Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Flattening a warped platter

Posts

Flattening a warped platter

#1

Steven Antonucci

Flattening a warped platter

steve antonucci

>I turned a 14" cherry platter the other day. It had been cut over the summer and Anchorsealed, so it wasn't "that wet", but it's still gone wavy on me...

Has anyone tried to make a flattening frame to remove wavies from a platter? Did it work or just bust the platter? It's still moving, and feels pretty flexible. I'd rather it was a platter than a potato chip...

Steve

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#2

Steven Antonucci

The answer: Cracked under weight of jig...

steve antonucci

>didn't even apply the screws...

I'll be filling it with epoxy and spending lots of time sanding epoxy into bead shapes...

I probably needed to put this in the frame the second it came off the lathe to restrict movement. Any ideas whether that would have caused the crack anyway?

Steve

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#3

Re: The answer: Cracked under weight of jig...

Jorge Castaneda

>Steve,

I am new at turning cherry, so far I have a 50% failure, maybe it is a bad batch, they just crack on me, specially the bigger ones; have you tried the tequila or vodka method? maybe that could be a way out

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#4

Tanqueray works best for me Jorge!

Gerry Meekins in Maryland

>

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#5

Re: Flattening a warped platter

RussFairfield

>"Not that wet" isn't close enough. Cherry and Maple platters move around enough just from atmospheric moisture and temperature changes without making it any worse by using wood that wasn't at equilibrium when it is turned and finished.

I have a couple of Cherry platters that are flat for about 3 weeks out of every year when they have returned to the same equilibrium moisture as when they were turned and finished. The rest of the year they look like a potato chip. But, that's Cherry, and nobody knows the difference when they have some fruit in them.

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#6

Steven Antonucci

Rephrasing my question:

steve antonucci

>Can the internal stresses in a platter be relieved gradually in a drying frame after final turing, or will the frame cause the wood to crack, or will it just potato chip when I remove it?

Horse is out of the barn on this one. I'm just trying to learn from my mistakes, of which wavy potato chip platters seem to be one...

Steve

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#7

Re: Rephrasing my question:

RussFairfield

>I think I have tried everything possible. Some will stay flat without cracking when placed under pressure, and some won't. Some will stay flat after they have been removed from the restraint, and some won't. And, some will lift 4 concrete blocks as they warp into whatever shape they want. My problem has always been trying to outguess the wood, and always getting it wrong. So, I try to get the wood as close as possible to equilibrium moisture before turning a platter, and then letting it do wherever it wants because that is what it is going to do anyway.

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#8

Steven Antonucci

Kind of what I figured...

steve antonucci

>It's frustrating to know that I just need to wait longer, but I'd rather do this than have the wood tear itself apart without me getting a chance to turn it at all...

Next time, I'll try a drying frame- I've got some Spalted Maple platter stock from a tree that was dead at least 10 years... 20"x 2", guessing about 20% EMC...

Thanks

Steve

Re: Flattening a warped platter

#9

Re: Kind of what I figured...(pretty doggone long)

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Steve,

A couple of thoughts. I had good luck flattening a platter that I turned from green Camphor. I was talking to one of the pro's (Al Caton) this weekend about the behavior of Camphor and he tells me that it tends to develop small cracks in the endgrain that are relatively shallow. He also says that you can let it set for years and that is all the cracking that will occur. I picked up a couple of pieces of 2-year old camphor this weekend and I can say from my limited observation, that he is correct.

I know from experience that cherry cracks tend to be large and deep. I have seen cherry logs that were cracked 3 or 4" outward from the pith after laying a couple of years. In the middle of a 10' log! This leads me to believe that Camphor is much more resistant to drying stresses than Cherry.

But, how does this help you? I think the only way to be succesful with drying cherry under pressure would be to get it into your drying press while it is still as wet as possible, as you suggested. If it starts to dry out at all, then you are trying to manipulate dry, shrunken cells, which will reduce the odds of a successful result.

You also need to be careful about the drying conditions if you get it into the drying rack without a crack. The lower the relative humidity, the greater the shock for the wood cells. As wood dries, though, it gets stronger and can resist more drying stress. The trick is to keep it in relatively high humidity and low temperature initially, with just enough ventilation to prevent the growth of molds. I have an unheated shop next to a creek, so I kept my Camphor platter out there for about 6 weeks in the early summer before I brought it into the house. I haven't seen more than 1/8" of movement in the several months that we've had it in the house.

Sorry for the ramble,

Gary