Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Sycamore Pentagon dish

Posts

Sycamore Pentagon dish

#1

Sycamore Pentagon dish

Colin Spencer

>I have made this dish / shallow bowl as a concept piece. I have made and seen both 3 and four sided dishes but never a five sided one.

This is made from an offcut of sycamore. It is 5" in diameter 1" deep with a wall thickness of 3/32" As can be seen it has a small foot, looking at the photos this should have been smaller? It is finished with sanding sealer and Renaisance wax and then buffed. It was turned without sacrificial pieces.

Comments wanted both good and bad. Is this something worthy of further exploration with more attractive woods?


img

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

#2

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

adrien

>very nice. what a knuckle buster!

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

#3

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I like the 5 sides, something different. Yes, I'd like the base much smaller.

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

#4

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

RevDoug

>Colin,

I'm not sure that making the foot smaller is the issue here. To my eye you've done a great job with this piece. The 5 sides are tremendous. The only issue that I have is with the straight sides. My eye can't decide whether this is a plate or a bowl. If the sides had more of a curve going into the foot I think that it would give a sense of stability and a nice shadow line that would give lift to this piece. But, like I said before, this is a very pretty piece. Looks like the sanding and finish is very well done. Thanks for sharing.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

#5

Re: Sycamore Pentagon dish

Dick Anderson

>Hi Colin:

Absolutely worthy of further exploration. And this is a great start. Some ideas you might want to consider. 1)Smaller foot with more bowl shape rounding. 2)Ogee shape on the bowl. 3) After turning basic shape then carve into the pentagon sides to form a star. 4) Pentagon wings with a bowl on the inside (eg a bowl within a bowl). 5) Sweep the points upward and inward like flower betals. 6) Use the shape you have started with to experiment with carving, burning, coloring texturing in the areas of the points.

There are many, many more possibilities that you or someone else could conjure up that would be different, interesting and unique.

Good Luck. I hope you will explore this further and post your results, for they will be very interestng to all of us.