Re: Safe Centers?
RussFairfield
>My opinion is that the wood should be driven with the least possible pressure between the centers to make it spin relaibly. For long spindles, low pressure is preferred because high pressures will bow the wood between the centers. For all turning, high pressures on the centers makes big holes in the wood, and put an unnecessary thrust loading on the lathe bearings. Since most lathes use ball bearings, they are not designed for high thrust loads.
To compare the 3 ways we can hold and drive the wood with a center. The positive grip of common spur center will grip the wood with the least pressure of anything we can use.
The Steb Center has smaller teeth that grip the wood, but they are less agressivelt that a spur center. It will take a bit more pressure than the spur-center. It also has a spring loaded center point (that I think is totally useless).
The Safety Center was originally designed as a dead-center in the tail stock, and the ring around the point was there to prevent the wood from splitting from pressure on the point, and form a cup for a grease or wax for lubrication. A dead-center in the tailstock is useful for turning long spindles because the friction forces a twist into the wood, and on a long spindle this can help reduce vibration.
When it is put in the headstock, the Safety-Center has nothing to drive the wood other than friction, and that requires a lot more pressure. In a soft wood, it will require so much pressure that the tail center will split the wood if it isn't a similar profile such as the Oneway that has a ring around it to prevent splitting. For turning a spindle, it can require so much pressure that the wood will bow. On the softer woods, it will be impossible to get enough pressure to drive the wood.
The better alternative to the spur-center isn't available that I know of. That is to take the Safety Center, and file little notches around the drive ring. This makes it into a Steb Center with a fixed point, and for about half the price. If you don't want to make your own, go for the Steb Center and forget about the Safety Center.
That's how I see them.