Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

Posts

AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

#1

AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

Lou Krupnick

>For the past year, I've been enjoying this message board as I ever so slowly learn to use the tools, sharpen them & push the knowledge base beginner mistakes. Now, as skills are slowly improving & I'm no longer content w/ form studies & ready to actually save some of which I make. Problem is, even after trying alcohol drying, the rough turned bowls still seem to warp. Am I turning them too thin, or is this to be expected? If so, any recommendations on truing them up??

Also, was given access to a fresh cut woodpile in Silver Spring, MD this weekend. Need wood??

Lou in MD

Re: AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

#2

Re: AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing

JKJ in East TN

>>Problem is, even after trying alcohol drying,

>the rough turned bowls still seem to warp.

The rough turned bowl will warp regardless of the drying method. This is due to the way wood shrinks more in one direction than another. The various drying methods (alcohol, coating with wax, placing in paper bags, boiling, kilns, microwave oven, etc) seek to minimize destructive cracking and/or decrease drying time. If you want a round bowl, rough it out with a thick wall, dry by some means, then turn again to final thickness, removing the warp.

The roughing thickness depends on the type of wood and the size and geometry of the piece. A very large bowl will need to be roughed thicker than a smaller bowl of the same wood since it will warp more. A bowl roughed from a wood that with a higher tangential/radial shrinkage ratio will need to be thicker than one made from another type of wood. A blank that is very green may need thicker roughed walls than one partially dried.

I personally have had good luck with roughing then simply coating the bowl with anchorseal and waiting until dry (perhaps 3-6 months). According to those with more experience with dense tropical woods, some need to be boiled. Many people report good results with the alcohol method.

JKJ

Re: AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

#3

What he said.....

Barry Irby

>Most of the drying methods are trying to get the blank dry more quickly than just letting it air dry and hopefully with the same amount of or less cracking. We are either looking for speed or fewer losses from cracks or both. As John pointed out, the warping is pretty much a given, but some of us believe we can reduce or manage that to some extent also. We don't really KNOW because this is not a very scientific community or process. Few if any of us have set up controlled studies that would qualify for even a good high school science project. (turn fifty or five hundred bowls from Identical blanks and dry then five different ways and leave an equal number to dry in air. Can't happen. No one has fifty identical blanks or the patience to do all that. So we are telling you what SEEMS to work for us in our climates and the way we do it. You might find something better.

You can turn bowls from green to finish in one session and let them warp and use them that way. I like them and so do some others. Some woods work beautifully for that and some don't.

I have good luck turning blanks with the 1 to 10 rule. 1" of thickness at the rim for each inch of diameter. IE, a ten inch diameter blank would be one inch thick at the rim. Some people try to make the whole blank one inch thick, very accurately. I find the bottom can be thinner, maybe 3/4"

I usually leave the chuck foot on my blanks and true it up later. Others think the chuck foot is where the cracking starts due to stresses from the change in thickness and they cut it off the blank, going for the perfect hemisphere shape. They use the excess thickness at the bottom to cut another chuck foot.

As they, its only wood and it grows on trees. Take a whack at whatever methods appeal to you.

The blanks usually become oval. Carefully remount them, so that the two long points are equal distance from the center line and so are the two short points. Then when you true up the blank, you will be removing the two long area on the exterior and the short points from the interior. Put the blank on the lathe and lock your tool rest in front of the bowl. Hold a pencil on the rest and turn the blank by hand. Start at the narrow point on the outside and see if you can draw a circle on what will be the top of the rim all the way around. Then move to the inside of the long points and see if you can draw a concentric circle all the way around. Hopefully you can and they are about a half inch or more apart. That's you maximum bowl. Some of them warp so badly you can do this. You should have dried it better or cut a thicker blank. The rule about 1 to 10 applies to straight grained blanks. The wild ones may require more thickness.

Re: AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

#4

Ahaa!!

Lou Krupnick

>Ahaa! so once again my expectations exceeded the reality of the situation,....Thanks so much!

Lou

Re: AL Drying, Cracks & Warpage- what am I missing?

#5

Contact me perhaps I can help. *LINK*

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Stephen,

I don't have all the answers but I have had very good luck with many different types of wood. If you haven't read the article on Wood Central you can find a link to it on my web site home page. Also, there is more information on an alcohol soaking blog I have started. The blog link can be found in the upper left corner of my home page.

It would be wonderful to do a formal experiment but the financial pay back would not warrant the time and expense of such an endeavor.

Good luck.

Dave Smith

Head wood pickler in Longview, WA.


Wood n Heart