Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

McNaughton coring questions.

Posts

McNaughton coring questions.

#1

McNaughton coring questions.

Barry Irby

>I have a slightly older McNaughton coring system. The medium sized set with three curved knives and a straight knife. My set came with the older straight across the end grind. I posted here about not being happy with the shape of the knives. They are not a consistent curve and as such you have to wallow out the path for them. I sent them back to the Rep and he resharpened them with the newer V shaped grind. He asked me if that were OK, and I said it was, after all, he is the factory Rep. He insists the knives are bent the same way they bend them all.

I am still not happy, They are worse than before. By regrinding them, he narrowed the "kerf" and they seem to bind more than before. The thinner cut seems to aggravate the problems with the curvature. Is there a good video on these things, or am I just having problems with my expectations?

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#2

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

Russell Babbitt Jr.

>Try this link to Craft Supplies. Mike Mahoney on the Mcnaughton

I used my Mcnaughton for the first time today. Worked ok. I need more practice to conserve more wood the next time.

http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/cgi-bin/shopper?preadd=action&key=341-0010

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#3

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

GeeSeaWhy

>The Chesapeake Woodturners had a good article on a class by Margaret Lospinuso, in their April 2002 newsletter. Google "Margaret Lospinuso" and you should find A Cure for Coring. I get 404 errors on the original newsletter but Google still has it cached as HTML - a bit hard to read and missing the illustrations but still helpful. Maybe a member of the Chesapeake club could send you a copy of the original.

Coring systems are not easy to use - keep practising. Core everything over 6" diameter, even if you throw away the core.

HTH,

Graeme

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#4

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

George Van in WI

>Barry, one thing I noticed when I core is if I pull on the handle rather than push the tip even a little bit the tip will cut outward about midway through the blank, then when the knife is trying to cut to the bottom on the end grain the center of the curve of the blade is rubbing on a hump created on the inside core where the blade cut outward. When this happens I can see resin on the blade on the inside caused from friction and the chute to eject chips is also plugged so the drag multiplies. I restart my cut against the inside core and remove the hump, then continue coring to separation. This may not be useful in your situation but I thought it was worth mentioning.

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#5

Brad Vietje

Mahoney video

Brad Vietje

>I agree -- get the Mahoney video and practice. I'd suggest using the straight knife only for a while, and get used to how big a kerf to leave, etc... then move the the knife with the slightest curve. The sharper the curve, the harder to use, so work your way up to that.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#6

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

adrien

>one way has some videos of their corer. no charge to download. quite helpful

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#7

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

Jorge Castaneda

>Barry,

I have a set with the new cutter profile, same as the old it works best when positioned exactly on the centerline and it does not need force to feed it, I witness Bill Grumbine coring with one finger!, it helps to widen the first inch or two.

Mis dos centavos

Jorge

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#8

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

Don Tewell

>Yeah, but Bills' one finger is larger and stronger than most of our arms!

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#9

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

Greg Jensen

>Barry,

If you are unhappy all you have to do is send them back to me and I will replace the blades with ones that are ground with the old style grind.

I thought I made this clear.

Greg Jensen

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#10

Re: Glad you showed up, Greg.

Al Crandall (NE of Indy)

>I recently did a search, without any luck, to find a picture of the new grind for the tips. I'm not at all unhappy with the old grind, but I figure there must be a reason for the new grind so I'm jumping on the band wagon. Can you tell me how to grind them, or point me to a picture? Thanks.

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#11

Re: Glad you showed up, Greg.

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Looking at mine and measuring, they are ground to a point at 45deg.on each side. Therefore, the angle of the tip is 90 deg. Hope that makes sense.

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#12

Re: Glad you showed up, Greg.

George Van in WI

>Al, I was told that the new grind will help prevent fiber break-out when the two cores seperate at the base because the cut is centered and therefore conical in both directions rather than in just one, leaving both cores supported at seperation.

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#13

Re: Thanks Gary and George. I understand.

Al Crandall (NE of Indy)

>

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

#14

Re: McNaughton coring questions.

Barry Irby

>I have just ordered Mahoney's video on the system. Perhaps I am have trouble with Operator Error. I have also been asked to Demo this system at my turning club in February. I volunteered to do this, based on the idea that it would force me to learn how. Writers either write about things they know or want to know. I am going to demo something I want to know. Hope no one is killed.

I am really struggling with these knives. It is clear to me that they are not bent in a circle and do not follow a circular path as they cut. Some are better than others, but some of them are bent correctly for part of their length and then straighten out. The knife starts to translate at that point.

I will watch the video and see what I am doing wrong. Thanks for your offer to replace the blades. I May take you up on it, but for now I need to hang onto the blades to have them for the demo.