How do I keep the smell?
MA
>I just finished a bowl out of aromatic cedar. I sanded it to 800 so it has a fair shine but would like to put a finish on it as the grain is really nice. What finish could I use and still keep the great smell?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How do I keep the smell?
MA
>I just finished a bowl out of aromatic cedar. I sanded it to 800 so it has a fair shine but would like to put a finish on it as the grain is really nice. What finish could I use and still keep the great smell?
Re: How do I keep the smell?
John Veerkamp
>You can use a light coat of lacquer wiped off immediately followed by wax. the aroma will come thru in a few days. or you can use wax alone for a slightly less durable finish. again the aroma comes thru fine. they look about the same.
John
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Carole Valentine
>Hi MA,
I'm waiting for you to post some pics! ;)
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Juergen
>I turned some cedar balls to put in clother drawers for the scent (unfinished). The smell would go away after a few months. Sanding the ball again brings back the smell.
Re: How do I keep the smell?
MA
>Post a pic?! YIKES! I'm in the L&L stage - lurk and learn. This is bowl #3 for me. Having fun and learning a lot from this messageboard - appreciate the good info. Maybe sometime in the future..FAR future...! MA
Re: How do I keep the smell?
JKJ in East TN
>I've used just beeswax on some cedar turnings. I like the soft look and it seems to not hide the smell. However, regardless of what you do the scent will diminish over time. You can restore the scent with a dab of cedar oil. Google will give sources if you can't find it locally.
JKJ
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Ernie Miller
>Finish the bowl the way you loke then turn a few small cedar balls to throe inside the bowl. then all you have to do is sand the balls a little every months to keep the smell lingering.
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>No one posted the obvious - do use anything.
I would assume that you did not turn it for a Salad Bowl, or any other use where the smell transfering to the contents would be an issue.
Finishes are for two purposes in my opinion: 1) protect the wood from the environment (water, etc), and 2) enhance the appearance. You probably do not need either.
I did an aeromatic Ceder bowl for my wife last month, and just sanding it to 800 grit, and then buffed it with a clean linen buffing wheel.
Mark
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Bill Hale
>I have done some of these and also wanted to get a finished look. I sanded the inside to 600 and did not finish it. I sanded the outside to 600 and did a urithane high gloss finish to pop the color of the wood. Looked great and smell wonderful also.
Good turning and be safe
Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.
Re: How do I keep the smell?
RussFairfield
>Just remember what causes that aroma of Cedar, Camphor and other aromatic woods. It is the gassing off of the oils on the surface of the wood. The best way to allow that is to put nothing on the wood.
A finish has to be permeable enough for the gasses to pass through so you can smell the oils, and it has to be oderless enough itself so as to not mask the odor from the oils in the wood. Wax is the most permeable, and epoxy is the least. Everything else is somewhere in the middle. Therefore, wax would be the best finish to put on an aromatic wood.
Trying to keep the aroma of a wood is an elusive dream. When those surface oils have all evaporated, the aroma will have disappeared. The aroma will be less in a year, it will p[robably be gone in two, and after that you will have to hold it to your nose to smell the wood at all.
Re: How do I keep the smell?
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>I wish that I would proof read what I type!!
Of course I meant "Do NOT use anything".
Mark
Thank you for the great advice!
MA
>Thank you all for the great ideas and advice. I'm leaning towards leaving it be or maybe trying wax on the bottom as a test spot. If the wax really makes a big difference then I'll try the method of only waxing the outside and leaving the inside unfinished. I also like the idea of having cedar turnings in the bowl that can be refreshed. Thank you all again. MA
Re: Thank you for the great advice!
John K Jordan
>>...or maybe trying wax
MA,
I've posted this before, but the picture below is of an e.r.cedar bowl with beeswax finish, followed by a light coat of Renascence Wax. This was the first time I used this finish (and actually my 3rd or 4th bowl, if I remember correctly) It retained the scent for a long time.
I have a theory (not scientifically tested) that the mild beeswax finish slows down the evaporation of the scented compounds in the wood, perhaps diminishing the strong initial scent but letting the scent last longer. The beeswax also protects the wood somewhat from dirty fingerprints, and as I mentioned before, I like the soft look. I've since used beeswax on other cedar bowls, wands, finger tops, and other things.
JKJ
Beeswax Recommendation
MA
>Hi John,
Your bowl is gorgeous! I haven't used beeswax before -> I did a search and found mixes of beeswax with other waxes or shellac. What do you recommend? Thanks. MA
Re: Beeswax Recommendation
JKJ in East TN
>>...What do you recommend?
I'm certainly no expert on this, but I just took a small piece of beeswax and held it gently against the turning bowl, then buffed it a bit with a small piece of cloth. (If you are not aware of this, never use a piece of cloth large enough to wrap around your finger or you could lose the finger - some people use only paper towels but I prefer small squares of cotton, about 2" square.)
I think with cedar you might be careful not to over apply the wax and get it so hot with friction that it turns liquid and leaves splotches. I'm not generally wild about cedar finished with oil or other finishes that soak into the wood and make it dark - I prefer the softer look. Best to experiment on a test turning to see what suits you. Also, warming the wax a little softens it.
I bought a small block of beeswax at Woodcraft, probably a lifetime supply!
JKJ
Thank you - will give that a try
MA
>