Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Extreme reaction

Posts

Extreme reaction

#1

Extreme reaction

JKJ in East TN

>The photo below is of the most interesting wood from a limb I've ever seen. This oak limb died last summer so I cut it today for firewood. The tree is still healthy, at least 3' in diameter. The limb was over 40' long, having grown mostly horizontal about 5' from the ground.

The section below, cut next to the trunk, is about 15" top to bottom. From counting the rings, this limb was about 95 years old. The eccentric rings started forming at about 20 or 25 years.

We split some and the grain is incredibly tortured and twisted along the limb, far more than what I would have expected by looking at the outside of the limb. I see very little ring shake. I understand limb wood may warp and crack far more than normal wood so I don't know if it would be worth turning. But the shape of the heartwood and the twisted grain makes it tempting to try. The rays fan out like an inverted fountain.

Hoadley describes hardwood reaction wood as the tension wood at the TOP of the limb. Does that mean the wood at the bottom may be better behaved? Has anyone turned such wood?

JKJ


img

Re: Extreme reaction

#2

Re: Extreme reaction

Sean Troy

>John, you had better just send that wood to me for a much closer inspection. I'll let you know next fall what I find. Sean

Re: Extreme reaction

#3

Re: Extreme reaction

Pat Mulligan

>I turned a bunch of walnut bowls from a limb that looked just like that.I boiled them and they worked out fine.The wood was beautiful-a lot of variation in color between the growth rings.

Re: Extreme reaction

#4

Re: Extreme reaction

JKJ in East TN

>Sean,

If you live near East TN, you can come get much as you can use. (before I split it!) That one limb filled up my pickup truck bed.

JKJ

Re: Extreme reaction

#5

Reminds Me Of An Oyster Shell

Barry Turner

>The off-center pith reminds me of an oyster shell. Whadaya think?

Re: Extreme reaction

#6

Re: Extreme reaction

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've turned white oak like that from a leaning tree. It seemed a little more difficult, especially after drying, and I had a lot of problems with honeycombing when the roughed-out blanks dried. (I didn't know about boiling back then.) But the grain pattern on the ones that survived made the effort worthwhile.

Re: Extreme reaction

#7

Re: Extreme reaction

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>It would be interesting to see the results of different experiments with this. Turn an end grain vessel with the pith on center, and to final thickness right away--as thin as you dare. Will it dry to a lopsided shape?

Then turn a side-grain vessel or deep bowl from the compression wood below the pith. I can't imagine what would happen, but it might be fun (or not).

Re: Extreme reaction

#8

Re: Extreme reaction

Sean Troy

>I won't be living out that way untill June. Drat LOL

Re: Extreme reaction

#9

Re: TURN,DON"T BURN!!!

JamieDonaldson

>I have turned some reaction wood like this, and while the results are not always predictable, it is usually much more fascinating than watching the flames! And don't forget, it can always become firewood again!

Re: Extreme reaction

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Extreme reaction

Brad Vietje

>Great looking wood there, JK,

My understanding is that the wood on the large side of the pith (down, in your photo) is called "reaction" wood, which is in compression, while the "tension" wood is on the small side of the pith. Both have a lot of stress, and neither will behave "normally", though the tension wood will be more "normal" than the reaction wood. I may be off here, since all my wood books are in temporary strage, having just moved.

In my experience with Apple, Yellow Birch, and Eastern Hophornbeam that was similarly lopsided, the reaction wood will shrink a lot more than the tension wood, and can make for some really cool warped shapes, though it is also more susceptible to checking. I would turn it green and very thin, so stresses can be relieved as it dries. You can also experiment with microwave drying, especially if you turn something real thin.

BTW: while your branch grew horizontally, any trunk or limb that leans away from vertical will show an off-center pith -- the further it leans, the more lopsided the profile.

Should be fun !

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Extreme reaction

#11

Re: Value added firewood!

JamieDonaldson

>Turn green to finish and cure very slowly in a Polish kiln(brown paper bag!)right in the shop environment for several weeks. This type of grain can be outstanding!

Re: Extreme reaction

#12

Re: Extreme reaction

Duane C.Leach

>My best advice is to turn it. You can always burn it in the fire place later. Mount it between centers and centered on the pith. One side will be short and the other very long, kind of an off center look.

Good luck

Duane

Re: Extreme reaction

#13

Re: Extreme reaction

John K Jordan

>>...untill June.

Well come June, stop by if you need any turning wood. Wood is in abundance and usually free around here.

JKJ

Re: Extreme reaction

#14

Re: I drooled on the keyboard.

