Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Critic time, please be honest!

Posts

Critic time, please be honest!

#1

Critic time, please be honest!

Chris K in MD

>Here is my first layered bowl that I made. I was not able to submit it for the AAW contest due to its size, but I am pleased with the results. I would like comments, Please be honest, I wont improve without honest feedback. I would like to point out that I applied a very shiny finish to it and have found it near impossible to take a picture without reflections, I apologized for this.

Facts:

woods-Bloodwood, B. walnut, Lacewood, B. walnut, Wenge, repeat

size 2" tall ~2.6 wide.

Finish is CA glue then sanded to 4k and buffed

Thank you! Chris

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#2

Re: Critic time, please be honest! 

Chris K in MD

>


img

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#3

What's not to like? Sorry, no pic

RevDoug

>

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#4

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

RevDoug

>Looks like you just beat me in with the pic. I like it a lot. Looks like your curve flattens out on the bottom half of the piece. It's not flat, just isn't as much curve as you have at the top. Really isn't a problem unless you were going for a sphere. Maybe more of a definite change if you weren't going for round. Your colors are great and the finish is fine. You might have used a bit of filler to fill some of the open grain of the Wenge to smooth it out a bit more. Other than that a nice job.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#5

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

Chris K in MD

>I have had a hard time with the finish of wenge, I applied three coats of CA glue and they continued to pop through. The first two took out alot of them but the third did about nothing. Thank you for the comments!

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#6

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

Chris K in MD

>I should have noted that I tried the spere shape but it didnt look right so I went with more of a taper to have the bottom a little smaller for a "lift".

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#7

JL

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

JL

>I'm with RevDoug on the wenge. You need a lot of filler for it. To give you an honest criticism (seeing how you asked for it) - the gloss is a bit too much. You need a really smooth surface to pull off a glossy finish. The open "holes" on the wenge mean you won't have a really smooth surface. I find the holes a distracting focal point. Perhaps a less glossy finish? My $0.02.

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#8

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

Rick Allen

>Hi Chris

Looks like a nice bowl, pot, whatever. The bead detail at the rim is nice. Because everything is balanced a balance of that bead would also be nice.

If you want room to grow, how about putting your features in at an angle. Not a big angle, perhaps just 15 or 20 degrees. Perhaps the top features at an oposite angle from the bottom. There are loads of posiblities with this. Try simple changes each time, adding a little to the next and the next.

Good luck

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Chris, here is my opinion, for what it's worth....The foot and the rim are almost the same size, and the largest diameter of the turning is right on center. This makes for a visually uninteresting form. Either raise or lower this point, this will visually improve the balance of the piece.

The large base causes the sides to come to an abrupt halt, right at the surface it sits on. By curving the base in, two things will happen. The angle that the turning approaches the table will change, adding needed lift. You will create a contrast in size between the opening and the foot size.

The viewer's eye will notice the contrast between the size of the base and the size of the opening. This, coupled with the improved balance, will produce a dynamic quality in the piece.

These comments are not intended to take away from what you've turned, which is very well done, but are intended to help kick things up a notch.

If you google "art, design or visual thinking" you will find some interesting sites on the topic. I hope this helps. Keith

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

#10

Re: Critic time, please be honest!

Chris K in MD

>Thank you all for your comments, they are helpful.

I have some questions based on your feedback.

JL,

I used three coats of CA glue and the hole syou see kept coming through, what is your advice?

Rick,

I dont undestand what you mean by features on an angle. Can you describe this?

Kieth,

What is a good contrast to shoot for between the opening and the base?

I will do a search like you reccomended, I think it will help me alot.

Thank you all again for your comments

Regards,

Chris