Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Minimum lathe speed

Posts

Minimum lathe speed

#1

Minimum lathe speed

Mike Horner

>I'm using an entry jet lathe right now - I have been using it for five years. It works well enought to hook me on turning, but it's a bit whimpy for larger bowls and other big stuff.

I'm looking at several 16" to 20" lathes in my price range (or, not too far out of it). Some have minimum speeds of 450 and 500 rpm for the lowest speeds. Since I turn some green wood of our place, this may be a little bit fast or way out of balance stock. What do you think that a good minimum speed is? Thanks

PS: Has anyone used the new 20" Grizzley lathe? It looks like lots of iron for not too much money.

Re: Minimum lathe speed

#2

Re: Minimum lathe speed

John Lucas

>Mike I would have to look it up but I don't think the Grizzly has a very good minimum speed. I also have an issue with the sander on the end and not having a hollow spindle, and the gap bed. Some people like a gap bed but most do not. Having a handwheel instead of the sander is something most of us really like. I would look very closely at the Nova 3000 and the Jet 16". They might be a little higher in price but they get very good marks from all who own them.

Re: Minimum lathe speed

#3

Grizzly review *LINK*

John Lucas

>Mike I hope this url works, I have to get to an assignment so I don't have time to check it. John


http://www.woodturner.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=1440

Re: Minimum lathe speed

#4

Re: Minimum lathe speed

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Mike

This question has come up on a couple of other forums. I have not seen the lathe, but I have looked at the specs. This is my opinion, based on my own experience with lots of different types of turning and on different types of machines.

The slowest speed is too fast for larger out of balance pieces that you would expect to turn on a lathe with a 20" swing. In addition to that, the design of the stand is somewhere around 50 years old - a good design for spindle work, but not for bowls or hollow forms.

The fastest speed is too slow for small spindles. Especially if you get into turning something small like pens, you will be frustrated with the lack of ability to get clean cuts or high gloss finishes from friction polishes.

The lathe appears to have one pulley for all the speeds, which means that the motor is going to be operating at lower speeds for the lower spindle speeds, and that means it is going to be easier to stall.

I do not mind the solid headstock, but then I have a Poolewood. I have a vacuum chuck that will work for solid headstock lathes. I would miss the handwheel, and I think the sander is an extra that does not need to be there. I don't think it adds to the attractiveness of the lathe, but I don't use disk sanders for anything. Perhaps if I was a segmented turner I would think differently.

To sum it all up, I would keep looking before I put money on this lathe. It seems to be a copy of an old design with a few goodies thrown in to gussy it up a bit, but overall it does not seem to have been designed with any input from turners. I could be wrong, but that is the impression I get.

Bill

Re: Minimum lathe speed

#5

Re: Minimum lathe speed

Carole Valentine

>Ditto what John said. I have the Nova DVR. It's minimum speed is 100 rpm. I have really found nothing to dislike about the machine other than the fact that the tool rest, spur center and locking handles provided with the lathe are not to my liking. These are easily remedied. But note that I have been accused of being "picky" - you may like them just fine. :) It's a lot of lathe for the money.

Re: Minimum lathe speed

#6

Re: Minimum lathe speed

Mike Horner

>Thanks for the responses. My gut feeling was that 500 rpm was way too fast for out-of-balance wet turning blanks, especially big ones. That's why I want a bigger lathe.

I'm comparing it to the Nova 2000 DVR, the Jet 16", and the Delta 16" that's on sale at Amazon. I'm inclined towards the Delta. I'd buy a 1 1/8 to 1 spindle thread adaptor to use all the 1 x 8 tpi stuff that I already have.