Al Crandall (NE of Indy)

>I would love to have a round of that stuff. That view is so enticing that I'd love to see a shallow platter turned in the same end grain orientation as the photo. The finished piece would have high sides and low sides like a bark-on natural edge, only with very little height variation around the edge. Might not work at all, but I'd die trying.

Re: Extreme reaction

#15

Great opportunity for testing drying methods.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi JKJ,

Here is the opportunity to debunk the alcohol drying process. Just turn several identical bowls from the bottom side of the limb. Dry them using different methods. When you are done the results will prove nothing. Because as the lines from The Boxer says, "A man hears what he want to hear and disregards the rest."

I have a lot of wood I would be willing to exchange for some of that oak limb. Or perhaps you would be willing to donate some to science.

Dave Smith

A Paul Simon fan in Longview, WA.

Re: Extreme reaction

#16

Hy John, where in East Tennessee are you?

David Propst

>

Re: Extreme reaction

#17

Al, David, and Dave

JKJ in East TN

>Al,

I would gladly give some to anyone who wants to turn it. But it is quite heavy and would cost a great deal to ship. Anyone in the area or coming through the area is welcome to it (and some spalted figured maple as well). BTW, judging from what I see in my microscope it is some type of white oak with abundant tyloses in the earlywood pores. I walked back down to the tree just now with my flashlight to look for leaves on the ground and it appears to be either Chinkapin or Chestnut Oak. (I saw seven deer behind the barn, three more than usual!)

HOWEVER... I cut about ten good blanks from it today and put one on the lathe. I did not find it pleasant to turn. I've turned dry oak before and I almost think the dry would better than the green! The problem I had was getting a smooth surface with even a very sharp gouge. I had no problem with sharp scapers, throwing long ribbons of shavings over my shoulder. But I just couldn't make my gouges work to suit me - even a smoothly scraped surface turned quickly into an irregular gouge-beating frustration. Also, I found much of the limb had radial cracks at the pith and some had separation between rings (shake) at about the 30 year mark. I saved a few that had a more solid core and cut out the pith on the other blanks. I'm afraid more of this wood will see the inside of my stove than my display shelf. If I get time I'll try turning another piece, but my work schedule is very tight these days.

David Propst,

We live 25 miles or so from Knoxville, up 25W towards Lake City, just a few miles north of Clinton. Are you in this area or do you come through here? If so, I'd love to meet and talk shop!

Dave Smith,

I'm a bit confused by your statements, but that's not unusual for me. I do hope to do some careful experiments someday, but they will have to wait until after I retire (hopefully this June!) I currently have a two month backlog at work and between that and the farm I have very, very little time to play. I'm not sure what you mean that the results of an experiment will prove nothing, since that is the whole point of careful experimentation. I hope you still don't think I'm out to discredit the alcohol drying method - I thought I was clear before that I am neutral about this, interested only in the facts. I am continuing to collect information as I find it and hope someday to do some controlled studies of some of the drying methods including boiling, alcohol, microwave, etc. (unless someone beats me to it)

Regardless, I don't think this oak branch would be my first choice of wood for these experiments. Besides being unpleasant to turn AND white-oak impermeable, I think the potential extreme variability of the reaction wood would make it a poor choice for comparison. I think it would be important to start with a large quantity of very uniform wood, all from the same tree. Something easier to turn, like green cherry, would make more sense to me.

As for this oak, you can have all of it you can turn if we can figure out how to get it to you. In fact, if you specifically want East Tenn white oak, I will soon remove a very large quercas alba to make room for my new workshop. Much of it I plan on converting to beams and lumber with my sawmill, but there will be many cords of firewood. (and some of the limbs appear to be at least 18" in diameter.) If you come visit with a truck, we can fill it with oak, persimmon, cherry, y.poplar, sassafras, maple, e.r.cedar, sourwood, holly, black locust, or what ever strikes your fancy. If I don't already have it cut, I have access to about 120 acres of private timberland we can choose from.

BTW, my wife and I went to hear Simon and Garfunkle when they came to Atlanta not long ago. Most I ever paid for a ticket.

JKJ

Re: Extreme reaction

#18

Re: Extreme reaction

Dick Parr

>John if it ever stops raining I would like to come out and get some.

Call ya next week

Dick

Re: Extreme reaction

#19

Re: Extreme reaction

JKJ in East TN

>Dick, do you want some anchor-sealed blanks cut from the limb or should I save a couple of unprocessed chunks for you? Also, do you want any persimmon?

JKJ