Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Safe Centers?

Posts

Safe Centers?

#1

Safe Centers?

Curtis TX

>Ok, I am falling further into this black hole of the lathe world. I am learning tons from you all and enjoying the pics you post.

One of the new purchases I am considering is a "Safe center". I am considering the Sorbey Stebcenter or the Oneway safe center. I realize the Sorbey has teeth while the Oneway does not. My question is do you have one of these centers? Are they really useful? Is the Sorbey more versatile?

Thanks for sharing your expertise.

Curtis

Re: Safe Centers?

#2

Re: Safe Centers?

John Lucas

>Curtis I have used them and they are OK but I don't see that they serve any purpose. If you get a catch it may not make as big a chunk in your wood but you still have to turn that part away. On smaller turnings if you don't apply a lot of pressure to you drive centers they will slip anyway. They are good centers and work well but if it was me I'd spend my money on something more useful.

I also have one of the small step centers and I don't like it for small thin work. The spring loaded point is too strong and makes the wood flex. If I could remove this center I would love it. I think the bigger ones that are designed to drive larger work would be wonderful.

My favorite center for small work is a 3/8" 4 point drive. It slips if you do something dumb and you can put just as much or little pressure as you need to turn the work.

Re: Safe Centers?

#3

Re: Safe Centers?

RussFairfield

>My opinion is that the wood should be driven with the least possible pressure between the centers to make it spin relaibly. For long spindles, low pressure is preferred because high pressures will bow the wood between the centers. For all turning, high pressures on the centers makes big holes in the wood, and put an unnecessary thrust loading on the lathe bearings. Since most lathes use ball bearings, they are not designed for high thrust loads.

To compare the 3 ways we can hold and drive the wood with a center. The positive grip of common spur center will grip the wood with the least pressure of anything we can use.

The Steb Center has smaller teeth that grip the wood, but they are less agressivelt that a spur center. It will take a bit more pressure than the spur-center. It also has a spring loaded center point (that I think is totally useless).

The Safety Center was originally designed as a dead-center in the tail stock, and the ring around the point was there to prevent the wood from splitting from pressure on the point, and form a cup for a grease or wax for lubrication. A dead-center in the tailstock is useful for turning long spindles because the friction forces a twist into the wood, and on a long spindle this can help reduce vibration.

When it is put in the headstock, the Safety-Center has nothing to drive the wood other than friction, and that requires a lot more pressure. In a soft wood, it will require so much pressure that the tail center will split the wood if it isn't a similar profile such as the Oneway that has a ring around it to prevent splitting. For turning a spindle, it can require so much pressure that the wood will bow. On the softer woods, it will be impossible to get enough pressure to drive the wood.

The better alternative to the spur-center isn't available that I know of. That is to take the Safety Center, and file little notches around the drive ring. This makes it into a Steb Center with a fixed point, and for about half the price. If you don't want to make your own, go for the Steb Center and forget about the Safety Center.

That's how I see them.

Re: Safe Centers?

#4

Re: Safe Centers?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I'm going to go against the grain here a little bit. I think the safety center works well for people learning spindle techniques. I bought one from Alan Lacer when he demoed at our club. He backed off the spring tension on the center point as far as it would go before he handed it to me. He said that helps reduce the amount of tail stock pressure needed. The safety center does limit the amount of damage from catches for beginners. Yes, there is still damage to turn out of the piece, but the catches are less scary for a beginner. Because the catches are less dramatic it is easier for the beginner to relax and build confidence in his technique. I can see where the safety center would be of limited use to John and Russ, because they are very accomplished turners and not afraid of skew and gouge catches. I also agree with John about adding the notches A dremel tool can add them in short order. You don't really need a whole ring of teeth 4 or 5 notches will do. I also have a 3/8-spur center, like John and do prefer that for small work. I have a Steb center and rarely use it for the same reasons as Russ and John.

Tom

Re: Safe Centers?

#5

Re: Safe Centers?

georgetroy

>I'm with Lucas on the so called Steb or safe centers. I use the 3/8" 4 point for production work on Wood Bic Pens. After I have cut a 9" x 3/4" x 3/4" piece of wood. I don't even bother to turn off the lathe. The long point of the small spur center catches first and then you just bring up the tail stock center and go. Twenty years ago I was watching the area Dollywood turners demo at Arrowmount and this is the way they did it, so I said why not. Doing this is impressive when you are doing demos at your Woodturning Club and during Craft Shows. In my opinion forget the Steb centers and use a variety of Spur centers. GT

Re: Safe Centers?

