it will behave - unknown until it's too late! Another is the geometry and thinness of the turning - thinner walls tend to crack less. Another is the drying method - controlling humidity while drying seems to work better.

As illustrated with your example, many wonderful turnings have been done with the pith intact; many others have been disasters. I personally don't know about elm and whether it is better or worse than other woods for this. If you have enough wood, you might try one with the pith and see if it self destructs.

JKJ

Re: How much pith to remove?

#3

Re: How much pith to remove?

Greg in Oshkosh

>Don't confuse pith with heartwood. Typically if you cut an inch from the true center on a 12" diameter piece of wood you have removed the most variable wood. However, it depends on species, growing conditions, etc. If there are already some minute cracks from the pith make sure they go.

Re: How much pith to remove?

#4

Re: How much pith to remove?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Elm will generally be more tolerant than other woods. This is because of its interlocking grain. Consequently, you should be able to get by with cutting closer to the pith.

I had hackberry, cherry and slippery elm left on the last day of the FL show. The hackberry and cherry had cracked pretty badly over the 3 days in the air-conditioned room. The elm had not cracked at all. Elm is pretty tough stuff.

Gary

Re: How much pith to remove?

#5

Elm is interesting ....

JamieDonaldson

>... for a number of reasons, and can be very elastic with the pith included if properly handled. This piece was turned wet thru the full diameter of the log section, and the pith puckered out like a football. I don't always follow the advice of the old boy who stated that one should "just always turn the pith out of it!"


img