Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Posts

Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#1

Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The occasional small catch when turning bowls is inevitable, and usually causes no real problem. It's those big bowl-busting catches that are the bane of many turners. They may damage or even break a piece, and they can cause possible injuries. Because I've been teaching classes for so many years, I think that I've seen just about every kind of catch that it's possible to have.

Why do the serious catches happen? There are many ways that a catch can happen, but nearly always it's because of the way the tool was being handled. A large catch is frequently a result of losing control of the tool when a small catch occurs. Any scraping tool, including hand-held hollowing tools, should be held with the handle under the forearm for support. Whenever possible, when using a scraper or a hollowing tool or a bowl gouge, the tool should be tucked in against your side. Move your body to move the tool. The larger muscles in your body do a much better job of controlling the tool than the smaller muscles.

A few things that you should know to prevent serious catches:

When using scrapers the handle should be tipped up a little, so that the butt end is a bit higher than the blade. Shear scraping is an exception....

When scraping on the outside of a bowl, cut below the centerline....

When scraping on the inside of a bowl, cut a little above the centerline....

Catches can occur when a tool is deep inside a hollow vessel, and the cutting edge crosses over the center at the bottom. In effect, the rotating wood is then coming up on the tool instead of down. This lifts the tool, then slams it back down on the tool rest. The result is often a broken rim, and sometimes a sore arm....

Using a scraper near the rim of a thin-walled bowl almost guarantees a catch....

Catches when using a bowl gouge, usually occur when the bevel gets away from the wood. An unsupported cutting edge will dig in.

Allowing the hollowing tool to rub on the rim of a hollow vessel is a sure way to break the rim if a catch occurs....

Many of today's newer lathes are designed with the bowl turner in mind. Shortbed lathes, and rotating and sliding headstocks allow the turner to stand facing the piece when hollowing. This makes it easier to maintain control of the tools, especially when turning hollow vessels.

Wally

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#2

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Halsey

>Thanks Wally,I aways enjoy learning from you.Halsey

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#3

Thank you, Wally!

Carole Valentine

>Excellent list! Now if you had posted this list a year ago, it might have saved me some aggravation. Instead I had to spend months figuring it out the hard way. ;))

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Brad Vietje

>Great tip's, Wally, especially for the beginners. I'd also add that when trying a new cut, or a new tool grind, its a good idea to try it in slo-motion, turning the lathe by hand. In addition to helping avoid catches and allow fluid body motions, turning off the end of the lathe is also a lot better than leaning over the bed all day -- much easier on the back !

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#5

one you missed...

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>A lapse of attention is one more. Twice now, I�ve had serious catches during a pause in turning. The last one happened when I was adjusting my Trend Power Shield. I thought that my gouge was well clear of the inside of the bowl I was turning but I was wrong. While I was adjusting my visor my gouge made uncontrolled contact with the inside of the bowl. Of course that led to a catch with the gouge slamming down on the tool rest I lost at least an inch from the edge of the bowl I was turning. I would have lost more but I glued a chunk of the rim back in. I hope that I�ve learned my lesson. I don�t look forward to careless mistake number three. Some of us have steeper learning curves than others.

Tom

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#6

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Bill Neddow

>Excellent summary Wally. I think we should all print it off and tack it up where we can see it daily. And I mean old-time turners as well. When you get over-confident, you break one of these cardinal rules and ... BANG.

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#7

Lists...

Walt Drummond, Middlesex, NJ

>Yeah, but Carole, you will never forget the things you learned the "hard way".

Wally's list is great, but until you've experienced them, it would be "now, where did I put that list someone wrote about what to do or not to do??"

Over the last 67 years, I've made and lost so many lists. I even lost the list of all the lists... :)

Lessons learned are better than lessons read about.

Walt (now where did I put that note...)

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#8

Re: Lists...

Stuart Johnson

>"Lessons learned are better than lessons read about."

says the guy that just had to pee on the electric fence himself :)

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#9

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

John Veerkamp

>Thanks for the warnings Wally.

John

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#10

LOL!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Keith Tompkins

>How 'bout attempting that last cut on a thin walled bowl. The one you know you really shouldn't attempt. Without any support of wood beneath the rim, the cut causes the rim to vibrate. The smallest catch results in an exploded bowl.

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#12

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

George Van in WI

>Thanks Wally,

I have been roughing a lot of forms to keep the wood from going to waste and practice. I have the problem you refer to, thepip in bottom of the form. I have been trying John Jorden's tip of coming to center from below the pip but have a hard time removing it smoothly. Is this because of green wood or my bad technique. I am using the Don Pencil Scorpion with the straight pin tip.

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#13

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

George Van in WI

>Above should read Stinger, got the names confused.

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#14

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You have the right idea George, but it'll work better with a curved scraper attached to the tool instead of a 3/16 in. cutter.

Wally

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

#15

Re: Serious, Bowl-Busting Catches.....

George Van in WI

>Thanks Wally, I will use that next time.