#6

Re: Safe Centers?

Carole Valentine

>I have a Steb Center that I used when I was learning the skew. It was great for that, but I rarely use it now. I feel like it requires too much pressure to keep it from slipping, and once it has slipped, it tends to just keep on slipping. I also seem to have a problem getting the spurs on my two and 4 pronged spur centers to seat deeply enough. I solved that problem with my little 1/4" bench chisel. Once I have given the spur center a couple of good raps to leave shallow marks from the spurs, I just take the chisel and increase the depth with a tap on each indentation. The bevel on my chisel matches the bevel on the spurs. May be a hassle, but it works for me and I rarely have a center slip and don't have to use a lot of tailstock pressure. Oh, and if the wood is uneven so the spurs don't make even contact, I drill a shallow 1" hole with a forstner bit which gives me a flat, level bottom for the spurs to grab. Note that this is from an isolated yearling who has had to basically figure out things on her own...there probably is a better way! LOL

Re: Safe Centers?

#7

Steb Center

Ron in Drums PA

>I like my Steb Center.

When I'm working on a design for a pen, I'll turn the blank between centers to see how the inlays look before I go through the time and materials of drilling and gluing in the tubes. The 3/8 steb center is great for this.

Re: Safe Centers?

#8

Re: Safe Centers?

JKJ in East TN

>The small Steb center is my favorite for thin spindles (1/2" to 1"). But two things: first, I replaced the very strong spring with a weaker spring, and second, I make a small hole in both ends of the blank with a gimlet tool, especially for hard woods such as most of the exotics. The small holes keep the wood from spliting (from either end) if the wood is brittle or in case I apply too much pressure.

I like the way the center holds and I like the tool clearance it gives me on the headstock end. Whether it lets the blank spin in the event of a catch doesn't matter much since after a little practice catches are extrememly rare.

JKJ

Re: Safe Centers?

#9

Richard Allen

Re: Safe Centers?

Richard Allen

>I guess I am in the minority here. I liek and use the Oneway Safety center all the time. For me ther are some advantages to this center which make it very usefull for me.

1. I have never exprinced the felxing issues using the safety center. When I am turning something small enough that flext will be an issue I drive the wood with a chuck.

2. I have not experinced a problem with slipping that was worse than slipping with a spur center. And when a spur center slips a hole is drilled.

3. The safety center lets me remove the stock and remount without reguard for rotational position of the work piece on the drive center. With a spur cent you should mark one of the spurs and mark the work piece so that the workpiece is mounted the same way it was when you took the work piece off. For example, you may be making a tennon that will fit with another piece. Removing the workpiece to test the tennon can sometimes be done several times while making the tennon. The safety drive makes this a trivial exersize. The spur center requires a few extra steps of a bit of luck.

4. The profile of the Oneway Saftey Center matches the Oneway Live Center. This means that you can flip you workpiece end for end and expect it to run true. There are several reason that fliping a spindle end for end could be a desirable things to do. For example: when sanding if you reverse the direction of spin for every other grit you can achieve a better surface with less time spent sanding. Flipping a spindle is a way that a non-reversing lathe can let you sand in reverse.

Will a safety center make you a better woodturner? Likely not. If you turn a lot of table legs then you might get good use from such a center. For most artistic turning there is little of no benifit to a safety center.

Re: Safe Centers?

#10

Re: Safe Centers?

Curtis TX

>Thanks everyone for the input!

Re: Safe Centers?

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Safe Centers?

Brad Vietje

>I am not familiar with the Safe Center described, but I do advocate using an old dead cup center (with point removed) in the headstock to drive the wood where safety, bad catches, and novice turners are involved. Once they master the use of the tools, and learn to avoid catches, there are many other ways to drive the wood that might be better for the application (long, or very thin spindles, for example).

I usually recommend beginners look for a long-forgotten dead cup center that came with that old lathe, or head to Sears and buy one with a removable point for about $ 8.00 -- a great way for beginners to drive wood safely between centers, and a good training tool for seasoned turners too -- if it stops turning, you just might be doing something wrong, using dull tools, or pushing too hard...

Within the context of saftey for beginner and novice turners, we're putting way too fine a point on things when we are concerned about how different centers will cause flex in a very fine spindle, such as an icicle for a hollow ornament -- novices aren't up to that anyway, and need to learn the basic cuts and what goofs to avoid.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT