Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Need opinions/votes

Posts

Need opinions/votes

#1

Need opinions/votes

David Breth

>I'm working on a cucumber wood bowl, that started life as a beam in a very old structure. I wanted to retain some of the hand-hewn features, so I left two sides flat, and the bottom has a recess, but other than that, shows that original work. I've stopped work temporarily because I need to make a couple of decisions.

My questions are:

1) In sanding, how far do I take this? The wood is soft, I can sand it to a very high level, but if I do, I think it might look out of place with the hand hewn areas. I'm thinking I should stop at 220-ish or maybe even less to make it look finished but not out of place.

2) In finishing, my plan had been to use my stand by minwax antique oil finish, which I know by about the third application will render the ca glue marks invisible (currently very visible in pic), BUT, that stuff needs to be buffed out when it is sticky, and I can't really wipe it off of the hand hewn areas without leaving near-permanent sticky areas. If you have suggestions that don't involve sprayguns, I'm interested.....

3) If you have any other suggestions for this one, please let me know.

Thanks -

David B.


img

Re: Need opinions/votes

#2

Re: Need opinions/votes

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I don't think I'd sand at all. I'd maybe even add some tool marks with a carving gouge, or a couple of random scorch marks and make it look primitive. No buffing for me either, maybe Mike Mahoney's Walnut Oil, followed by his oil wax finish if you wish.

Re: Need opinions/votes

#3

Re: Need opinions/votes

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I would sand it to 320 or 400. Then steel wool after the finish to make a very matt finish. Try different ways on scrap first.

Re: Need opinions/votes

#4

Re: Need opinions/votes

Tom in Red Deer

>Hi David

My vote would be for some kind of oil finish (Tung maybe) and sand only to 220 or so. An oil would let you hand buff the round parts and only protect the natural parts. It should also hide the ca marks. The oil would take a bit longer but the age of the wood might warrant the time spent.

Just my .01 worth.

Tom

Re: Need opinions/votes

#5

Re: Need opinions/votes

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>I'm going to piggy back onto TEK's remarks. If you have enough material for more than one 'bowl' suggest you sand one to 180/220 range and put your choice of finish on it. Do another one as Tom suggests only use a mix of beeswax/mineral oil. Just wipe it on, let it soak, wipe it off. Gives a very nice soft finish. There is no 'build' with this finish so no shiny spots. Try some on a scrap piece.

The beeswax finish is mostly a make your own with 1 part beeswax, melted in the 'wave and 4 parts mineral from the grocery store. Pour it into a jelly jar with a lid and let it set up. Looks like a soft clear shoe polish. Apply with a scrap of soft cloth and wipe off - buff with an old dish/bath towel. Wonderful stuff for salad bowls by the way.

Re: Need opinions/votes

#6

Re: Need opinions/votes

John Lucas

>I'm going to go different than the others. I like the contrast between highly sanded areas and bark or rough areas. I seldom sand bowls very far but I would sand this to 400 and then use a finish that won't get too glossy. I like the natural wood finish on bowl like that so whatever finish you use if you knock it down with something like 4/0 wool. I wouldn't use steel wool because it can get wire stuck in the rough areas. I would use one of the plastic steel wool substitues.

Re: Need opinions/votes

#7

Re: Need opinions/votes

David Breth

>Thank you for all the suggestions. I'll have to weigh this a bit more before I do it. Good news is I do have multiple pieces to try, but probably all of them will require glueing like you saw in the pictures. When I turned this one, the piece started to go out of round on me as material was removed, I'm sure becuase of the cracks and because of weight imbalances given that I left some rough parts.

I don't think I will add primitive features. The suggestion is interesting, but I just know that I would end up doing it in such a way that it would look contrived, and it would bug me if nobody else. I am leaning toward an oil finish, because it will lend protection to the hand hewn areas, but I'm a little concerned about that only because the stuff gets sticky. I don't think I will use steel wool, because there is little doubt it will get caught on the edges. I think universally you are suggesting that I not see how much of a sheen I can get with this, and I tend to agree with that thinking. It would look pretty terrible I think, if the bowl part was lacquered (for example), and the rest was rustic.

Thanks again -

David B.